Human Generated Data

Title

The Prizewinning Punch

Date

19th century

People

Artist: Amédée de Noé, called Cham, French 1818-1879

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of W. G. Russell Allen and Paul J. Sachs, M8905

Human Generated Data

Title

The Prizewinning Punch

People

Artist: Amédée de Noé, called Cham, French 1818-1879

Date

19th century

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of W. G. Russell Allen and Paul J. Sachs, M8905

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2019-11-07

Human 94.5
Art 92.7
Drawing 83.4
Painting 78.5
Person 73.5
Wood 70.9
Person 66.6
Text 66.1
Sketch 61.8
Poster 56.1
Advertisement 56.1

Clarifai
created on 2019-11-07

illustration 99.9
art 99.5
people 99.2
painting 99.1
print 98
man 96.3
book 95.5
adult 94.9
one 94.8
saint 93.4
religion 90.9
image 89.8
old 89.7
baby 89.6
paper 89.4
symbol 88.3
visuals 87.7
Renaissance 86.3
desktop 84
god 81.2

Imagga
created on 2019-11-07

sketch 45.6
drawing 34.9
graffito 30
representation 29.7
decoration 26.7
old 20.2
vintage 19.8
art 18.7
currency 17.9
money 17
window 16.6
bank 15.2
bill 15.2
paper 14.9
retro 13.9
church 13.9
cash 13.7
antique 13.6
close 12.5
financial 12.5
stamp 12.3
banking 11.9
frame 11.6
design 11.4
one 11.2
dollar 11.1
wall 11.1
grunge 11.1
finance 11
wealth 10.8
religion 10.8
detail 10.5
architecture 10.1
letter 10.1
device 9.6
mail 9.6
post 9.5
envelope 9.5
culture 9.4
black 9
postmark 8.9
postage 8.8
symbol 8.7
building 8.7
exchange 8.6
business 8.5
painter 8.4
note 8.3
historic 8.2
pattern 8.2
paint 8.1
aged 8.1
office 8
textured 7.9
postal 7.8
ancient 7.8
bills 7.8
museum 7.8
dollars 7.7
architectural 7.7
unique 7.6
house 7.5
sculpture 7.5
savings 7.5
rich 7.4
brown 7.4
glass 7.3
history 7.1

Google
created on 2019-11-07

Microsoft
created on 2019-11-07

text 99.9
drawing 99.6
sketch 98.9
cartoon 98.8
book 98.3
painting 96
indoor 87.2
art 75.7
illustration 73
child art 62.6

Color Analysis

Face analysis

Amazon

AWS Rekognition

Age 35-51
Gender Male, 53.5%
Sad 53%
Happy 45.4%
Surprised 45%
Disgusted 45%
Calm 46.5%
Confused 45%
Angry 45%
Fear 45%

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person
Poster
Person 73.5%

Categories

Imagga

paintings art 100%

Captions

Microsoft
created on 2019-11-07

a close up of a book 37.4%
close up of a book 32.5%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-02-03

This image appears to be a vintage illustration or cartoon titled "Polichinelle Vainqueur." The scene portrays a lively puppet show featuring Polichinelle, a traditional comic character, and another character with a wild appearance. Polichinelle is depicted in mid-action, possibly engaged in a comedic fight or dramatic event. The illustration captures the vibrant and chaotic nature of the show, with an audience watching intently from below the stage. The text below the drawing, in French, describes the performance as a democratic and social piece with elements of fights, coarseness, and other familiarities. The image is rich in detail, with expressive characters and a sense of dynamic movement.

