Human Generated Data

Title

An Angel Playing a Lute, from The Presentation of Christ in the Temple, after Carpaccio

Date

1906

People

Artist: Desideri, Italian 19th-20th centuries

Artist: Edward Waldo Forbes, American 1873 - 1969

Artist after: Vittore Carpaccio, Italian 1460 - 1526

Classification

Paintings

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Edward W. Forbes, 1949.37

Copyright

© Estate of Edward Forbes

Human Generated Data

Title

An Angel Playing a Lute, from The Presentation of Christ in the Temple, after Carpaccio

People

Artist: Desideri, Italian 19th-20th centuries

Artist: Edward Waldo Forbes, American 1873 - 1969

Artist after: Vittore Carpaccio, Italian 1460 - 1526

Date

1906

Classification

Paintings

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Edward W. Forbes, 1949.37

Copyright

© Estate of Edward Forbes

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2019-04-04

Clarifai
created on 2018-03-23

people 99.7
adult 99.5
one 99.4
saint 99
religion 99
art 98.9
painting 98.7
man 98.3
book series 97.7
Renaissance 97.6
seat 95.7
Mary 95.5
book 95.2
gown (clothing) 95.1
kneeling 94.7
illustration 94.6
god 94.4
furniture 94.2
sit 94
aura 93.8

Imagga
created on 2018-03-23

sculpture 57.4
art 37.3
statue 36.2
comic book 31.5
religion 28.7
architecture 27.3
monument 24.3
old 23
ancient 22.5
culture 22.2
carving 21.9
antique 20.9
bust 20.2
religious 19.7
figure 18.8
church 18.5
god 18.2
history 17.9
temple 17.4
holy 17.3
plastic art 17.1
landmark 16.2
decoration 15.8
faith 15.3
detail 15.3
stone 15.2
tourism 14.8
golden 13.8
travel 13.4
famous 13
historic 12.8
building 12.7
print media 12.6
gold 12.3
city 11.6
palace 11.6
saint 11.5
spiritual 11.5
dollar 11.1
money 11.1
statues 10.8
bible 10.8
carved 10.8
catholic 10.7
decorative 10
traditional 10
tourist 10
currency 9.9
museum 9.8
marble 9.7
spirituality 9.6
bill 9.5
symbol 9.4
historical 9.4
finance 9.3
face 9.2
close 9.1
style 8.9
angel 8.8
belief 8.8
closeup 8.8
oriental 8.7
meditation 8.6
device 8.4
cash 8.2
wealth 8.1
shield 8.1
bank 8.1
financial 8
sculptures 7.9
prayer 7.7
dollars 7.7
stock saddle 7.7
banking 7.4
bronze 7.3
metal 7.2
covering 7.2
color 7.2

Google
created on 2018-03-23

Microsoft
created on 2018-03-23

text 97.9
book 91.8

Color Analysis

Face analysis

Amazon

Microsoft

Google

Imagga

AWS Rekognition

Age 23-38
Gender Female, 99.7%
Calm 4.1%
Happy 1.4%
Confused 0.7%
Disgusted 0.5%
Sad 92.6%
Angry 0.5%
Surprised 0.3%

Feature analysis

Amazon

Painting
Person

Clarifai

Clothing
Human face
Footwear
Human hand
Human arm

AWS Rekognition

Painting 96.4%

Categories

Imagga
created on 2018-03-23

paintings art 100%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2018-03-23

a person sitting on a book 23%
a person holding a book 22.9%
a person holding a book 22.8%

Clarifai

No captions written

Salesforce

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-04-29

a photograph of a painting of a man playing a guitar and a guitar

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip-2 on 2025-06-29

a painting of a woman playing the lute

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4 on 2024-01-24

The image features a figure dressed in a draped, vibrant red robe over a flowing green garment, giving a sense of classical attire. The figure is seated on a wooden structure and is positioned in a dynamic pose, with one foot extended forward, stepping on a platform, and the other bent at the knee, resting on the seat. The figure's arms are engaged in playing a large, stringed instrument resembling a lute, which rests on the lap, and the hands deftly touch the strings and the instrument's neck.

