Human Generated Data

Title

Shenandoah

Date

1910

People

Artist: Joseph Pennell, American 1857 - 1926

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Paul J. Sachs, M359

Human Generated Data

Title

Shenandoah

People

Artist: Joseph Pennell, American 1857 - 1926

Date

1910

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Paul J. Sachs, M359

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2022-03-04

Painting 96.2
Art 96.2
Person 93.7
Human 93.7
Person 91.4
Drawing 72.5
Sketch 68.2
Utility Pole 55.5

Clarifai
created on 2023-10-29

people 99.2
print 98.9
art 98.1
vintage 97
engraving 96.5
sepia pigment 96.4
painting 94.9
monochrome 94.4
vehicle 94.3
tree 94.1
sepia 93.5
transportation system 92
chalk out 91.6
landscape 91.4
old 91.1
tower 90.9
fence 90.2
group 89.4
etching 89.3
no person 88.2

Imagga
created on 2022-03-04

sketch 46.1
drawing 37
representation 30.6
grunge 24.7
texture 22.9
jigsaw puzzle 22.6
vintage 22.3
old 20.9
landscape 20.8
structure 20.3
antique 19
book jacket 18.5
puzzle 17.8
cable 17.6
sky 17.3
snow 17.3
winter 16.2
frame 15.8
forest 15.7
ancient 15.6
tree 14.7
aged 14.5
jacket 14.4
cold 12.9
silhouette 12.4
pattern 12.3
retro 12.3
game 12.2
black 12
paper 11.8
season 11.7
trees 11.6
wallpaper 11.5
water 11.3
wrapping 10.9
design 10.7
travel 10.6
outdoors 10.5
empty 10.3
city 10
art 9.8
backgrounds 9.7
urban 9.6
electricity 9.4
sun 9.4
line 9.4
clouds 9.3
power 9.2
grain 9.2
park 9.1
mountain 9.1
border 9.1
dirty 9
sunset 9
material 8.9
building 8.9
wall 8.9
natural 8.7
frost 8.6
covering 8.6
old fashioned 8.6
energy 8.4
rough 8.2
scenery 8.1
billboard 8
grime 7.8
architecture 7.8
high 7.8
space 7.8
decay 7.7
spot 7.7
obsolete 7.7
damaged 7.6
wood 7.5
environment 7.4
light 7.4
river 7.3
wire 7.3
decoration 7.1
textured 7

Google
created on 2022-03-04

Wood 87.8
Art 81.6
Tree 81.5
Painting 80.2
Plant 73.5
Drawing 70.7
Illustration 70.2
Visual arts 68.5
Paper product 67.4
Printmaking 65
History 64.7
Landscape 63.5
Artwork 63
Monochrome 62.6
Sketch 57.2
Trunk 57.1
Antique 53.4
Font 52.7
Modern art 50.2

Microsoft
created on 2022-03-04

text 94.8
drawing 94
gallery 88.3
sketch 77.1
room 50.3
picture frame 35.9
painting 29.1

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Painting
Person
Painting 96.2%

Categories

Captions

Microsoft
created on 2022-03-04

a painting on the wall 76.1%
a painting on a wall 75.7%
a painting hanging on a wall 75.6%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-01-29

This is a black and white etching depicting an urban landscape that appears to be in a state of decay or construction. In the foreground, there is a rough, uneven terrain that looks like a street torn up, with tracks embedded into the ground; possibly streetcar tracks. Multiple utility poles stretch into the distance, following the path of the tracks. The middle ground features a tall, dilapidated building that seems to be either under demolition or has suffered extensive damage. It has a skeletal appearance, with much of its structure exposed. In the background, more buildings are visible, but they are shrouded in a hazy or smoky atmosphere, which could suggest pollution or fog. The skyline suggests an urban setting with multiple buildings, possibly depicting an industrial city scene. The dramatic contrast in lighting, with the sky being much lighter than the rest of the etching, draws attention to the intricate details in the texture of the clouds and the silhouettes of the cityscape. There is a sense of movement in the sky, as the clouds swirl above the stark lines of the utility poles and buildings. The piece has a dark, moody atmosphere, with a sense of abandonment or desolation. The etching seems to comment on themes of urban decay, industrialization, or the passage of time affecting city landscapes.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-01-29

