Human Generated Data

Title

Elm, Ash, and Oak

Date

1850

People

Artist: James Duffield Harding, British 1798 - 1863

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Fine Arts Department, M23032

Human Generated Data

Title

Elm, Ash, and Oak

People

Artist: James Duffield Harding, British 1798 - 1863

Date

1850

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Fine Arts Department, M23032

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2023-10-23

Art 99
Painting 99
Outdoors 97.8
Plant 97.2
Nature 95.6
Tree 91.6
Snow 81.9
Plant 78.2
Text 57.5
Plant 57
Drawing 56.9
Page 56.5
Book 55.6
Publication 55.6
Land 55.2
Vegetation 55.2
Woodland 55.2

Clarifai
created on 2019-02-26

dirty 99.9
messy 99.2
abstract 98.9
stain 98.6
sooty 98.5
desktop 98.2
illustration 98
rough 97.8
retro 97.6
design 97.4
artistic 97.1
graphic 96.9
vintage 96.1
splash 95.9
texture 95.8
bill 95.8
smudge 95.2
art 95.2
vector 95.1
brush 95.1

Imagga
created on 2019-02-26

design 35
grunge 33.3
snow 33.2
year 32
winter 31.6
splash 31
snowflake 30.9
decoration 30.6
cold 30.2
card 30.1
season 28.9
holiday 28
ice 27.9
wallpaper 26.9
new 26.8
ornament 26.8
frame 26.5
celebration 26.4
backdrop 25.6
motif 25.3
graphic 24.9
art 24.8
texture 24.4
pattern 22.6
halftone 21.8
crystal 21.7
element 21.6
greeting 21.4
backgrounds 21.2
snowflakes 20.5
decorative 18.4
rubbish 16.7
liquid 16.6
border 16.3
tracing 16
shape 15.7
light 15.4
drop 14.6
merry 14.3
drops 14.2
color 13.9
star 13.9
paint 13.6
style 13.4
creative 13.3
curve 13.2
floral 12.8
eve 12.5
gift 12.1
water 12.1
modern 12
effect 11.9
paper 11.8
flake 11.8
stencil 11.6
decor 11.5
stars 11.3
shiny 11.1
dirty 10.9
splashing 10.7
stain 10.6
digital 10.6
frozen 10.5
motion 10.3
elements 10.2
symbol 10.1
template 10.1
drink 10.1
bright 10
tree 10
celebrate 10
material 9.9
ripple 9.6
bubbles 9.5
patterns 9.5
bubble 9.4
tile 9.4
clean 9.2
silhouette 9.1
vintage 9.1
present 9.1
transparent 9
solid 8.9
textured 8.8
drip 8.8
clear 8.8
structure 8.7
spray 8.7
spring 8.7
drawing 8.6
curl 8.6
freeze 8.5
shapes 8.5
holidays 8.4
ribbon 8.4
purity 8.3
retro 8.2
wet 8.1
detail 8.1
confetti 8
cool 8
tracery 8
seasonal 7.9
snowfall 7.9
artistic 7.8
elegant 7.7
frost 7.7
seamless 7.6
plant 7.5
freshness 7.5
close 7.4
lights 7.4
grain 7.4
artwork 7.3
aged 7.3
colors 7.1
deer 7
space 7

Google
created on 2019-02-26

Paper 59.2

Microsoft
created on 2019-02-26

porcelain 7.8
nature 7.8
autumn 6.1
texture 4.8
fall 3.4
abstract 3.2
winter 3

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Plant
Plant 97.2%
Plant 78.2%
Plant 57%

Categories

Imagga

paintings art 96.9%
nature landscape 1.5%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2019-02-26

a close up of a snow covered field 42.8%

Clarifai
created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-26

a photograph of a group of four different types of trees -100%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-02-10

The image appears to be a vintage illustration titled "Plate 4" displaying different tree foliage drawing techniques or studies. There are four depictions of tree branches with leaves, arranged in a grid format with two on the top and two on the bottom. Each of them is associated with a "Lesson" number and labeled with the type of tree.

  • The top left image is labeled “Lesson 13” and "Elm."
  • The top right image is labeled “Lesson 14” and "Elm."
  • The bottom left image is labeled “Lesson 15” and "Ash."
  • The bottom right image is labeled “Lesson 16” and "Oak."

In the center of the image, there is a handwritten note "TDH 1850," indicating possibly the artist's initials and the year of creation. The background of the image shows signs of age, with brownish spots and some discoloration. The illustrations are detailed with intricate splotches and dashes to create the textures of the leaves and branches.