Below the figure, there's a small dark box with a viewing hole, possibly representing a perspective device from the Renaissance era. Adjacent to this box lies a piece of paper with Latin inscriptions, hinting at potential academic or scholarly references. The background is minimal, with dark earthy tones that highlight the figure and the luminosity of the garments. The overall composition suggests a scene from a historical or allegorical context, rich in symbolic content related to music, art, and possibly science.

Anthropic Claude

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-24

This is a classical painting depicting a musician playing a lute, a stringed instrument popular during the Renaissance period. The figure is wearing flowing robes - a rose-colored top and a silvery-gray skirt or lower garment. They are seated in a relaxed pose with bare feet, on what appears to be stone or wooden steps. The musician's posture shows them leaning over the lute in an intimate, absorbed manner while playing. The painting demonstrates the typical style and attention to detail of Renaissance art, particularly in the rendering of the fabric's folds and the careful depiction of the musical instrument. There appears to be a signature or inscription at the bottom of the painting that reads "VICTOR CARPATHIUS."

Created by claude-3-haiku-48k-20240307 on 2024-03-29

The image depicts a woman playing a lute or similar stringed instrument. She is dressed in ornate robes and appears lost in contemplation as she plays the instrument. The background features a dark, shadowy setting with some indistinct objects or frames visible. The overall mood of the painting seems pensive and introspective.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2024-12-26

This image is a painting of a man playing a lute. The man has long, wavy red hair and is wearing a loose-fitting red shirt with billowy sleeves and a flowing green skirt. He is sitting on a ledge, with his right leg crossed over his left, and his right foot resting on the ledge. His left foot is dangling in the air.

The man is holding the lute in his left hand and plucking its strings with his right hand. The lute is a large, pear-shaped instrument with a long neck and a round body. It has a light-colored wood finish and is adorned with intricate carvings on its neck and body.

In the background, there are several objects that appear to be part of a room or a stage. There is a large, rectangular object behind the man, which could be a wall or a backdrop. To the right of the man, there is a small, square object that looks like a picture frame or a mirror. On the ledge in front of the man, there is a small, white piece of paper with some writing on it.

Overall, the image suggests that the man is a musician or a performer, and that he is playing the lute as part of a concert or a show. The background objects add context to the scene, suggesting that it is taking place in a formal setting.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2024-11-23

The image depicts a painting of a young man playing a lute. The man is seated on a bench, with his left leg crossed over his right and his left arm resting on his knee. He has long, reddish-brown hair and wears a red robe over a white shirt and green pants. His right hand holds the neck of the lute, while his left hand plucks the strings.

The background of the painting features a wall with a window and a bookshelf. The overall atmosphere of the image is one of serenity and contemplation, with the young man lost in thought as he plays his instrument.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-01-04

The image is a painting of a person sitting on a stone bench, playing a musical instrument. The person is wearing a red and green outfit and has long hair. The person is barefoot and is holding a musical instrument, possibly a lute, in both hands. The person is looking down, possibly at the musical instrument. There is a piece of paper with some text on the floor.

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-01-04

The image depicts a painting of a young man playing a lute. The man is seated on a stone bench, his legs crossed, and he is dressed in a flowing green robe with a red undergarment. His long, wavy hair falls down to his shoulders, and he is looking down at the instrument he is playing. The lute is a stringed musical instrument, and the man's fingers are positioned on the strings. The painting is set against a dark background, and there is a small piece of paper with writing on it on the bench next to the man. The painting has a classical style, and the man's pose and expression suggest a sense of melancholy or introspection.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-04-26

The image is an oil painting depicting a young woman seated and playing a lute. She has long, reddish-brown hair and fair skin. She is dressed in a rose-colored robe with billowing sleeves and a draped green cloth that covers her lap and legs. Her right foot is bare, and her left foot is only partially visible beneath the cloth.

