Human Generated Data

Title

Unfinished painting

Date

n.d.

People

Artist: Barnett Newman, American 1905 - 1970

Classification

Paintings

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Straus Center for Conservation and Technical Studies, Gift of the Barnett and Annalee Newman Foundation, 2007.100.76

Copyright

© The Barnett Newman Foundation, New York / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York

Human Generated Data

Title

Unfinished painting

People

Artist: Barnett Newman, American 1905 - 1970

Date

n.d.

Classification

Paintings

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Straus Center for Conservation and Technical Studies, Gift of the Barnett and Annalee Newman Foundation, 2007.100.76

Copyright

© The Barnett Newman Foundation, New York / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2022-05-17

Canvas 88.1
Art 83.8
Advertisement 77.5
Modern Art 76.9
Poster 73
Text 66.7
Collage 65.3
Home Decor 63.6
Paper 63.1

Clarifai
created on 2023-10-14

dirty 99.8
canvas 99.1
old 99
antique 98.9
retro 98.8
wear 98.8
parchment 98.7
paper 98.5
empty 98.3
worn 98.1
art 97.8
rough 97.5
stain 97.2
cardboard 97.1
ancient 96.4
no person 96.4
artistic 96
snap 95.9
painting 95.6
rusty 95.4

Imagga
created on 2022-05-17

binding 74.9
paper 58.1
texture 57.7
vintage 57.1
grunge 57.1
old 54.4
antique 50.3
aged 45.3
retro 39.4
border 38.9
wallpaper 36.8
frame 35.3
empty 35.3
cardboard 28.8
material 28.6
sheet 28.2
parchment 27.9
ancient 27.7
canvas 27.5
blank 26.6
rough 26.5
dirty 26.2
document 26
backgrounds 26
damaged 25.8
aging 25
page 24.2
cover 23.2
envelope 23
binder 22.9
art 22.8
book jacket 22.6
decay 22.2
design 22
text 21.9
covering 21.5
grime 21.5
crumpled 21.4
letter 21.1
rusty 21
grungy 20.9
ragged 20.5
grain 20.3
stains 19.5
container 19.4
structure 19.2
graphic 19
space 18.6
pages 18.6
mottled 18.5
jacket 18.5
old fashioned 18.1
faded 17.5
fracture 17.5
protective covering 17
backdrop 16.5
stained 16.4
spot 16.3
wall 16.3
worn 16.3
textured 15.8
book 15.7
stain 15.4
broad 14.7
brown 14.7
historic 14.7
album 14.6
pattern 14.4
crack 13.6
torn 13.6
notebook 13.6
wrapping 13.3
paint 12.7
tracery 12.7
burnt 12.6
succulent 12.6
shabby 11.8
crease 11.8
card 11.7
scrapbook 11.7
your 11.6
element 11.6
floral 11.1
edge 10.6
obsolete 10.6
weathered 10.5
textures 10.4
greeting 10.2
decorative 10
detailed 9.6
flower 9.2
smudged 8.9
detail 8.9
burned 8.8
surface 8.8
scratch 8.8
messy 8.7
artistic 8.7
age 8.6
leaf 8.6
scratched 7.8
manuscript 7.8
ornament 7.8
memory 7.7
dirt 7.7
style 7.4
note 7.4
decoration 7.2
color 7.2

Google
created on 2022-05-17

Rectangle 90.4
Red 80.2
Material property 80.1
Magenta 78
Tints and shades 77.1
Font 75.7
Art 74.4
Carmine 66.1
Book 64.9
Paper product 64.6
Paper 64.1
Painting 62.8
Symmetry 62.3
Peach 60.8
Pattern 57.2
Illustration 55.5
Coquelicot 54.6
Visual arts 53.4
Book cover 52
Square 50.6

Microsoft
created on 2022-05-17

text 96.8
red 94
abstract 92.3
handwriting 84.5
sign 74.9
white 65.4
rectangle 62.4
maroon 59.6
minimalist 50.5

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Rug

Clarifai

Picture frame

AWS Rekognition

Rug 86.1%

Clarifai

Picture frame 48.8%

Categories

Imagga
created on 2022-05-17

food drinks 39.7%
paintings art 38.9%
interior objects 10.2%
macro flowers 6.3%
text visuals 2.5%
nature landscape 1%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2022-05-17

a sign on the side of a building 67.6%
a sign above a door 60.8%
a sign sitting on the side of a building 51%

Clarifai

No captions written

Salesforce

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-04-28

a photograph of a red and white painting of a square red and black square

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip-2 on 2025-06-27

a red square with black and white stripes

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4 on 2024-11-16

This is an abstract painting or print that features a bold red square with a thick blue vertical stripe on its right-hand side. The blue stripe is right-justified and the entire composition is centered on a canvas that appears raw or unprimed, with the edges of the fabric visible and frayed in some places. There are smudges, drips, and stray marks scattered across the surface, suggesting a hand-crafted process. The bright, flat fields of color and the simplicity of the composition are evocative of modernist or minimalist artwork. The use of primary colors red and blue is striking against the neutral canvas background.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-01-02

This image features a piece of abstract art with a large, uniformly painted red rectangular area dominating the majority of the canvas. The red area has some irregularities, such as small black marks and imperfections scattered across its surface. To the far right of the image, there is a solid black vertical stripe running from the top to the bottom of the red section. Surrounding the red and black areas, there is an unpainted beige margin that reveals the raw edges of the canvas, highlighting its texture and creating a stark contrast with the vivid colors. Some parts of the edge appear frayed and uneven, and there are noticeable drips and smudges, particularly along the bottom edge, where the red paint has bled into the beige canvas. The composition is minimalistic yet striking, characterized by its bold color contrasts and raw, unfinished edges.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2024-12-28

This appears to be a minimalist abstract artwork consisting of a large red rectangular field with a thin vertical black stripe along the right edge. The composition is set against what looks like a cream or off-white background. The red paint application shows some texture and irregularities, particularly along the bottom edge where there appears to be some dripping or bleeding of the red paint. The piece has a stark, bold quality typical of color field painting or minimalist art movements. The contrast between the vibrant red and the deep black stripe creates a strong visual tension in the composition.

