Human Generated Data

Title

The Good Argument

Date

1840s

People

Artist: Honoré-Victorin Daumier, French 1808-1879

Classification

Drawings

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Bequest of Grenville L. Winthrop, 1943.795

Human Generated Data

Title

The Good Argument

People

Artist: Honoré-Victorin Daumier, French 1808-1879

Date

1840s

Classification

Drawings

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Bequest of Grenville L. Winthrop, 1943.795

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2020-04-30

Person 99
Human 99
Painting 98.5
Art 98.5
Drawing 92.3
Sketch 83.7
Person 80.7
Photo 58.9
Photography 58.9
Portrait 58.9
Face 58.9

Clarifai
created on 2020-04-30

art 99.9
people 99.7
painting 99.7
illustration 98.7
woman 98.3
print 97.9
adult 96.7
portrait 95.7
book bindings 95.3
two 94.6
one 94.3
book 92.5
old 91.9
man 91.1
visuals 91
street 89.3
elderly 89.3
engraving 88.7
furniture 87.9
vintage 87.8

Imagga
created on 2020-04-30

portrait 28.5
face 26.3
person 25.3
hair 23.8
sexy 20.9
fountain 20
pretty 18.9
make 18.1
sketch 17.8
attractive 17.5
fashion 17.3
adult 16.4
model 16.3
people 15.1
structure 14.8
eyes 13.8
drawing 12.8
man 12.8
lady 12.2
black 12.2
one 11.9
makeup 11.9
representation 11.4
skin 11
head 10.9
close 10.8
smile 10.7
women 10.3
human 9.7
sadness 9.7
sad 9.6
style 9.6
look 9.6
cute 9.3
lips 9.3
dark 9.2
blond 9.2
alone 9.1
sensual 9.1
care 9.1
looking 8.8
statue 8.7
mystery 8.6
youth 8.5
covering 8.4
feminine 8.4
hairdresser 8.2
sensuality 8.2
pose 8.2
happy 8.1
wet 8
posing 8
body 8
art 8
braid 8
love 7.9
hands 7.8
bride 7.7
seductive 7.6
hairstyle 7.6
horse 7.6
closeup 7.4
natural 7.4
long 7.3
animal 7.2
fantasy 7.2
spa 7.2
eye 7.1
net 7.1
lovely 7.1

Google
created on 2020-04-30

Painting 78.7
Art 72.1
Prophet 71.7
Stock photography 70.9
Illustration 66.9
Outerwear 65.8
Drawing 51.1

Microsoft
created on 2020-04-30

text 99.8
drawing 99.8
sketch 99.6
book 98.7
painting 94.3
cartoon 88.8
child art 88.6
illustration 67

Color Analysis

Face analysis

Amazon

Imagga

AWS Rekognition

Age 50-68
Gender Male, 76.5%
Angry 0.1%
Calm 99.1%
Fear 0%
Confused 0%
Disgusted 0.1%
Sad 0.2%
Surprised 0%
Happy 0.5%

Imagga

Traits no traits identified

Imagga

Traits no traits identified

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person
Painting
Person 99%
Person 80.7%
Painting 98.5%

Categories

Captions

Clarifai
created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-29

a photograph of a man in a black robe is holding a cell phone -100%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-02-18

This is an image depicting a courtroom scene rendered in a sketch-like style with a color palette dominated by sepia tones, invoking a historical or vintage feel. In the foreground, a figure, likely a lawyer or barrister given the attire, is standing and expressing emphatically toward the background, where there seems to be a group of spectators or a jury. The lawyer's robe and gesticulation suggest a moment of dramatic argument or presentation. On the table in front of this figure, we can see what appears to be legal documents or papers, along with an inkwell and a quill, reinforcing the historical setting. The background is filled with attentive faces, watching the proceedings closely. The atmosphere is one of intense focus and anticipation, characteristic of a courtroom in the midst of a significant legal debate or trial.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-02-18

