Human Generated Data

Title

They Do Not Agree

Date

18th-19th century

People

Artist: Francisco José de Goya y Lucientes, Spanish 1746 - 1828

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Mr. and Mrs. Philip Hofer, M12550

Human Generated Data

Title

They Do Not Agree

People

Artist: Francisco José de Goya y Lucientes, Spanish 1746 - 1828

Date

18th-19th century

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Mr. and Mrs. Philip Hofer, M12550

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2019-11-01

Art 95.7
Painting 91.4
Mammal 63.4
Animal 63.4
Horse 63.4
Horse 62.9
Text 57.6
Person 57.5
Human 57.5
Person 48.7

Clarifai
created on 2019-11-01

people 99.9
illustration 99.8
print 99.5
art 99.4
adult 97.8
painting 97.7
group 95.8
wear 95.4
engraving 94.5
man 93.6
leader 91.7
lithograph 88.6
mammal 88.2
vintage 86.3
cavalry 85.9
military 84.6
old 84
antique 83
two 82.2
woman 80

Imagga
created on 2019-11-01

grunge 64.8
graffito 63.9
old 55.1
decoration 49.8
vintage 49.7
texture 47.3
aged 46.2
antique 43.3
retro 40.2
wall 38.9
memorial 37.4
grungy 35.1
doormat 35
dirty 33.5
gravestone 32.8
structure 30.6
frame 30
textured 29
damaged 28.6
ancient 28.6
paper 28.3
mat 27.7
material 26.8
pattern 26
rusty 25.7
worn 23.9
rough 21.9
brown 21.4
stone 21
floor cover 21
weathered 20.9
art 19.5
design 19.2
surface 18.5
wallpaper 18.4
torn 18.4
rust 18.3
stained 18.3
paint 18.1
border 18.1
space 17.9
decorative 17.5
stain 17.3
blank 17.2
color 16.2
messy 15.5
empty 15.5
decay 15.4
covering 15.4
flower 15.4
parchment 15.4
aging 15.4
dirt 15.3
page 14.9
floral 14.5
canvas 14.2
text 14
grain 13.9
backdrop 13.2
brass 13.1
ragged 12.7
burnt 12.6
dark 11.7
stains 11.7
spot 11.5
detail 11.3
graphic 11
scratched 10.8
backgrounds 10.6
old fashioned 10.5
artistic 10.4
world 10.1
shabby 9.8
grime 9.8
architecture 9.4
leaf 9.3
map 9.3
historic 9.2
artwork 9.2
black 9
distressed 8.8
faded 8.8
crumpled 8.7
crack 8.7
obsolete 8.6
north 8.6
yellow 8.6
close 8.6
textures 8.5
atlas 7.9
country 7.9
urban 7.9
burned 7.9
manuscript 7.8
scratch 7.8
album 7.8
geography 7.7
construction 7.7
detailed 7.7
rustic 7.7
card 7.7
japan 7.7
china 7.5
exterior 7.4
earth 7.3
global 7.3
building 7.3
metal 7.2

Google
created on 2019-11-01

Microsoft
created on 2019-11-01

drawing 91.8
person 91.4
gallery 88.7
clothing 82.3
text 79.7
painting 77.4
old 76.6
sketch 74.1
white 74.1
black 68.4
room 60.9
vintage 32.6
picture frame 28.5
plaque 17.2

Color Analysis

Face analysis

Amazon

AWS Rekognition

Age 17-29
Gender Female, 52.2%
Sad 45.2%
Calm 54.7%
Disgusted 45%
Angry 45%
Confused 45%
Surprised 45%
Happy 45%
Fear 45%

AWS Rekognition

Age 31-47
Gender Female, 51.5%
Angry 45.1%
Happy 45%
Fear 45%
Disgusted 45%
Calm 54.6%
Surprised 45%
Confused 45%
Sad 45.2%

Feature analysis

Amazon

Painting
Horse
Person
Painting 91.4%
Horse 63.4%
Horse 62.9%
Person 57.5%
Person 48.7%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2019-11-01

a vintage photo of a flower 58.5%
a vintage photo of a person 58.4%
a black and white photo of a flower 47.4%

Clarifai
created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-03

a photograph of a drawing of a man on a horse -100%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-01-31

This image displays an etching or engraving that depicts a chaotic battle scene. A central figure, on horseback, appears to be a focal point of the action. This person is wearing what looks like a feathered helmet, indicating a status of some authority or a specific kind of soldier. The horse rears up amidst the tumult. There are other figures in the background; some appear to be on foot and in various poses of combat or distress.

