Human Generated Data

Title

Liber Studiorum, Catalogue

Date

19th century

People

Artist: Joseph Mallord William Turner, British 1775 - 1851

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Philip Hofer, M4171-M4241.X

Human Generated Data

Title

Liber Studiorum, Catalogue

People

Artist: Joseph Mallord William Turner, British 1775 - 1851

Date

19th century

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Philip Hofer, M4171-M4241.X

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2021-04-04

Book 100
Page 100
Text 100
Document 60
Menu 55

Clarifai
created on 2021-04-04

no person 98.4
retro 98.2
calligraphy 97.2
antique 97.2
page 97.1
victorian 96
template 95.1
paper 95
stripe 95
booklet 93.6
damask 91.2
vignetting 90.5
vector 89.5
filigree 87.9
ornate 87.9
artistic 86.5
art 86.3
vortex 85.9
elegant 84.7
ancient 84.6

Imagga
created on 2021-04-04

menu 100
fare 100
food 70.5
paper 36.9
old 30.7
page 30.6
text 28.8
book 28.8
antique 23.4
vintage 23.2
blank 20.6
grunge 20.4
document 20.4
texture 19.5
design 16.9
frame 16.7
letter 16.5
ancient 16.4
sheet 15
new 14.6
print 14.2
retro 13.9
wallpaper 13.8
card 13.6
religion 13.5
business 13.4
pattern 13
office 12.9
message 12.8
bible 12.7
aged 12.7
read 12.5
word 12.3
cover 12
note 12
border 11.8
dirty 11.8
open 11.7
backdrop 11.5
religious 11.2
empty 11.2
template 11
prayer 10.6
holy 10.6
textured 10.5
writing 10.4
decoration 10.1
holiday 10
notebook 9.8
pages 9.8
sepia 9.7
parchment 9.6
faith 9.6
god 9.6
artistic 9.6
close 9.1
year 9.1
detail 8.9
symbol 8.8
spiritual 8.6
day 8.6
art 8.5
study 8.4
church 8.3
gold 8.2
object 8.1
journal 8
graphic 8
celebration 8
testament 7.9
words 7.8
season 7.8
drawing 7.7
numbers 7.7
pen 7.6
write 7.5
map 7.5
color 7.2
black 7.2

Google
created on 2021-04-04

Book 90.1
Publication 83.9
Font 83.9
Parallel 70.9
Paper 65.4
Paper product 65.4
Document 63
Event 61.6
Art 56.5
Rectangle 53.9
Letter 53.4

Microsoft
created on 2021-04-04

text 99.6
letter 98.4
handwriting 93.7

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Book
Book 100%

Categories

Imagga

text visuals 99.9%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2021-04-04

text, letter 99.9%

Clarifai
created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-17

a photograph of a book with a picture of a cat on it -100%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-02-13

This is an image of a printed page from a catalogue. At the top, it is titled "CATALOGUE," followed by a note regarding letters on plates and notations in the margin with specific meanings, such as "P." for pastoral, "E." for elegant pastoral, "M. and S." for mountains, "M." for marine, "H." for historical, and "A." for architectural categories.

Below this explanation, there's a heading that reads "THE PUBLISHED PLATES."

Listed items:

  • No. 1 — THE FRONTISPIECE TO LIBER STUDIORUM is mentioned as being most respectfully presented to the Subscribers by J. M. W. Turner, published May 23, 1812. Additionally, it includes a critical note about "The picture in the centre, the Rape of Europa," which was engraved by Turner himself, commenting on the contrast between its beauty and the clumsy frame it is set in.

  • No. 2 — (BRIDGE AND COWS), categorized under "P." for pastoral.

  • No. 3 — (WOMAN WITH TAMBOURINE), also in the pastoral category ("P."), followed by a critique stating that this piece is one of the worst and feeblest studies in the book, with a reference to a quote from "Russell, Modern Painters, Vol. III., p. 324" which, despite its weak artifice, claims the composition is in parts exquisite.

The text at the bottom is cut off at the page edge, and the context for the statement starting with "in spite of its weak artific..." is incomplete.

This page is likely from an art catalogue perhaps from an exhibition or collection of works by the artist J. M. W. Turner or related to his "Liber Studiorum" series. The text is printed cleanly on off-white paper with age discoloration typical of older documents.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-02-13

The image is a scanned page from an old catalogue or book, specifically an index or listing titled "CATALOGUE." It is focused on "THE PUBLISHED PLATES" of a collection known as "Liber Studiorum." The catalogue is introduced with a brief note about the meaning of letters (such as P. for pastoral, M. for mountain, etc.) and explains that the names in the catalogue are taken from the plates as they appear upon them.