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-02-03

The image depicts a colorful illustration or lithograph from a publication. The scene is set within a rectangular frame, portraying a chaotic and humorous scenario. In the upper center of the image, within the confines of a theater booth or similar structure, we see two figures engaged in a comical struggle. One character with oversized features, most notably a pointed hat that suggests a jester or clown-like appearance, is flailing backwards with an exaggerated look of alarm or surprise. A feather or plume emerges from the hat, emphasizing the character's dynamic movement. Accompanying this character is a small monkey, which clings to the edge of the booth looking equally startled. Below this central altercation is a crowd of people wearing hats indicative of 19th-century fashion. This audience appears bewildered, with some looking up towards the commotion above them and others trying to avoid potential harm as objects seem to have fallen among them. The text below the image is in French and hints at a satirical or social commentary, which was typical for theatrical caricatures of the period. The top of the image reads "ACTUALITÉS," which suggests a series or theme of current events or topics of the time. The overall impression is one of lively satire, perhaps commenting on cultural or political events of the era when the piece was created.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2025-02-03

This is a French political cartoon or caricature titled "Polichinelle Vainqueur" (Victorious Punch/Polichinelle). It appears to be from the "Actualites" (Current Events) series, dated around 1850. The image shows theatrical characters in a puppet show or stage performance, with Polichinelle (a character similar to Punch from Punch and Judy) appearing to triumph over others in a comical scene. Several top hats are strewn about the bottom of the image, suggesting some kind of chaos or conflict. The subtitle reads "Pièce démocratique et sociale à grand spectacle mêlée de combats, pugilats, grossièretés et autres familiarités" which translates to "Democratic and social spectacle mixed with fights, fistfights, rudeness and other familiarities." The art style is characteristic of 19th century political satire, with exaggerated features and theatrical poses. The coloring is subtle, using muted tones and watercolor-like effects. The image appears to be commenting on the political or social dynamics of the time through the metaphor of theatrical performance.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2025-02-03

The image depicts a satirical caricature titled "Polichinelle vainqueur", which translates to "Victorious Polichinelle" in English. It shows the character Polichinelle, a stock character from commedia dell'arte, as a winged figure triumphantly perched atop a pile of defeated opponents in a theater box or stage setting. The defeated figures are portrayed in exaggerated, unflattering poses, suggesting this is meant to be a humorous social commentary or political satire mocking certain familial squabbles and rivalries of the time period. The sketch-like drawing style with shading gives it an unfinished, rough quality typical of satirical illustrations from the late 18th or early 19th century.

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2025-02-03

The image depicts a chaotic scene of a Punch and Judy-style puppet show. The central figure appears to be a clown-like puppet called "Polichinelle" (a traditional French puppet character) who is shown triumphantly emerging from some kind of confrontation or fight. Around him are various other puppet characters, some of whom seem to be engaged in physical altercations or other comical antics. The overall impression is one of a lively and rambunctious performance, with the accompanying caption describing it as a "democratic and social piece with a great spectacle of combats, pugilists, buffoonery, and other familiarities."

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-13

The image is a political cartoon, specifically a satirical illustration, titled "Polichinelle Vainqueur" (Victorious Punchinello). It was created by the French artist Honoré Daumier in 1838. **Key Elements:** * **Title:** The title, "Polichinelle Vainqueur," translates to "Victorious Punchinello." Punchinello is a character from the Commedia dell'Arte, often depicted as a fool or a clown. * **Scene:** The cartoon depicts a chaotic scene with several figures, including a man with a large head and a feathered hat, who appears to be in the midst of a fight or struggle. Other characters are shown in various states of distress or disarray. * **Color Scheme:** The illustration is rendered in a muted color palette, with shades of gray, brown, and blue dominating the scene. This choice of colors adds to the overall sense of gloom and chaos. * **Symbolism:** The cartoon likely contains symbolic elements, which were common in political cartoons of the time. These symbols could represent various political or social issues of the era, but without specific context, their exact meaning is open to interpretation. * **Style:** Daumier's style is characterized by his use of caricature and satire to critique societal norms and political figures. His work often featured exaggerated features and dramatic poses to convey his messages. **Context:** * **Time Period:** The cartoon was created in 1838, a time of significant political and social change in France. The July Revolution of 1830 had recently taken place, leading to the establishment of a constitutional monarchy under King Louis-Philippe. * **Political Climate:** The political climate during this period was marked by tensions between the monarchy and the emerging middle class. The cartoon may reflect these tensions or critique the political figures of the time. **Conclusion:** "Polichinelle Vainqueur" is a satirical illustration by Honoré Daumier, created in 1838. The cartoon depicts a chaotic scene with symbolic elements, likely critiquing political or social issues of the era. Daumier's use of caricature and satire was characteristic of his work, which often targeted societal norms and political figures. Without specific context, the exact meaning of the cartoon is open to interpretation, but it provides insight into the political and social climate of 19th-century France.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-13