The style of the artwork suggests it could be historic, likely from a period when such scenes were common subjects for prints. The use of light and shadow is dramatic, contributing to the intense and dynamic feel of the scene. The paper looks aged, with some marks and annotations outside of the framed scene, likely referencing details about the print's series or edition. This image appears to be part of a larger narrative, possibly from a historical or mythological context.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-01-31

This image is an etching titled "Bury Them and Keep Quiet" (Entierro y silencio) by Francisco Goya. It depicts a chaotic scene likely from a battlefield or aftermath of a battle. The left side shows a soldier on horseback, directing or observing the scene with a stern presence. The horse appears dark in color, while the soldier is illuminated by light, creating a stark contrast.

Towards the right, there is a group of people who seem to be in conflict or distress, some appearing to be attacking or defending themselves with swords. There is a dramatic depiction of motion and action suggested by their postures. In the foreground, a figure is seen lying on the ground, either injured or deceased, wrapped in a cloak or blanket. Another figure kneels or leans over this person, suggesting a somber moment of grief or final duty.

The background is dark, emphasizing the bleak and somber atmosphere, with a light source illuminating only certain figures and portions of the scene. This etching is known for its dramatic intensity and emotional impact, characteristic of Goya's works that often depicted the brutal realities of war.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2025-01-31

This appears to be a historical etching or print depicting a dramatic battle or combat scene. The central figure is mounted on a dark horse and appears to be wearing military attire with plumed headgear, pointing forward in a commanding gesture. There are other figures shown in combat positions on the ground, some appearing to be falling or in defensive postures. The artwork uses strong contrast between dark and light areas, which was typical of etchings from this period. The style and composition suggests this might be from the 18th or early 19th century, possibly depicting a scene from a military conflict of that era. The dramatic lighting and dynamic poses of the figures create a sense of tension and movement in the scene.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2025-01-31

The image shows an etching or print depicting a group of figures on horseback. The riders appear to be soldiers or military figures, with one figure prominently positioned on a rearing horse in the center. Other riders and horses are shown behind and to the sides of the central figure in a chaotic, battle-like scene. The artwork has an energetic, sketchy style with dark shading and cross-hatching to create depth and shadow. The print is labeled as plate 17 in the bottom left corner, suggesting it may be part of a series.

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2025-01-31

The image depicts a chaotic scene of violence and war. Several figures on horseback are shown attacking and trampling over a group of people on the ground. The figures on horseback appear to be soldiers or warriors, wielding weapons. The people on the ground seem to be civilians or non-combatants, some of whom are falling or cowering in fear. The overall atmosphere is one of chaos and destruction, with a sense of brutality and the lawless nature of the conflict. The image conveys a powerful and unsettling message about the horrors of war and its impact on innocent lives.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-16

The image is a black and white etching of a battle scene. The scene depicts a chaotic and intense moment in a war, with soldiers on horseback and on foot engaged in combat. The etching is detailed, capturing the movement and emotion of the moment.

The etching is signed by the artist, Rembrandt van Rijn, and dated to 1640. It is considered one of his most famous works and is widely regarded as a masterpiece of Dutch Golden Age art. The etching is part of a series of prints that Rembrandt created, known as the "Battle Pieces," which depict scenes of war and conflict.

The etching is housed in the collection of the British Museum in London, where it is considered one of the museum's most prized possessions. It is a testament to Rembrandt's skill as an artist and his ability to capture the human experience in his work.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-16

The image depicts a scene of war, with a central figure on horseback wielding a sword. The man is dressed in a white shirt and dark pants, and he wears a helmet adorned with feathers. He sits atop a dark-colored horse, which faces to the right.