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-02-10

This image features four distinct botanical illustrations, most likely of ferns or other foliage, organized in a two-by-two grid on a portrait-oriented page. Each illustration varies slightly in pattern and shading, suggesting they are different species or variations. Below each illustration, there are inscriptions that read "LESSON L," "LESSON I," "LESSON Ib.," and "LESSON Ic.", though the exact order is a bit obscured due to the angle and positioning.

The image exhibits signs of aging and handling, such as discolored spots and browning, which suggest it is from an older document. There is handwriting in ink on the upper right corner between the right illustrations, which appears to read "J.D.H. 1830", potentially indicating the artist's initials and the year of creation.

Additionally, at the top of the page, the text "Plate 4" indicates that this page is part of a series or a collection. The style of the renderings is delicate and detailed, consistent with 19th-century botanical illustrations, which were often created for scientific works or as instructional materials in botany.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2025-02-10

This is a study sheet or lesson page from 1850, marked "JDH 1850" in the middle. It contains four similar sketches of tree foliage, labeled as Lessons 15 and 16. The sketches appear to be done in pencil or charcoal, showing different studies of leaf clusters or tree branches with a delicate, feathery appearance. The drawings demonstrate techniques for rendering the texture and volume of foliage through light and shadow. The page has some age spots or foxing (yellowish-brown spots) typical of old paper. Each sketch shows slightly different approaches to depicting the natural, flowing form of leaves and branches, likely used as drawing exercises or demonstrations for art students.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2025-02-10

The image shows sketches or illustrations of several tree-like structures, labeled as "Lesson 15", "Lesson 16", "Lesson 17", and "Lesson 18". The sketches appear to be done in pencil or charcoal, depicting the shapes and textures of the trees or foliage in a loose, artistic style. The background has a slightly aged or weathered look with some splatters or stains. Overall, it seems to be a study or practice sheet focusing on drawing different types of trees or plants.

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2025-02-10

The image appears to be a series of four drawings or illustrations of tree branches or foliage. The drawings have a sketchy, textured style and are arranged in a grid layout on the page. Each drawing depicts a different arrangement or cluster of branches and leaves. The overall style and presentation suggest this may be an educational or scientific illustration, perhaps depicting different types of plant growth or botanical specimens.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-17

The image presents a page from an old book, featuring four sketches of trees in the top half and the bottom half. The sketches are rendered in a simple, yet detailed style, with the trees depicted in various shades of gray.

  • Title and Date
    • The title "Plate 4" is written in small text at the top center of the page.
    • Below the title, the date "1850" is inscribed in larger text.
  • Sketches
    • The four sketches of trees are arranged in two rows, with two sketches in each row.
    • The sketches are drawn in a simple, yet detailed style, with the trees depicted in various shades of gray.
    • Each sketch is accompanied by a label indicating the lesson number, ranging from Lesson 12 to Lesson 16.
  • Background
    • The background of the page is a light beige color, with a subtle texture that resembles aged paper.
    • The page appears to have been stained or discolored over time, with small spots of discoloration scattered throughout.
  • Overall Impression
    • The image conveys a sense of age and history, suggesting that the book is a rare or antique volume.
    • The simple, yet detailed style of the sketches suggests that the book may be a instructional or educational text, perhaps related to art or botany.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-17

The image presents a vintage-style page featuring four illustrations of trees, accompanied by text and numbers. The page is off-white with yellowish spots, suggesting age or wear.

Tree Illustrations:

  • Four trees are depicted in a sketch-like style, with varying sizes and shapes.
  • Each tree has a unique arrangement of branches and leaves.
  • The trees are positioned in the top-left, top-right, bottom-left, and bottom-right corners of the page.

Text and Numbers:

  • In the center of the page, the text "JDH 1850" is written in black ink.
  • Above the text, the word "Plate" is visible, although the number is not legible.
  • Below the text, the words "LESSON 13," "LESSON 14," "LESSON 15," and "LESSON 16" are written in small letters, each corresponding to one of the tree illustrations.
  • Small illegible words are placed below each tree illustration.

Overall Appearance:

  • The page has a distressed appearance, with yellowish spots and a worn look.
  • The illustrations and text are rendered in a simple, yet elegant style, suggesting an educational or instructional purpose.