Here are specific details listed on the page:

  1. No. 1 – The Frontispiece to Liber Studiorum: This work is noted as "most respectfully presented to the Subscribers by J. M. W. Turner." It was published on May 23, 1812, and includes a description that refers to an engraving by Turner, depicting "the Rape of Europa." Comments on the contrast between beauty and the framework of the picture are included.

  2. Part I – Published January 20, 1807: This section lists two entries:

    • No. 2 – (Bridge and Cows): Marked with the letter P. indicating a pastoral theme.

    • No. 3 – (Woman with Tambourine): Marked with E. P. (likely standing for elegant pastoral). This entry includes a quote from Ruskin's "Modern Painters" complimenting the composition and distinctiveness of the piece.

The entries blend critical and descriptive commentary on the published plates, offering insight into the works of J. M. W. Turner.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2025-02-13

The image appears to be a catalog or publication of some kind, with a table of contents listing various published plates. The first entry describes "THE FRONTISPIECE TO LIBER STUDIORUM" that was published in 1812 and engraved by Turner. The subsequent entries list other published plates, such as "BRIDGE AND COWS" and "WOMAN WITH TAMBOURINE", providing brief descriptions of the content of these plates. The image does not contain any human faces, so I have disregarded the instruction about identifying or naming any individuals in the image.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2025-02-13

The image shows the title page of a catalogue, published on January 20, 1807, titled "THE PUBLISHED PLATES." It contains a brief description stating that the plates in the catalogue were selected from the collection of J. T. Smith, and are intended for display at an architectural exhibition.

Below the description is a list of three published plates:

  1. "THE FRONTISPIECE TO LIBER STUDIORUM", most respectfully presented to the Subscribers by J. M. W. Turner, published May 23, 1812.
  2. "(BRIDGE AND COWS)", no further details provided.
  3. "(WOMAN WITH TAMBOURINE)" by E.P., described as "All the worst and feblest [sic] ideas of the foul mind with the nymph playing the tambourine, that with the long bridge seen through the trees (No. 13) and with the group of beech trees over the foul mind's mean unmanly libellous falsehood of my faculties in Claude."

The page has an aged, yellowed appearance consistent with being from an old document or book.

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2025-02-13

This appears to be a catalogue page, likely from an art publication or book. At the top of the page, there's a heading "CATALOGUE" followed by a note explaining the lettering system used for the plates. Below that is a section titled "THE PUBLISHED PLATES" which lists several entries:

No. 1 is described as "THE FRONTISPIECE TO LIBER STUDIORUM" published May 23, 1812. There's a note about the center picture depicting the Rape of Europa, which was apparently engraved by Turner himself.

Under "PART I — PUBLISHED JANUARY 20 1807" are two more entries:

  • No. 2: "(BRIDGE AND COWS)"
  • No. 3: "(WOMAN WITH TAMBOURINE)" which includes a quote from Ruskin's "Modern Painters, Vol. III, p. 324" discussing the pastoral scene.

The page appears to be printed on cream or beige colored paper and has a formal, academic layout typical of vintage catalogues or scholarly publications.

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-24

This image shows a catalogue page, likely from an art book or collection. At the top, there's a heading simply stating "CATALOGUE" followed by a note explaining the meaning of letters used in the margins. Below that is a section titled "THE PUBLISHED PLATES" which lists three entries:

  1. The frontispiece to Liber Studiorum, published May 23, 1812, which includes a note about Turner's engraving of the Rape of Europa.

  2. A piece titled "Bridge and Cows"

  3. A piece called "Woman with Tambourine" with an accompanying critical note about its pastoral elements and composition.

The page appears to be from an older publication, printed on cream-colored paper with traditional typography. The text includes both descriptive entries and scholarly commentary about the artworks being catalogued. Part I is noted as being published January 20, 1807.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-16

The image shows a page from an old book or catalog, with the title "CATALOGUE" at the top. The page is open to a section that appears to be a table of contents or index, listing various entries and their corresponding page numbers.

  • Title
    • The title "CATALOGUE" is written in large, bold font at the top of the page.
    • Below the title, there is a subtitle that reads "THE PUBLISHED PLATES."
  • Entries
    • The page lists several entries, each with a brief description and a page number.
    • The entries are numbered, starting from 1 and increasing consecutively.
    • The descriptions are brief and appear to be summaries of the content on the corresponding pages.
  • Page Numbers
    • Each entry includes a page number, which indicates where the reader can find the corresponding content.
    • The page numbers are listed in a column to the right of the descriptions.
  • Layout
    • The page is divided into two columns, with the descriptions and page numbers arranged in a neat and organized manner.
    • The text is printed in a clear, readable font, making it easy for the reader to navigate the page.

