Unable to open [object Object]: HTTP 0 attempting to load TileSource

Human Generated Data

Title

Study of Circles

Date

c. 1932-1933

People

Artist: Bertrand Goldberg, American 1913 - 1997

Classification

Drawings

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, Gift of the Artist, BR49.92

Human Generated Data

Title

Study of Circles

People

Artist: Bertrand Goldberg, American 1913 - 1997

Date

c. 1932-1933

Classification

Drawings

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, Gift of the Artist, BR49.92

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Clarifai
created on 2018-03-23

design 99.4
pattern 99.4
illustration 99.1
decoration 99
vector 98.6
desktop 98.4
abstract 98.3
graphic 98.1
wallpaper 98.1
art 97.3
seamless 97.1
guilloche 97
shape 97
grid 96.8
texture 96.8
element 96.7
retro 96.2
style 96.2
geometric 95.9
background 95.6

Imagga
created on 2018-03-23

arabesque 56.7
pattern 41.7
texture 41
embroidery 40.2
design 38.3
wallpaper 37.5
decoration 34.1
lace 34
floral 32.3
retro 32
graphic 30.7
art 28.4
seamless 27.6
ornament 26.7
backdrop 26.4
vintage 24
decor 23
ornate 22.9
paper 22.8
decorative 22.6
element 21.5
card 21.5
frame 19.8
flower 19.2
antique 19.1
leaf 18.7
style 18.6
textile 18
creative 17.7
old 17.4
fabric 17.4
shape 16.4
swirl 15.7
grunge 15.3
curve 14.9
elegant 14.6
color 14.5
elegance 13.4
surface 13.2
textured 13.2
artistic 13
blank 12.9
plant 12.7
border 12.7
material 11.6
scroll 11.4
tile 11.2
brown 11
template 11
repetition 10.8
silhouette 10.8
revival 10.7
ornamental 10.4
classic 10.2
modern 9.8
detail 9.7
black 9.6
openwork 9.6
celebration 9.6
old fashioned 9.5
damask 9.5
symbol 9.4
holiday 9.3
greeting 9.3
cover 9.3
foliage 9.2
scrapbook 8.7
invitation 8.7
colorful 8.6
pink 8.4
grain 8.3
rough 8.2
square 8.1
dirty 8.1
structure 7.9
circle 7.7
drawing 7.7
luxury 7.7
wall 7.7
curl 7.6
patterns 7.6
print 7.5
fashion 7.5
page 7.4
banner 7.4
backgrounds 7.3
effect 7.3
aged 7.2
shiny 7.1
interior 7.1

Google
created on 2018-03-23

pattern 78.6
line 76.9
circle 76.8
design 74.4
font 73.8
doily 67.5
area 67.2
product 66.1
material 60.3
point 54.9
symmetry 54.5
square 54.1

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Rug

Clarifai

Picture frame

AWS Rekognition

Rug 97.4%

Categories

Imagga
created on 2018-03-23

text visuals 97.3%
paintings art 1.3%
interior objects 0.8%
streetview architecture 0.6%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2018-03-23

a close up of a logo 64%
a close up of a piece of paper 50.4%
close up of a logo 50.3%

Clarifai

No captions written

Salesforce

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-11

a photograph of a drawing of a square shaped object with a circle of circles

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip-2 on 2025-06-28

a drawing of circles on paper with red lines

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-03-05

The image is an artwork consisting of numerous overlapping circles. These circles appear to be hand-drawn in red and black, with variations in the thickness and darkness of the lines. Some circles are more defined in solid color, while others are faint, suggesting perhaps lighter pressure or a drier medium was used for those.

The pattern of the circles isn't rigidly uniform; it has a more organic structure with varying sizes and levels of overlap. The arrangement has a loose grid-like pattern, but the imperfect overlap and hand-drawn quality offer a sense of movement and dynamism. There is no discernible background aside from the paper or canvas the circles are drawn upon, which seems off-white or light in color. There are slight imperfections and irregularities in the drawing that contribute to its handcrafted feel.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-03-05

The image features an abstract drawing composed of a repetitive pattern of circles. The circles are primarily outlined in black and red lines. The drawing covers a light beige or off-white background. Some circles are slightly overlapping, creating a sense of depth and complexity. The overall arrangement of the circles appears to form a grid-like pattern, but with slight irregularities and variations in the spacing and positioning of the circles. The dual-color scheme of black and red adds a dynamic element to the otherwise simple geometric design.

Anthropic Claude

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-25

This is an abstract geometric drawing consisting of multiple circles arranged in a grid-like pattern. The circles are drawn in both red and black/gray lines, creating an overlapping effect. The circles appear to be roughly the same size and are arranged in rows and columns across the paper. Some circles are more boldly drawn than others, particularly one in the bottom right corner which appears darker and more defined. The overall composition has a rhythmic, repetitive quality typical of minimalist or pattern-based artwork. The background appears to be off-white or beige paper, giving the piece a subtle, understated quality.