She is seated on a stone structure with rectangular frames. On the lower right, a small, open book with the name "VICTOR CARPATHIVS" can be seen.

The background is simple, with horizontal and vertical lines creating a sense of depth. The overall style of the painting is reminiscent of classical portraiture, with attention to detail in the drapery and the woman's facial expression. The lighting is soft, casting subtle shadows that enhance the contours of her figure and the lute.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-04-26

Here's a description of the image:

Overall Impression: The image is a classical painting, likely an oil on canvas, depicting a young person playing a lute. The style suggests a Renaissance or Baroque influence.

Subject and Composition:

  • Figure: A person, possibly female (the style is not very specific), is the central figure. They are seated with their legs crossed, appearing relaxed. They are focused on playing a lute, and their expression is serene and concentrated.
  • Lute: The lute is a prominent element, held in the figure's lap. The instrument is detailed and suggests a high level of artistic skill.
  • Setting: The background and setting are somewhat ambiguous but consist of layered blocks that could suggest a backdrop.

Color and Light:

  • Colors: The color palette is muted, dominated by warm tones like browns, reds, and greens. There's a sense of classical painting.
  • Light: The lighting is soft and diffused, casting gentle shadows.

Style and Technique:

  • Realism: The painting aims for realism, evident in the details of the figure and the lute.
  • Technique: The brushstrokes seem blended, suggesting a smooth and polished finish.

Additional details:

  • A small piece of paper near the bottom of the painting has some text written on it.
  • The figure is dressed in soft draping cloth in shades of red and light teal.

Overall, the painting conveys a sense of peaceful contemplation and artistic skill.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-04-25

The image depicts a painting of a young man playing a lute. The subject is seated on a stone platform, dressed in flowing garments. His attire consists of a light blue-green robe and a reddish-brown cloak draped over his shoulders. The man is barefoot, and his feet are prominently visible.

The lute he is playing is held diagonally across his body, and he appears to be focused on his music. The background is relatively dark, which helps to highlight the figure and his instrument. The lighting in the painting is soft and creates a serene atmosphere.

In the lower right corner of the painting, there is a small plaque or piece of paper with writing on it. The text reads "VICTOR CARPATIVS FACIEBAT AETATIS SVAE XXII," which translates to "Victor Carpaccio made this at the age of 22." This indicates that the painting was created by the artist Vittore Carpaccio when he was 22 years old. The overall composition and style suggest it is a work from the Renaissance period.

Qwen

Created by Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-72B-Instruct on 2025-06-26

This image is a classical painting depicting a young woman seated and playing a lute. She is dressed in a flowing, draped garment that is green and blue in color, with a red shawl draped over her shoulders. The woman has long, wavy, reddish-brown hair and is looking to her left with a serene expression. She is barefoot, and her feet are positioned on the edge of a stone or marble surface. In front of her, there is an open book with the text "VICTOR CARPATHUS" visible. The background features a dark, muted palette with some architectural elements, possibly suggesting a column or a wall with a niche. The overall style of the painting is reminiscent of Renaissance or Baroque art.

Created by Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct on 2025-06-26

This is a painting depicting a seated figure playing a lute. The figure is dressed in a red and gold robe, suggesting a historical or classical setting. The lute is held across the body, and the figure appears to be in a contemplative or focused pose, with one hand strumming the strings and the other resting on the soundboard. The background is simple, with muted colors and a wooden ledge or platform visible, on which a small book with the inscription "VICTOR GARPATIVS" is placed. The overall style of the painting, with its soft textures and subdued color palette, suggests it could be from the Renaissance or Baroque period.

Text analysis

Amazon

ARPATHIVS
VICTOR ARPATHIVS
VICTOR