In summary, the image depicts a vintage-style page featuring four tree illustrations, accompanied by text and numbers. The page has a distressed appearance, with yellowish spots and a worn look, suggesting age or wear.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-02-10

The image is a black-and-white drawing of four trees on a white background. The trees are drawn with intricate details, showing the branches and leaves. The drawing is divided into four sections, with each section labeled with a number and a name. The top left section is labeled "LESSON 13," the top right section is labeled "LESSON 14," the bottom left section is labeled "LESSON 15," and the bottom right section is labeled "LESSON 16." The drawing is signed with the initials "JDH" and the year "1850."

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-02-10

The image depicts a historical document or a page from an old book, featuring four botanical illustrations of trees. Each illustration is labeled with the name of the tree species and the lesson number it corresponds to. The trees are depicted in a detailed, hand-drawn style, showcasing their foliage and structure. The page is titled "Plate 4," indicating it is part of a series. The paper shows signs of age, with some discoloration and wear, particularly noticeable around the edges and in the background. The illustrations are in shades of gray, with the trees rendered in a fine, detailed manner. The text and labels are written in a cursive script, typical of historical documents from the 19th century.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-05-30

This image is a page from a vintage botanical illustration book. It shows four detailed drawings of tree foliage, each labeled with the type of tree, lesson number and the artist's initials and the date.

Here's a breakdown:

  • Overall Composition: The image is centered around four drawings of trees, each in a different location on the page. The layout appears to be a study or guide, likely for learning how to draw trees.
  • Drawings: The drawings use a cross-hatching technique to render depth and texture. They give the appearance of being drawn with pencil or ink.
  • Labels: Each drawing is labeled with the tree species ("Elm", "Ash", "Oak"). Also labels like "Lesson 13", "Lesson 14", "Lesson 16" help identify the specific lessons or studies.
  • Text and Date: The artist's initials are "J.D.H." and the year "1850" is also included.
  • Paper: The paper has a warm, cream color. It shows signs of age like yellowing, which enhances the vintage feel.

Overall, it's a well-executed piece of historical botanical art.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-05-30

The image is a page from a botanical textbook or study guide. It features four illustrations of different tree species, labeled with their names and lesson numbers. The illustrations are drawn in a delicate, detailed style, likely from an engraving or etching.

At the top of the page, it reads "Plate 4" in small lettering. Below this, the initials "JDH" and the year "1850" are inscribed. The page is divided into quadrants, with each quadrant containing a different tree illustration.

In the top left quadrant, the illustration is labeled "LESSON 13" with the word "Elm" written underneath. In the top right quadrant, the illustration is labeled "LESSON 14" with "Ash." The bottom left quadrant is labeled "LESSON 15" with "Oak." The bottom right quadrant is labeled "LESSON 16" with "Beech."

The illustrations themselves depict the unique foliage patterns of each tree species. The drawing style is intricate and precise, using shading and line work to create depth and texture. The overall aesthetic is elegant and informative, reminiscent of botanical illustrations from the 19th century.

The page has a slightly aged appearance, with a few light stains and imperfections that add to its vintage character.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-09

The image appears to be an old, hand-drawn botanical illustration from 1850. It is labeled "Plate 4" at the top and contains four distinct sketches of what seem to be clusters of ferns or similar plant structures. Each of the four illustrations is labeled with a lesson number, ranging from 13 to 16. The initials "JDH" and the year "1850" are written in the center of the page.

Here is a detailed breakdown:

  1. Top Left (Lesson 13): This illustration shows a dense cluster of fern-like structures. The drawing is intricate, with detailed lines depicting the individual fronds.

  2. Top Right (Lesson 14): Similar to the first, this illustration also depicts a cluster of fern-like structures. The drawing is detailed, showing the complexity and arrangement of the fronds.

  3. Bottom Left (Lesson 15): This illustration continues the theme of fern clusters. The drawing is slightly less dense than the previous two but still detailed, showing the individual fronds and their arrangement.

  4. Bottom Right (Lesson 16): The final illustration in the series, this one also shows a cluster of fern-like structures. The drawing is detailed and intricate, capturing the natural form of the plants.

The paper shows signs of aging, with yellowing and some spots, indicating its historical nature. The illustrations are likely part of a botanical study or educational material from the mid-19th century.

Text analysis

Amazon

LESSON
Oak
Plate
Elm
LESSON 14
1850
14
LESSON IN
LESSON is
J.D.H
IN
Ask
LESSON ID
is
ID

Google

Plate JDH 8s0 LESSON Ls LESSON I LESSON LESSON 10
Plate
JDH
8s0
LESSON
Ls
I
10