Human Generated Data

Title

Detail from "1978-2000"

Date

1978-2000, printed 2003

People

Artist: Robert Gober, American born 1954

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Schneider/Erdman Printer's Proof Collection, partial gift, and partial purchase through the Margaret Fisher Fund, 2011.202.11

Copyright

© Robert Gober

Human Generated Data

Title

Detail from "1978-2000"

People

Artist: Robert Gober, American born 1954

Date

1978-2000, printed 2003

Classification

Photographs

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2019-04-06

Soil 99
Newspaper 98.6
Text 98.6
Ground 96.5
Person 94.3
Human 94.3
Rock 87.3
Road 81.2
Gravel 81.2
Dirt Road 81.2
Outdoors 69.1
Animal 67.9
Bird 67.9
Nature 65.6
Grassland 58.3
Field 58.3
Archaeology 57.6
Page 56

Clarifai
created on 2018-03-23

people 97.9
adult 95.3
one 94.4
monochrome 90.4
no person 87.6
man 87.1
outdoors 85.7
street 85.7
desktop 85.1
war 84.8
two 83.6
cemetery 83.2
stone 80.7
old 78.5
portrait 78
dirty 76.2
ground 76.1
group 75.2
sand 73.6
ball-shaped 73.6

Imagga
created on 2018-03-23

memorial 79.9
structure 58.3
brass 52.6
stone 46.2
texture 45.9
gravestone 45.1
old 43.2
grunge 36.6
wall 34.2
textured 31.6
rough 29.2
surface 27.4
material 26.8
antique 26
pattern 25.3
vintage 24.8
aged 24.4
retro 23.8
grungy 23.7
dirty 22.6
ancient 19.9
newspaper 19.2
design 18.6
brown 18.4
weathered 18.1
mosaic 17.9
detail 17.7
wallpaper 16.1
color 15.6
paint 15.4
art 14.7
stained 14.4
damaged 14.3
rusty 14.3
paper 14.1
transducer 14
jigsaw puzzle 13.8
close 13.7
aging 13.4
frame 13.3
canvas 13.3
product 13.2
backdrop 13.2
construction 12.8
closeup 12.8
messy 12.6
worn 12.4
backgrounds 12.2
rock 12.2
brick 11.3
blank 11.1
puzzle 11
architecture 10.9
history 10.7
creation 10.6
cemetery 10.6
concrete 10.5
electrical device 10.5
border 10
gray 9.9
urban 9.6
text 9.6
page 9.3
cracked 8.8
cement 8.8
building 8.7
rust 8.7
obsolete 8.6
dirt 8.6
black 8.4
decorative 8.4
exterior 8.3
crack 7.8
torn 7.7
stain 7.7
parchment 7.7
game 7.6
style 7.4
decoration 7.4
book 7.3
effect 7.3
yellow 7.3

Google
created on 2018-03-23

Microsoft
created on 2018-03-23

outdoor 91.8
black 66.4
old 43.9

Face analysis

Amazon

Microsoft

Google

AWS Rekognition

Age 26-43
Gender Male, 99.6%
Happy 0.8%
Confused 13.2%
Calm 7.4%
Sad 15.6%
Angry 4.5%
Disgusted 1.5%
Surprised 57%

AWS Rekognition

Age 26-43
Gender Male, 78.3%
Calm 16.9%
Angry 8.7%
Surprised 3.5%
Sad 56.6%
Confused 4.8%
Happy 8.3%
Disgusted 1.2%

Microsoft Cognitive Services

Age 41
Gender Male

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person 94.3%
Bird 67.9%

Captions

Microsoft

a black sign with white text 53.9%
a black sign with white letters 50.7%
a black and white photo of a person 44.9%

Text analysis

Amazon

Saying
Killing
Made
He
Sexual
to
Man,
a
ss to Killing Man, Saying He Made a Sexual Advdt
FRIDAY
for
that
years
ss
deputy
FRIDAY MARCH 5. 1999
1999
his
deputy in
in
Mullins
MARCH 5.
Advdt

Google

FRIDAY, MARCH 5, 1999 s to Killing Man, Saying He Made a Sexual Adv Gaithèr approached theem in a seual year-oid gay college si W'yo, who wa authorities this ime, a man to death states in his confession that that after he left a bar and le month and made hina upset, that be didn't like it have been charged because the because G ard's murder made a homo Depty Bradley said that Mr. Mul- What's becoming v lins caled Mr. Gaither at home on that hate in this count ifs deputy in the night of the kiling and thai lethal with alarming nurnl area be Gaither then drove to peck up Mr said David M Smith, a and Montgom Mullins and Mr. Butler at their for the Human Rights c e two guen had homes. They drove to a reservoir gay and lesbian politic after waiving outside Sylacauga, where the two Washington and were then men beat Mr. Gaither and placed 19 murder of him is the trunk of his car, Depaty 9-year-old tex Bradley sald. They then drove the Mr. Gasther had wor years ar a large distrit for the Russell Corporath facturer of sporting appa ander City, Ala. Bobbie co worker, sad Mr. Ga with his parents and wa "He was a real nice, owin hearted," Ms. Story said car to Mr. Muilins's house, picked up of whom are some kerosene, matches and two old County jail in tires, and drove to an isolated area. re Steven Eric Tbe deputy sasd the men lighted s Monroe But. the tires with the kerosene, removed construction Mr. Gaither from the trunk, beat him ga, Ala., Depu in the head with an ax handle and An article today in Butler con then placed his body on the burning Charles Monroe Butler, 21, one of ham News quoted NT two men charged with murder. ther, Marion H Galther that he did wot beleve t He died of severe blunt head tr the Butler maDeputy Bradley said. "Once had been gay and that b
Saying
who
ime,
to
states
made
didn't
been
a
Bradley
v
at
that
kiling
drove
Mr
David
Mullins
had
two
beat
is
the
car,
tex
Mr.
years
and
picked
up
of
whom
some
kerosene,
tires,
re
Steven
Monroe
Gaither
from
Ala.,
An
article
Butler
then
News
wot
died
tr
MARCH
1999
in
college
authorities
this
man
left
bar
upset,
have
because
ard's
Depty
Mul-
thai
nurnl
area
for
guen
politic
placed
9-year-old
They
facturer
City,
Ala.
with
his
owin
Ms.
County
an
Tbe
removed
trunk,
him
quoted
men
charged
murder.
H
did
He
severe
head
said.
gay
5,
Made
Sexual
theem
W'yo,
wa
le
month
be
like
murder
becoming
on
hate
ifs
night
alarming
said
Montgom
Rights
e
reservoir
after
Washington
19
Gasther
large
distrit
sporting
ander
was
real
hearted,"
car
Muilins's
area.
Eric
lighted
s
construction
today
con
Charles
one
NT
he
b
wor
ar
Bobbie
Ga
parents
"He
Story
are
matches
jail
ga,
ax
body
burning
Butler,
ham
ther,
Marion
t
blunt
Killing
Man,
Adv
Gaithèr
approached
seual
it
What's
peck
Sylacauga,
were
trunk
sald.
FRIDAY,
year-oid
si
death
confession
hina
G
homo
lins
caled
home
count
deputy
lethal
M
Smith,
their
Human
c
homes.
lesbian
waiving
outside
where
Depaty
Russell
Corporath
appa
co
worker,
sad
nice,
house,
old
isolated
sasd
But.
tires
Depu
handle
21,
Galther
beleve
maDeputy
"Once