This image depicts a courtroom scene in which a lawyer, dressed in traditional legal robes, is making an emphatic gesture, likely presenting an argument or addressing the court. The lawyer's posture suggests passion and determination, with his arm raised and his hand in a dynamic motion. In the background, an audience or jury is visible, attentively observing the proceedings. The setting is indicative of a formal judicial environment, with detailed attention given to the interior, such as the benches and the overall architecture.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2025-02-18

The image depicts a courtroom or legal setting, with a judge or authority figure on a raised platform addressing a crowd of people in the courtroom. The figure on the raised platform appears to be gesturing emphatically, while the individual seated below appears to be in a more passive, deferential pose. The overall scene suggests a legal proceeding or trial taking place, with the authority figure delivering a ruling or statement to the gathered crowd.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2025-02-18

The image appears to be a pen and ink sketch or drawing depicting two elderly men in court or on trial. The men are hunched over, with one gesturing while speaking and the other seated at a table. There is a crowd of onlookers in the background, suggesting this may be a significant public trial or legal proceeding. The shading and linework give the drawing a somber, serious tone befitting the courtroom setting and the advanced age of the central figures.

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2025-02-18

This appears to be an artwork depicting a courtroom scene. A lawyer or barrister in traditional black robes is shown making an impassioned argument or speech, leaning forward dramatically with one arm raised in a gesture. Another figure in similar attire is seated beside them. In the background, there appears to be a crowd of observers or jury members watching the proceedings. The style suggests this is likely a historical illustration or satirical cartoon, possibly from the 18th or 19th century, rendered in ink or watercolor with a loose, expressive drawing technique.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-13

The image depicts a courtroom scene, likely from the 19th century. It features a judge standing at a desk, pointing to something outside the frame, while a man sits at the desk in front of him. The judge is dressed in a long black robe, and the man at the desk wears a dark jacket. The background shows a courtroom with a crowd of people seated behind the judge's desk, indicating a trial or hearing is in progress. The atmosphere appears tense, with the judge's gesture suggesting he is addressing someone or something outside the scene. The overall mood is one of seriousness and gravity, reflecting the solemnity of a legal proceeding.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-13

The image depicts a courtroom scene, with a judge standing at the front of the room and addressing the audience. The judge is dressed in a long black robe and has his right arm raised, pointing towards the crowd. He appears to be speaking passionately or making a point.

In the foreground, there is a man sitting at a table, facing the judge. He is also wearing a dark-colored robe and seems to be taking notes or preparing documents. The table in front of him holds various papers and writing instruments.

Behind the judge, a large crowd of people can be seen, all facing forward and listening intently to the proceedings. They are seated in rows, with some standing at the back of the room. The atmosphere appears tense and focused, with everyone's attention directed towards the judge.

The background of the image features a wall with vertical lines, which may represent wooden panels or a screen. The overall mood of the scene is one of seriousness and gravity, suggesting that the trial or hearing is of great importance.

The image is rendered in a sketchy style, with bold lines and minimal color. The dominant colors are shades of brown and gray, which adds to the somber and formal atmosphere of the scene. Overall, the image effectively conveys the sense of a serious legal proceeding, with the judge and the crowd fully engaged in the process.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-02-18

The image is a sketch of a courtroom scene. The courtroom is depicted in a sketch-like style, with a focus on the figures rather than the details of the surroundings. The central figure is an elderly man in a black robe, standing and gesturing with his right hand. He appears to be a judge or a lawyer delivering a speech or making a point during a trial. The man sitting in front of him is likely a defendant or a witness. The courtroom is filled with people, mostly men, who are watching the proceedings. The sketch captures the atmosphere of a legal proceeding, with the judge or lawyer taking center stage.

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-02-18

The image is a monochromatic sketch of a courtroom scene, likely from the 19th century, given the style and attire of the figures. The central figure is an elderly man standing, dressed in a long, dark robe with a white collar, which suggests he is a judge or a legal authority. He is holding a small object in his right hand, which he appears to be displaying to the courtroom. His expression is stern, and his posture is authoritative.

