Human Generated Data

Title

Untitled (Singapore or Kyoto, Japan)

Date

March 14, 1960-April 22, 1960

People

Artist: Ben Shahn, American 1898 - 1969

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Bernarda Bryson Shahn, P1970.2448

Copyright

© President and Fellows of Harvard College

Human Generated Data

Title

Untitled (Singapore or Kyoto, Japan)

People

Artist: Ben Shahn, American 1898 - 1969

Date

March 14, 1960-April 22, 1960

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Bernarda Bryson Shahn, P1970.2448

Copyright

© President and Fellows of Harvard College

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2023-10-07

Animal 97.9
Pigeon 84.2
Dove 60.6
Sparrow 55.3

Clarifai
created on 2018-05-10

bird 99.8
sand 98.8
beach 97.9
pigeon 97.7
nature 97.2
animal 96.4
seashore 94
water 94
wildlife 93.8
feather 93.1
desktop 92.4
outdoors 91.5
sea 91.2
no person 91.2
shore 89.6
stone 88.3
beak 87.7
summer 86.7
ground 86.6
ocean 86

Imagga
created on 2023-10-07

quail 83.9
game bird 51.2
beach 46.6
sand 46.3
bird 38.7
water 34.7
dung beetle 34.3
sea 33.6
game 31.6
ocean 30.7
coast 28.7
vacation 26.2
dove 24
landscape 23.1
travel 22.5
summer 21.9
coastline 21.6
shore 21.4
starling 20
tropical 18.7
island 17.4
wave 17.3
outdoor 16.8
holiday 15.8
sky 15.3
relax 15.2
rock 14.8
tranquil 14.5
stone 14.3
scenic 14
sun 13.7
beetle 13.6
wild 13.1
natural 12.7
outdoors 12.7
bay 12.3
paradise 12.3
lake 11.9
seaside 11.6
tourism 11.5
seascape 11.5
relaxation 10.9
walk 10.5
texture 10.4
day 10.2
recreation 9.9
rocks 9.4
waves 9.3
scenery 9
scene 8.7
cloud 8.6
idyllic 8.5
resort 8.4
hot 8.4
leisure 8.3
peaceful 8.2
tourist 8.2
wildlife 8
river 8
footprints 7.9
footprint 7.9
drought 7.9
soil 7.9
clear 7.8
sunny 7.7
pacific 7.7
tree 7.7
wilderness 7.6
desert 7.5
mountains 7.4
environment 7.4
calm 7.3
horizon 7.2
sunset 7.2
sunlight 7.1
surface 7.1
horseshoe crab 7

Google
created on 2018-05-10

Microsoft
created on 2018-05-10

ground 97.7
outdoor 96.5
animal 88.4
gallinaceous bird 66.1
bird 65.5

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Bird

Clarifai

Bird

AWS Rekognition

Bird 97.9%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 97.6%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 97.3%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 96.8%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 96.7%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 96.4%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 96.1%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 96.1%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 96%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 94.9%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 92.2%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 91.5%

AWS Rekognition

Bird 85.9%

Clarifai

Bird 93.9%

Clarifai

Bird 93.3%

Clarifai

Bird 92.5%

Clarifai

Bird 92.3%

Clarifai

Bird 88.8%

Clarifai

Bird 87.2%

Clarifai

Bird 86.6%

Clarifai

Bird 83.2%

Clarifai

Bird 82%

Clarifai

Bird 81.9%

Clarifai

Bird 76.5%

Clarifai

Bird 71.9%

Clarifai

Bird 70.6%

Clarifai

Bird 66.5%

Clarifai

Bird 66.4%

Categories

Imagga
created on 2023-10-07

beaches seaside 98.7%
nature landscape 1.1%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2018-05-10

a bird that is standing in the sand 83%
a duck walking in the sand 82.9%
a bird standing on a beach 78.2%

Clarifai

No captions written

Salesforce

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip-2 on 2025-07-07

pigeons in the park, paris, france, by person

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-04

a photograph of a flock of pigeons are standing in the sand

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-11-20 on 2025-06-08

The black-and-white image features a group of pigeons scattered across an open, textured ground. The surface appears rough and grainy, possibly a concrete or dirt area. The pigeons are casually dispersed, some standing upright while others are resting or pecking at the ground. The composition is simple, highlighting the pigeons in a candid, unposed arrangement.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-08-06 on 2025-06-08

The image is a black and white photograph depicting a flock of pigeons scattered across a rough, textured ground surface. The pigeons are positioned in various poses, some standing and others pecking at the ground, seemingly in search of food. The ground is speckled with small pebbles and debris, adding texture to the scene. There is no distinct background or structures visible, with the focus solely on the pigeons and the ground they occupy. The overall composition suggests a casual, everyday moment of city life where pigeons are commonly found.