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2024-11-14

The image shows a large, solid red rectangle taking up the majority of the frame. The rectangle is bordered by a thin black line on the right side. The background appears to be a textured, off-white or beige surface with some weathering or distress visible around the edges. The overall composition is simple and minimalist, focusing primarily on the bold, vibrant red color.

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-26

This appears to be an abstract or minimalist artwork consisting of a large red rectangular block with a thin vertical black stripe or bar along one edge. The composition is set against what appears to be a white or off-white background. The red paint has a somewhat textured or slightly uneven application, particularly visible along the bottom edge where there appears to be some bleeding or dripping of the paint. The style is reminiscent of color field painting or minimalist art movements from the mid-20th century.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2024-12-25

The image depicts a vibrant red square with a black vertical stripe on the right side, set against a beige background. The red square is surrounded by a beige border, which appears to be torn and frayed at the edges. The overall effect is one of boldness and simplicity, with the bright red color drawing the viewer's attention.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2024-11-22

The image depicts a striking abstract painting, characterized by bold red and black colors. The dominant red hue occupies the majority of the canvas, with a vertical black stripe on the right side. A beige border surrounds the artwork, adding a subtle contrast to the vibrant colors within. The painting's edges appear worn and frayed, suggesting a sense of age and wear. The overall composition is simple yet powerful, with the red and black colors creating a dynamic tension that draws the viewer's eye. The use of bold colors and geometric shapes gives the painting a modern and contemporary feel, while the worn edges add a sense of history and depth.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-01-04

The image is a photograph of a painting. The painting consists of a large red square or rectangle, bordered by a thin black line on the right side and a thin white line on the top. The red area appears to be on a beige background, which is visible around the edges of the red shape. The red color is solid and uniform, with no visible texture or pattern. There are a few small black spots scattered throughout the red area, and some red paint has spilled over the edges of the red shape, creating a slightly uneven border. The overall effect is minimalist and abstract, with a focus on the contrast between the bold red color and the neutral background.

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-01-04

The image features a painting that is composed of a large red square with a black border. The red square is the dominant feature, occupying most of the canvas. The black border is thin and evenly applied around the edges of the red square. The painting appears to be on a white background, which enhances the contrast between the red and black colors. The edges of the canvas are frayed, suggesting that the painting is old or has been handled roughly. The image is cropped closely around the painting, focusing attention on the artwork itself.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-04-26

The image depicts a modern abstract painting with a vibrant, unfinished quality.

The primary element is a large rectangle of bright, saturated red that dominates the canvas. To the right of the red field, a narrow vertical strip of dark blue provides a contrasting element.

The painting is executed on what appears to be an unprimed canvas, and the edges of the canvas are visible, creating a raw, unfinished aesthetic. The canvas extends beyond the colored areas, revealing a neutral or slightly off-white border along the top, left, and bottom edges. This border is frayed and shows signs of dripping paint, suggesting a spontaneous or experimental process.

There are minor imperfections and splatters of paint on the red surface, further contributing to the work's unrefined and expressive nature. The overall impression is that of a minimalist composition with an emphasis on color and texture, conveying a sense of energy and immediacy.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-04-26

Here's a description of the image:

The artwork features a rectangular composition with a prominent red field dominating the center. A vertical strip of dark blue runs along the right side of the red rectangle. The edges of the central red and blue shapes are slightly irregular, suggesting a hand-applied process.

The artwork is set against a creamy, off-white background, which also frames the red and blue sections. The texture of the backing material is visible, and there are small details like drips of the red paint along the bottom edge, emphasizing the artist's process and materials. The top edge also shows a line of what might be stitching or a seam. The overall aesthetic is minimalist and abstract, with a focus on color, shape, and texture.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-04-25

The image depicts an abstract artwork characterized by a large, predominantly red field with a narrow black vertical stripe on the right side. The red area is not uniformly smooth; it has some texture and minor irregularities, which give it a slightly rough appearance. The edges of the red field show signs of paint drips and smudges, particularly along the bottom edge. The artwork is framed by a beige or light brown border, which appears to be the raw edge of the canvas or paper, adding a rustic touch to the piece. The overall composition is simple yet striking, with the contrast between the red and black creating a bold visual impact.

Qwen

Created by Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct on 2025-06-25

The image depicts an abstract artwork with a dominant red square in the center. The red square is framed by a beige border with visible frayed edges, suggesting a handcrafted or natural material like fabric or paper. On the right side of the red square, there is a vertical black rectangle that runs from top to bottom. The edges of the entire composition have some imperfections, with red paint spills and frayed fibers, contributing to a raw, artistic feel. The background is white, which contrasts with the bold colors of the artwork. The overall style is minimalist and geometric, emphasizing the contrast between the solid red and black shapes against the neutral beige border and white background.

Created by Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-72B-Instruct on 2025-06-25

The image is an abstract painting with a predominantly red color field. The red paint appears to be applied in a thick, almost dripping manner, giving it a textured appearance. On the right side of the painting, there is a vertical black stripe that contrasts sharply with the red. The edges of the painting show some wear and fraying, indicating that it might be on a piece of fabric or a similar material. There are also some splatters and drips of paint around the edges, adding to the raw, unpolished look of the artwork. The overall effect is bold and striking, with the red and black colors creating a strong visual impact.