Overall, the image suggests that the book or catalog is a comprehensive guide to a particular subject or collection, with the entries providing a brief overview of the content on each page.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-16

The image depicts an open book with the title "CATALOGUE" prominently displayed at the top of the page. The text is presented in a serif font, with the title in a larger size and centered on the page. Below the title, there are two bullet points that provide information about the letters used in the catalogue.

The main body of the text is divided into sections, each with a heading that describes the content of the section. The headings are in a smaller font size than the title but larger than the body text. The body text is written in a clear and concise manner, making it easy to read and understand.

The background of the page is a light beige color, which provides a clean and neutral backdrop for the text. The overall design of the page is simple yet effective, allowing the reader to focus on the content without distraction. The image appears to be a scan or photograph of an old book, with some signs of aging such as yellowing of the paper and slight wear on the edges.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-02-13

The image shows an open book with a page that reads "CATALOGUE" at the top. Below the title, there is a section titled "THE PUBLISHED PLATES" with three numbered plates listed. The first plate is described as "THE FRONTISPIECE TO LIBER STUDIORUM is most respectfully presented to the Subscribers by F. M. W. Turner. Published May 23, 1812." The second plate is described as "BRIDGE AND COWS," and the third plate is described as "WOMAN WITH TAMBOURINE." The text also includes a reference to "E. P." and a quote from Ruskin's "Modern Painters." The book appears to be a catalogue of published plates, possibly related to art or prints.

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-02-13

The image is a photograph of an open book. The book is titled "CATALOGUE" and is opened to a page that contains text. The page is numbered as page 1. The text on the page is organized into sections. The first section is titled "THE PUBLISHED PLATES" and lists three items: "No. 1.—THE FRONTISPIECE TO LIBER STUDIORUM is most respectfully presented to the Subscribers by F. M. W. Turner. Published May 23, 1812", "No. 2.—(BRIDGE AND COWS)", and "No. 3.—(WOMAN WITH TAMBOURINE)". The second section is titled "PART I—PUBLISHED JANUARY 20, 1807". The text is written in a serif font, and the page has a beige background.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-05-11

Here is a description of the image:

The image shows a page from a catalogue, likely from a book or collection of art prints. The page is cream-colored and contains several entries that describe "The Published Plates."

The first entry, numbered "No. 1," is titled "THE FRONTISPIECE TO LIBER STUDIORUM." It is presented to the subscribers by J.M.W. Turner and was published on May 23, 1812. The description mentions that the picture in the center, "the Rape of Europa," was engraved by Turner himself, noting the contrast between its beauty and the framework around it.

A "PART I" designation indicates that the following plates were published on January 20, 1807.

The subsequent entries include:
"No. 2-(BRIDGE AND COWS.)", marked as pastoral (P.)
"No. 3-(WOMAN WITH TAMBOURINE.)", marked as elegant pastoral (E.P.).

A quote from Ruskin's "Modern Painters" is included under the entry for "WOMAN WITH TAMBOURINE," criticizing it as one of the worst studies but acknowledging the composition's exquisiteness in parts.

At the top of the page, there is a title "CATALOGUE," and a note that explains the meaning of certain letters used in the margin of the catalogue to describe the type of plate (e.g. pastoral, elegant pastoral, mountainous, marine, historical, architectural). It also explains the usage of names taken from the plates themselves and the usage of commonly accepted names for plates that have no names on them.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-05-11

This image is a page from a catalogue. The title is "CATALOGUE" in a large font. The image describes a list of published plates, which is numbered 1 to 3. Each plate is described briefly, including the name of the plate, and any additional information about the artist. The first plate includes a reference to the painting "The Rape of Europa". The image also includes references to the painting in terms of "The frame work" and "Its beauty".

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-08

The image is a page from a catalog of published plates. The page provides information about the catalog and lists specific artworks with brief descriptions. Here is a detailed summary:

Title

  • CATALOGUE

Introduction

  • The catalog includes letters at the top of the plates and in the margin. These letters indicate different categories:
    • E. P. (pastoral)
    • E. P. (elegant pastoral)
    • M. and M. S. (mountainous)
    • M. (marine)
    • H. (historical)
    • Arch. (architectural)
  • The names in the catalog are taken from the plates as they appear. For plates without names, a brief description is provided.