This image is a French caricature from the late 19th century, featuring a man wearing a tall hat and holding a feather quill pen. He is depicted as being thrown out of a window by a group of people, with his legs sticking out of the window and his body in mid-air. The man's face is contorted in a comical expression, and he appears to be shouting or screaming. The caricature is titled "Polichinelle Vairqueur" and features a caption at the bottom that reads, "Piece democratique et sociale a grand spectacle melee de combats, pugilats, grossieretes et autres familiarites." This translates to "Democratic and social piece with a great spectacle mixed with fights, punches, coarseness, and other familiarities." The image is likely a commentary on the political and social climate of France during the late 19th century, with the man being thrown out of the window representing the rejection of certain ideologies or political figures. The use of humor and satire in the caricature suggests that it was intended to be a lighthearted critique rather than a serious political statement. Overall, the image provides a glimpse into the political and social attitudes of France during the late 19th century, and highlights the use of humor and satire as a means of commentary and critique.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-02-03

The image is a black-and-white cartoon illustration from a newspaper or magazine, titled "Actualités." It depicts a whimsical scene with several exaggerated characters. At the top, a man wearing a tall, cone-shaped hat with a feather and a monocle is perched on a ledge, holding a book, and looking down. To his left, a small, winged creature resembling a fairy or a small child with wings is sitting on the ledge. Below them, a large, hairy creature with a big nose and a long tongue is leaning over the ledge, seemingly trying to reach the man or the fairy. The background shows a chaotic scene with several men, all wearing top hats, gathered around and looking up at the characters on the ledge. The men appear to be in a state of shock or amazement, with exaggerated expressions. The illustration is framed by a border and has a caption in French at the bottom, which translates to "Democratic and social piece with a grand spectacle of combats, puppets, grotesques, and other families."

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-02-03

The image appears to be a page from a French publication from the 19th century. The page features a black and white illustration of a scene with several cartoon characters. The illustration is captioned "Actualites" and "Polichinelle Vainqueur," which suggests it may be a satirical or political cartoon. The scene depicts a group of people gathered around a stage or platform where a puppet or marionette is performing. The puppet appears to be a caricature of a politician or public figure, wearing a hat and holding a feather. There are also other characters in the scene, including a dog and a cat. The caption below the illustration reads "Piece démocratique et sociale a grand spectacle melé de combats, pugilats, grossieretés et autres familiarités," which translates to "Democratic and social piece with a great spectacle mixed with fights, boxing, rudeness and other familiarities." Overall, the image appears to be a satirical commentary on politics and public figures in 19th-century France, using the medium of a puppet show to convey its message.

Text analysis

Amazon

melee
spectacle
de
ACTUALITES.
POLICHINELLE
Picce
sociale
combats,
autres
grand
grossieretes
pugilats, grossieretes
famlarites.
pugilats,
Picce democrafique et sociale a grand spectacle melee de combats,
et autres famlarites.
et
VAINQUEUR
democrafique
a
Aubert
Imp
57
Imp Anbert
138
Bourse
Anbert
CHAM
la
Chez Aubert H de la Bourse POLICHINELLE VAINQUEUR
Chez
H

Google

ACTUALITES. 57 on GHAM 138 Imp Aubert &C Picce democratique et sociale à grand spectacle mêlee de combats, pugilats, grossièretés et autres familiarites POLICHINELLE VAINQUEUR Chex Aubert M de la Bourse C
ACTUALITES.
57
on
138
Imp
Aubert
&C
Picce
democratique
sociale
à
grand
spectacle
GHAM
et
mêlee
de
combats,
pugilats,
grossièretés
autres
familiarites
POLICHINELLE
VAINQUEUR
Chex
M
la
Bourse
C