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2024-12-29

This image appears to be an abstract drawing or illustration composed of numerous overlapping and intersecting circles or oval shapes. The circles are drawn in various shades of gray, ranging from light to dark, creating a sense of depth and texture. The placement and overlapping of the circles give the overall image a chaotic, yet somewhat organized and geometric appearance. There is a single black circle near the bottom of the image that stands out from the rest. The drawing has a vintage or hand-drawn quality, conveying a sense of thoughtfulness and intentionality in its creation.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2024-12-29

The image shows an abstract geometric pattern made up of many overlapping circles drawn in red and gray lines on a beige background. The circles vary slightly in size and appear to form a dense, irregular grid or lattice structure across the page. In the lower right corner, there is a small black circle, possibly the artist's signature or mark. The overall composition has an organic, hand-drawn quality while exploring mathematical repetition and complex visual rhythms.

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2024-12-29

This is an abstract geometric drawing consisting of multiple circles arranged in a grid-like pattern. The circles are drawn in both red and black/gray lines, creating an overlapping effect. The circles appear to be roughly the same size and are loosely drawn by hand, giving the piece an organic, sketchy quality despite its structured arrangement. The overall composition fills most of the paper, with the circles forming approximately 10 rows and 12 columns. Some circles appear more boldly drawn than others, and there's a slightly darker, more emphasized circle in the bottom right corner of the composition.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-11

The image presents a visually striking composition of overlapping circles, with a dominant beige background. The circles are drawn in various sizes and colors, including black, red, and gray, creating a dynamic and intricate pattern. The use of different colors adds depth and visual interest to the image, while the overlapping circles create a sense of movement and energy.

The overall effect is one of complexity and visual stimulation, inviting the viewer to explore the intricate details of the composition. The image's use of color and pattern creates a sense of tension and release, drawing the viewer's eye through the composition and encouraging them to engage with the artwork on a deeper level.

The image's abstract nature allows for multiple interpretations, making it a thought-provoking piece that invites the viewer to consider the relationships between form, color, and pattern. Overall, the image is a captivating and engaging work of art that rewards close observation and contemplation.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-11

The image depicts a piece of artwork featuring a collection of circles drawn in red and black pencil on a beige background. The circles are arranged in a seemingly random pattern, with some overlapping each other. The overall effect is one of chaos and disorder, as if the artist has simply thrown the circles onto the page without any thought or planning.

Despite the apparent randomness of the arrangement, there is a certain beauty to the image. The use of red and black pencils adds a sense of depth and contrast to the piece, while the beige background provides a neutral backdrop that allows the circles to take center stage.

Overall, the image is a thought-provoking and visually striking representation of the power of art to create beauty out of chaos. It challenges the viewer to look beyond the surface level and consider the deeper meaning and symbolism behind the image.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-01-11

The image features an abstract drawing composed of numerous overlapping circles. The circles are drawn in two different colors: red and black. The circles are arranged in a grid-like pattern, with each row and column containing a consistent number of circles. The drawing is set on a white background, which contrasts with the red and black colors of the circles. The circles vary in size, with some being larger and others smaller, creating a dynamic and visually engaging composition.

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-01-11

The image shows a drawing of a large number of circles. The circles are arranged in a grid-like pattern. Each circle is drawn with a red and black line. The circles vary in size, with some being larger than others. The circles are arranged in a way that creates a sense of depth and movement. The drawing is on a piece of paper with a white background.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-06-04

The image appears to be an abstract drawing on a light beige or off-white paper. The artwork consists of numerous hand-drawn circles arranged in a grid-like pattern, with some circles overlapping each other.

The circles are drawn in two distinct colors: red and black (or a very dark gray). The red circles seem to form the initial grid, while the black circles fill in the spaces between them. There is also a thin, looping line that wanders across the entire grid, connecting some of the circles.

In the lower right corner of the drawing, there are two isolated circles: one large and one small. The larger circle is only partially filled, while the smaller circle is completely filled with black. The overall impression is one of careful, repetitive mark-making and an exploration of geometric patterns.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-06-04

The image is a drawing on a rectangular piece of paper, dominated by a grid-like pattern of overlapping circles.

  • Circles: The circles are the primary visual element. They are drawn with a loose, hand-drawn quality, and they vary in size. Some circles are drawn in red, while others are in black. The circles overlap, creating a layered effect.
  • Grid: The circles are arranged in a grid-like formation, although the pattern isn't perfectly regular. This grid-like structure provides a framework for the composition.
  • Lines: Thin, curved lines meander across the drawing, connecting and intersecting the circles.
  • Color: The limited use of red and black provides a contrast.
  • Margins: The paper has a slightly off-white tone. There's a blank margin.
  • Texture: The overall effect suggests a sketch or a study.
  • Isolated Circles: In the bottom right corner of the artwork there are two isolated circles, one filled in and one hollow, separated from the larger grid-like arrangement.

The artwork looks like an abstract study of form, pattern, and the interplay of overlapping shapes.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-05-29

The image features a drawing composed of numerous overlapping circles of varying sizes. The circles are drawn in black and red, with the black circles appearing more prominent and darker, while the red circles are lighter and less distinct. The circles are arranged in a seemingly random pattern, overlapping and intersecting with each other, creating a complex and intricate visual effect. The background is a light beige or off-white color, which contrasts with the darker circles and allows them to stand out. The overall impression is one of a detailed, abstract design that emphasizes repetition and layering.

Qwen

No captions written