The image is a striking black-and-white etching that depicts an industrial landscape. The scene features a prominent, large, and slightly tilted industrial building on the right side, exuding smoke which adds to the gritty atmosphere of the setting. There are several telegraph poles lining what appears to be railroad tracks running through the center of the image, leading into the depths of the industrial complex. In the background, other factory structures and chimneys can be observed billowing smoke, enhancing the bleak and industrious feeling of the image. The left side is dominated by a rocky hillside. Two figures, possibly workers, can be seen on or near the railroad tracks in the middle ground, adding a sense of scale and human presence to the stark, mechanical environment. The overall mood of the image is somber and reflective of the heavy, labor-intensive industrial era. The framing and composition draw the viewer's eye into the heart of the industrial scene, emphasizing the scale and impact of the industry on the landscape.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2025-01-29

This is a moody, atmospheric black and white etching or drawing depicting an industrial landscape. The scene shows railroad tracks running through what appears to be a mining or industrial area. Telephone or power poles line the tracks, their stark vertical forms creating a rhythm across the composition. On the right side of the image is what looks like a large coal tipple or mining structure. The background shows industrial buildings or factories with smokestacks silhouetted against a light sky. The overall tone is dark and gritty, with strong contrasts between light and shadow, capturing the rough, working character of an early 20th century industrial site. Small figures can be seen along the tracks, giving scale to the imposing industrial structures around them.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2025-01-29

The image depicts a post-apocalyptic or war-torn urban landscape in a monochromatic, sketch-like style. Collapsed buildings, rubble and debris fill the scene, with damaged structures and power lines in the background suggesting a city in ruins. A few small human figures can be seen walking amidst the destruction, emphasizing the sense of desolation and devastation. The rough, expressive linework adds to the gritty, ominous atmosphere conveyed by the decimated cityscape.

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2025-01-29

The image depicts a gritty, industrial scene. In the foreground, there are ruins and damaged structures, possibly from some kind of destruction or demolition. Train tracks run through the center of the frame, with utility poles and wires stretching across the scene. In the background, there are silhouettes of tall buildings or structures, suggesting an urban environment. The overall atmosphere is dark and foreboding, with a sense of abandonment and decay.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-16

The image is a black and white drawing of a coal mine scene. It depicts a large coal mine with a tall building on the right side, and a road leading to it. There are several telephone poles and wires in the foreground, as well as a few people walking on the road. The background of the image shows a city skyline in the distance, with smoke billowing from the mine. The overall atmosphere of the image is one of industry and hard work, with the mine and its workers being the central focus. The image is drawn in a detailed and realistic style, with a focus on capturing the textures and details of the scene.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-16

The image depicts a black-and-white sketch of a cityscape with a prominent railroad track running through it. The scene is set against a backdrop of buildings, telephone poles, and power lines, with a few people visible in the foreground. **Key Features:** * **Railroad Track:** A central element of the image, the railroad track stretches from the foreground to the background, disappearing into the distance. * **Buildings:** Several buildings are visible in the background, including what appears to be a large factory or warehouse on the right side of the image. * **Telephone Poles and Power Lines:** Telephone poles and power lines are scattered throughout the image, adding to the urban landscape. * **People:** A few people are visible in the foreground, walking along the railroad track or standing near the buildings. * **Atmosphere:** The overall atmosphere of the image is one of industry and activity, with the railroad track and buildings suggesting a bustling urban environment. **Artistic Style:** * **Sketchy Lines:** The image features sketchy lines and loose brushstrokes, giving it a sense of spontaneity and energy. * **Monochromatic Color Scheme:** The use of a single color (black and white) creates a sense of simplicity and focus, drawing attention to the composition and subject matter. **Overall Impression:** The image presents a dynamic and engaging portrayal of urban life, capturing the hustle and bustle of a city in motion. The sketchy lines and monochromatic color scheme add to the image's sense of energy and spontaneity, making it a compelling and thought-provoking work of art.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-01-29

The image is a black-and-white drawing of a city street with a few people walking on the road. There are a few buildings on either side of the road. A few electric poles are placed on the left side of the road, and some wires are connected to them. There are some rocks on the left side of the road. The drawing is framed with a white border.

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-01-29

The image depicts a black-and-white etching of a scene from a city. In the foreground, there is a road with a few people walking along it. On the left side of the road, there is a steep hill with several utility poles and wires running along it. On the right side of the road, there is a large building with smoke coming out of it, possibly a factory. In the distance, there are more buildings and a cityscape. The sky is overcast and gray.