The Published Plates

No. 1. – THE FRONTISPIECE TO LIBER STUDORUM

  • Description: Respectfully presented to the Subscribers by J. M. W. Turner.
  • Publication Date: May 23, 1812.
  • Details: The picture in the center, "The Rape of Europa," was engraved by Turner himself. The contrast between its beauty and the clumsy and unmeaning framework in which it is set is striking.

No. 2. – (BRIDGE AND COWS)

  • Publication Date: January 20, 1807.

No. 3. – (WOMAN WITH TAMBOURINE)

  • Category: E. P. (pastoral)
  • Description: All the worst and feeblest studies in the book, such as the peddler with the nymph playing the tambourine, the woman with the tambourine through the trees (No. 13), and the woman with the tambourine on the winding road (No. 43), owe the principal part of their ineffectiveness to Claude. (Reference: Ruskin, Modern Painters, Vol. III, p. 324)
  • Comment: In spite of its weak artificiality, the composition is in part exquisite.

This page from the catalog provides a structured and detailed listing of the published plates, including their categorization, publication dates, and critical commentary.

Text analysis

Amazon

PUBLISHED
STUDIORUM
THE
CATALOGUE.
LIBER
FRONTISPIECE
THE PUBLISHED PLATES.
PLATES.
FRONTISPIECE TO LIBER STUDIORUM is most
TO
most
is
presented
Subscribers
No.
them:
the
plates
No. THE
which
architectural.
For
respectfully
The
letters
pastoral
have
top
by
from
The from the olates thev them: For the plates which
the following
of
respectfully presented the Subscribers by .
printed
mountainous
the Cataloguc. have the following
and
The letters the pastral : top of elegant and pastoral printed in the mountainous marine i H.,
elegant
.
in
olates
the commonly
Cataloguc.
thev
pastral :
commonly
H.,
marine i

Google

CATALOGUE. * The letters at the top of the plates, and printed in the margin of the Catalogue, have the following mean ings :- P., pastral; E P, elegant pastoral ; M. and M. S., mountainous; M., marine; H., historical; A., architectural. The names in the Catalogue anre taken from the plates so far as they appear upon them. For the plates which bear no name the commonly accepted name is given in parentheses THE PUBLISHED PLATES. No. 1.-THE FRONTISPIECE TO LIBER STUDIORUM is mmost respectfully presented to the Subscribers by J. M. W. Turner. Published May 23, 1812. -The picture in the centre, the Rape of Europa, was engraved by Turner himself. The contrast between its beauty and the clumsy and unmeaning framework in which it is set is striking. PART I-PUBLISHED JANUARY 20, 1807. No. 2.-(BRIDGE AND COWS.) P. No. 3.– (WOMAN WITH TAMBOURINE.) * All the worst and feeblest studies in the book, as the pastoral with the nymph playing the tambourine, that with the long bridge seen through the trees (No. 13) and with the flock of goats on the walled road (No. 43),- owe the principal part of their im becilities to Claude."-RUSKIN, Modern Painters, Vol. III. p. 324 In spite of its weak artificiality, the composition is in parts exquisite. E. P.
CATALOGUE.
*
The
letters
at
the
top
of
plates,
and
printed
in
margin
Catalogue,
have
following
mean
ings
:-
P.,
pastral;
E
P,
elegant
pastoral
;
M.
S.,
mountainous;
M.,
marine;
H.,
historical;
A.,
architectural.
names
Catalogue
anre
taken
from
plates
so
far
as
they
appear
upon
them.
For
which
bear
no
name
commonly
accepted
is
given
parentheses
THE
PUBLISHED
PLATES.
No.
1.-THE
FRONTISPIECE
TO
LIBER
STUDIORUM
mmost
respectfully
presented
to
Subscribers
by
J.
W.
Turner.
Published
May
23,
1812.
-The
picture
centre,
Rape
Europa,
was
engraved
Turner
himself.
contrast
between
its
beauty
clumsy
unmeaning
framework
it
set
striking.
PART
I-PUBLISHED
JANUARY
20,
1807.
2.-(BRIDGE
AND
COWS.)
P.
3.–
(WOMAN
WITH
TAMBOURINE.)
All
worst
feeblest
studies
book,
with
nymph
playing
tambourine,
that
long
bridge
seen
through
trees
(No.
13)
flock
goats
on
walled
road
43),-
owe
principal
part
their
im
becilities
Claude."-RUSKIN,
Modern
Painters,
Vol.
III.
p.
324
In
spite
weak
artificiality,
composition
parts
exquisite.
E.