In the background, several other men are visible, some of whom appear to be injured or dead. One man lies on the ground, while another stands behind the horse, holding a sword. A third man is seen in the distance, also armed with a sword.

The overall atmosphere of the image suggests a sense of chaos and violence, as if the scene is unfolding in the midst of a battle. The use of dark colors and the dramatic pose of the central figure add to the sense of tension and drama.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-01-31

The image is a black-and-white print of a drawing. It depicts a scene of chaos and conflict. The drawing shows a group of men in military uniforms engaged in a battle. The central figure is a man on horseback, holding a sword, and appears to be leading the charge. The background is filled with smoke and dust, suggesting a violent and intense battle. The drawing is framed by a border, and there is a watermark in the top left corner.

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-01-31

The image is an old etching of a battle scene, featuring a dramatic and chaotic atmosphere. In the foreground, there is a rider on a horse, pointing a sword or lance towards the enemy. The rider is wearing a hat and a long coat, and the horse is rearing up on its hind legs, adding to the sense of movement and urgency. In the background, there are several soldiers engaged in combat, with some lying on the ground and others standing and fighting. The scene is set in a dark and smoky environment, with clouds of smoke rising from the battlefield. The image has a sepia tone, giving it an antique and historical feel.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-05-04

The image is a black and white etching of a battlefield scene, reminiscent of the style of Francisco Goya. The artwork is bordered by a thin, rectangular frame that seems to be the edge of the etching plate itself, and the artwork is set against a larger, light-beige rectangular background.

The central focus is on a horse-mounted figure who appears to be an officer, judging by his feathered helmet and uniform. He is pointing assertively towards the right side of the image, seemingly directing his troops. The horse is dark and muscular, and the officer sits confidently atop it.

To the officer's left and slightly behind, there are other figures, likely soldiers, some on horseback and others on foot. These figures are less detailed, adding to the chaotic atmosphere of a battle.

On the right side of the image, there is a cluster of figures engaged in combat. Several are on the ground, appearing to be fallen soldiers, while others wield weapons, seemingly in the thick of battle. The figures are silhouetted against a lighter background, adding contrast and emphasizing the struggle.

The overall scene conveys a sense of violence, urgency, and the grim realities of warfare. The use of dark and light contrasts creates a dramatic effect, drawing the viewer's eye to the key elements of the composition.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-05-04

Here's a description of the image:

Overall Impression:

The image is a black and white etching depicting a chaotic and brutal scene of warfare or a conflict. The style suggests it's likely a historical work, and the etching technique enhances the emotional impact.

Key Elements:

  • Central Figure: A man on horseback is the focal point. He is wearing a military uniform with a feathered helmet and appears to be directing the conflict with his outstretched arm. The horse is also prominent and adds to the sense of power and action.
  • Combat and Casualties: The foreground is filled with figures in various states of being attacked, wounded, or dead. Soldiers are engaged in close combat with swords, daggers, or other weapons. Some have fallen on the ground. The depiction of death and suffering is evident.
  • Visual Technique: The use of etching provides great details, shadows, and tones to enhance the sense of motion and emotion.
  • Background: The background has been etched to depict a foggy area

Overall, the image conveys a strong sense of violence, chaos, and the devastating impact of warfare.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-08

The image is an etching depicting a chaotic battle scene. It features several figures engaged in combat, with a focus on a horse and rider in the center. The horse appears to be rearing up, adding to the sense of turmoil and action. The rider is dressed in what appears to be military attire, possibly from a historical period.

Surrounding the horse and rider are other figures, some of whom are armed with swords and appear to be in various states of struggle or defeat. The scene is dark and dramatic, with heavy shading and cross-hatching used to create a sense of depth and movement. The background is filled with smoke or clouds, enhancing the chaotic atmosphere.

The etching is framed by a border, and there are some inscriptions at the top, which might indicate the title, artist, or other identifying information. The overall mood of the image is intense and dynamic, capturing a moment of conflict and disorder.

Text analysis

Amazon

(lati
(lati 171.
171.
40.13.6
/r 40.13.6
/r

Google

Plati 17.
Plati
17.