To the left of the judge, seated at a desk, is another elderly man, also dressed in dark robes, likely a lawyer or a court clerk. He is looking up towards the judge, possibly in response to the object being shown. The desk in front of him has a few items, including what appears to be a quill pen and a small container, possibly for ink.

In the background, the courtroom is filled with spectators, all of whom are seated and appear to be watching the proceedings attentively. The courtroom itself has a high ceiling with visible wooden beams, and the walls are lined with benches for the audience. The overall atmosphere is one of formality and seriousness, typical of a legal proceeding.

The sketch captures a moment of tension or significance in the courtroom, with the judge's gesture drawing the attention of everyone present. The use of shading and line work in the sketch adds depth and highlights the emotional intensity of the scene.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-05-24

Here's a description of the image:

Overall Impression:

The image is a courtroom scene depicted in a style that suggests a satirical or caricatured drawing. It's likely a pen and ink or watercolor drawing with a focus on depicting characters and their expressions.

Main Elements:

  • Two Key Figures: The most prominent figures are two men.
    • One man, likely a judge or lawyer, is depicted in a black robe. He is animated and appears to be gesturing dramatically with his right hand, towards the audience (or maybe towards the light). His expression is exaggerated, suggesting a strong emotion.
    • The second man is seated at the front, seemingly in the defendant's seat. He is in shadow, has a serious look on his face, and is wearing a dark robe.
  • The Audience: In the background, there is a row of people who appear to be the audience or jury. They are rendered in a somewhat sketchy way, with their faces being small and simple.
  • Setting: The scene takes place within a courtroom. There is a desk or bench, a railing separating the audience from the court officials, and the impression of the room's walls. A beam of light is above the audience, possibly from a window.

Style and Tone:

  • Caricature: The figures are somewhat exaggerated, especially the expressions of the judge or lawyer. This suggests a desire to emphasize character traits or convey a particular emotional response.
  • Satirical: The image probably has a satirical intent, as the exaggerated expressions and potentially mocking depiction of the courtroom suggest criticism of the legal system or certain personalities within it.

In summary, the image is a scene of a courtroom with two men in roles of a judge and a defendant. The judge is animated and the scene is satirical.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-05-24

Here is a description of the image:

The image is a caricature of a courtroom scene. In the foreground, a man in a judge's robe is seen in profile with his head bowed. Next to him at a table sits another figure in a robe who is leaning forward, with one hand on the table and the other raised in the air, as if making a statement. Behind them, a crowd of faces is visible in the gallery, all seemingly focused on the speaker. The style is loose and sketchy, with visible brushstrokes and a limited color palette, giving the impression of a quick sketch or study. The composition is framed by a gold border.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-06

The image depicts a courtroom scene featuring two prominent figures, likely a judge and a lawyer, in what appears to be a dramatic moment. The central figure, presumably the lawyer, is standing and gesturing emphatically with his right hand raised, as if making a passionate argument or plea. He is dressed in a long, flowing black robe, which gives him a commanding and authoritative presence. His facial expression is intense, suggesting he is deeply engaged in his speech.

In front of him, seated at a table, is another figure, likely the judge, who is attentively listening. The judge is also dressed in formal attire, including a robe, and appears to be taking notes or reviewing documents. The table is cluttered with papers, a quill pen, and an inkwell, indicating the formal and meticulous nature of the proceedings.

In the background, there is a large audience or jury, depicted as a crowd of faces, suggesting that the courtroom is filled with spectators or jurors intently watching the proceedings. The setting is indoors, with large windows allowing light to filter into the room, adding to the solemn and serious atmosphere of the scene.

The artwork is rendered in a style that emphasizes the emotional intensity and theatricality of the moment, with careful attention to the expressions and gestures of the figures. The use of shading and line work creates a sense of depth and drama, highlighting the importance of the event taking place.