Anthropic Claude

Created by anthropic.claude-3-haiku-20240307-v1:0 on 2025-06-12

The image shows a group of pigeons or doves scattered across a sandy or gravelly surface. The birds appear to be resting or foraging on the ground, with some in a more upright posture and others lying down. The image is in black and white, giving it a stark, moody atmosphere. The birds are the focal point, with the plain, textured background providing a simple, minimalist setting for their presence.

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-12

This is a black and white photograph showing several pigeons scattered across what appears to be a concrete or paved surface. The birds are positioned at various angles and distances from each other, creating an interesting composition across the frame. The ground appears to be textured with small stones or gravel, and the contrast between the dark birds and the light-colored ground is quite striking. The image has a documentary or street photography feel to it, capturing these urban birds in their natural environment.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-05-27

The image depicts a black and white photograph of a group of pigeons on the ground. The pigeons are scattered across the image, with some standing upright and others lying down. The ground appears to be made of dirt or sand, with small rocks and pebbles scattered throughout.

The overall atmosphere of the image suggests a daytime setting, possibly in a park or other outdoor area where pigeons are commonly found. The lack of any other objects or people in the image adds to the sense of isolation and simplicity, focusing the viewer's attention on the pigeons themselves.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-05-27

The image depicts a black and white photograph of a group of pigeons on the ground. The pigeons are scattered across the dirt or gravel surface, with some standing upright and others sitting down. The background is a flat, barren landscape with no visible features or objects other than the pigeons and the ground they are standing on.

The overall atmosphere of the image is one of desolation and emptiness, with the pigeons appearing to be the only living creatures in the scene. The black and white color scheme adds to the sense of bleakness and monotony, giving the image a somber and melancholic tone.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-05-27

A black-and-white photograph shows a group of pigeons scattered on the ground. Some are standing, while others are sitting. The pigeons are in different positions, and some are facing different directions. The ground is covered with small stones and appears to be a sandy area. The pigeons are in a natural setting, and the image captures the birds in a moment of rest or contemplation.

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-05-27

The image is a black-and-white photograph of a group of pigeons gathered on the ground. The pigeons are spread out across the scene, with some standing and others sitting. The ground appears to be covered in small stones and dirt, giving it a rough texture. The pigeons vary in size and posture, with some facing different directions. The overall atmosphere of the image is calm and peaceful, with the pigeons seemingly at ease in their surroundings.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-04-30

Certainly! Here's a description of the image:

Overall Impression:

The image is a black and white photograph featuring a group of pigeons on a textured, grainy surface. The scene appears to be outdoors, likely in a park or a public space.

Specific Details:

  • Subjects: A collection of pigeons is the main focus. They are scattered across the surface, in various poses. Some are standing, others are possibly resting, and some might be foraging.
  • Surface: The ground is covered in small particles giving it a rough texture.
  • Composition: The composition is fairly straightforward, with the pigeons distributed throughout the frame.
  • Lighting: The lighting seems to be natural and possibly diffused, creating soft shadows and a muted tonal range due to the black and white format.

Overall Atmosphere:

The photo has a simple, observational quality. It portrays a common scene of pigeons in a public area, captured with a focus on texture and the natural behaviors of the birds.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-04-30

The black-and-white photograph shows a collection of pigeons scattered across a gravelly surface. The pigeons, varying in shades of gray, are dispersed throughout the frame, some standing still and others appearing to be in motion. The rough texture of the ground is visible due to the high contrast and detail captured in the shot. The overall composition is simple and naturalistic, with the pigeons as the main subjects and the textured ground providing context.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-01

The image is a black and white photograph showing a group of pigeons on a ground surface. The ground appears to be a mix of gravel and sand, possibly a beach or a paved area with scattered debris. There are approximately 12 pigeons in the image, each engaged in different activities such as standing, walking, or pecking at the ground. The pigeons are spread out across the frame, with some closer to the foreground and others further in the background. The overall scene conveys a calm and natural setting, typical of pigeons in an urban or semi-urban environment.

Qwen

Created by Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct on 2025-07-08

The image is a black-and-white photograph showing a group of pigeons scattered across a sandy or gravelly surface. The pigeons are varying in posture; some are standing, while others are sitting or lying down. The background appears to be an open area with no visible structures or significant details, emphasizing the natural setting. The overall atmosphere of the image is calm and somewhat desolate, with the focus on the pigeons and their interaction with the environment.

Created by Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-72B-Instruct on 2025-07-08

This black-and-white image captures a group of pigeons scattered across a textured surface, likely gravel or a concrete ground. The pigeons are in various poses—some are standing, others are walking, and a few appear to be pecking at the ground. The scene is devoid of any other objects or significant background features, giving it a minimalist and somewhat stark appearance. The monochromatic color scheme adds to the simplicity and focuses attention on the forms and textures within the image.