Unable to open [object Object]: HTTP 0 attempting to load TileSource

Human Generated Data

Title

Exercise in Value Progression: Concentric Circles

Date

1922-1923

People

Artist: Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack, Australian 1893 - 1965

Classification

Drawings

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, Association Fund, BR49.720

Copyright

© Kaj Delugan

Human Generated Data

Title

Exercise in Value Progression: Concentric Circles

People

Artist: Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack, Australian 1893 - 1965

Date

1922-1923

Classification

Drawings

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, Association Fund, BR49.720

Copyright

© Kaj Delugan

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Clarifai
created on 2018-02-10

no person 95.6
industry 91.3
round 91.2
building 91.1
design 90.8
architecture 89.6
desktop 88
expression 86.7
city 86.7
art 86.6
urban 84.3
technology 83.9
abstract 83.5
round out 83.4
old 83.2
modern 82.3
pattern 82.1
sight 82
texture 81.3
retro 80.7

Imagga
created on 2018-02-10

stucco 56.1
circle 26.7
machine 22.3
music 21.7
wheel 19.8
light 18.7
audio 18.2
round 18.1
sound 17.8
close 16.5
technology 16.3
speaker 15.5
bass 14.8
motion 14.6
device 14.4
pattern 14.4
shape 14.2
design 14.1
equipment 14
texture 13.2
reflection 13
wave 13
art 12.7
disco 12.5
graphic 12.4
studio 12.2
digital 12.1
metal 12.1
loudspeaker 11.9
disc 11.7
retro 11.5
black 11.4
liquid 11.3
entertainment 11
3d 10.8
loud 10.8
ripple 10.5
mechanism 10.5
swirl 10.1
drink 10
stereo 9.8
volume 9.7
party 9.5
industry 9.4
drop 9.1
transparent 9
color 8.9
computer 8.8
closeup 8.8
record 8.7
colorful 8.6
storage 8.6
grunge 8.5
dynamic 8.5
wallpaper 8.4
blur 8.4
plastic 8.3
industrial 8.2
brown 8.1
cool 8
shiny 7.9
treble 7.9
curve 7.9
disk 7.8
line 7.7
old 7.7
musical 7.7
power 7.6
form 7.4
effect 7.3
detail 7.2
hole 7.2
lines 7.2
dome 7.1

Google
created on 2018-02-10

Microsoft
created on 2018-02-10

indoor 85.5

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Rug

Clarifai

No features identified

AWS Rekognition

Rug 90.5%

Categories

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2018-02-10

a black sign with white text 16%
a black sign with white letters 14.7%
a close up of a white wall 14.6%

Clarifai

Created by general-english-image-caption-clip on 2025-07-10

digital art selected for the #.

Salesforce

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-02

a photograph of a painting of a circular object with a circular object

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip-2 on 2025-06-29

a black and white photo of a circular design

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2024-12-30

The image depicts a geometric, monochromatic design featuring concentric circles. The circles start with a black circle at the center and progressively transition to lighter shades of gray as they expand outward. The outermost circle is white. The entire pattern appears on a rectangular gray background, which shows signs of wear and tear, particularly along the edges where the paint is chipped and peeling. The overall look is somewhat abstract and can be seen as a modern or contemporary piece of art playing with shades, light, and symmetry.

Created by gpt-4 on 2024-11-29

The image you provided displays an abstract artistic concept featuring concentric circles. These circles create a sense of depth, making it appear as though one is looking into a tunnel or hole. The colors alternate between shades of gray and white, with the innermost circle being a deep black, enhancing the tunnel-like illusion. The edges of the artwork show wear and damage, with tears and creases, suggesting that the material is aged or has been handled frequently. The background appears to be an off-white or cream color with visible adhesive residue along the edges, indicating that the artwork may have been previously fixed to another surface. The overall composition exhibits a strong graphic quality and is reminiscent of the Op Art movement, which plays with visual perception.

Anthropic Claude

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-25

This is an abstract geometric artwork featuring concentric circles in grayscale. The circles radiate outward from a dark center point, gradually becoming lighter in shade until reaching white at the outermost ring. The circular pattern is set against a gray square background. The image appears to be somewhat aged or weathered, with visible wear and tear along the edges. This type of design is reminiscent of Op Art (Optical Art) from the mid-20th century, which often used geometric patterns to create visual effects. The gradual gradation from dark to light creates an illusion of depth, making the center appear to recede into the background while the lighter outer rings seem to advance forward.

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2024-12-26

This image appears to be an abstract artwork featuring concentric circles in grayscale. The circles radiate outward from a dark center point, gradually becoming lighter in shade until reaching a white outer ring. The circular pattern is set against a gray background, and the image shows some wear or aging, particularly visible along the edges where there appears to be some deterioration or damage to the paper or material it's created on. The composition creates an optical illusion of depth, making it appear like a tunnel or vortex receding into space. This type of design is characteristic of minimalist or op art (optical art) from the mid-20th century.

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2024-11-27

The image depicts a series of concentric circles in shades of gray against a dark background. The circles gradually increase in width and decrease in intensity from the center outward, creating a tunnel-like effect. The image has a minimalist, geometric aesthetic and appears to be a work of abstract art or optical illusion.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2024-12-24

The image presents a grayscale concentric circle design, with the outermost circle being white and gradually transitioning to black at the center. The circles are evenly spaced and appear to be hand-painted, as evidenced by the visible brushstrokes and texture. The background of the image is a dark gray color, which provides a striking contrast to the lighter shades of the circles.

The overall effect of the image is one of simplicity and elegance, with the clean lines and precise geometry creating a sense of order and harmony. The use of grayscale tones adds a sense of sophistication and subtlety, making the image suitable for a variety of contexts, from artistic expression to design and architecture.

In terms of technical details, the image appears to be a digital representation of a physical artwork, possibly created using a combination of traditional media and digital tools. The resolution of the image is high enough to reveal the texture and brushstrokes of the original artwork, suggesting that it was scanned or photographed at a high quality.

Overall, the image is a beautiful example of geometric abstraction, showcasing the power of simple shapes and colors to create a compelling and visually striking composition.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2024-11-26

The image presents a square painting featuring a concentric circle design, with a central black circle surrounded by progressively lighter shades of gray. The outermost circle is white, creating a striking contrast against the darker background.

Key Features:

  • Concentric Circles: The painting features a series of concentric circles, each with a distinct shade of gray, ranging from black at the center to white at the outermost edge.
  • Background: The background of the painting is a dark gray color, which provides a subtle contrast to the lighter shades of gray in the concentric circles.
  • Composition: The overall composition of the painting is simple yet effective, with the concentric circles creating a sense of depth and visual interest.
  • Color Scheme: The color scheme of the painting is primarily monochromatic, with shades of gray dominating the palette. The addition of white in the outermost circle adds a touch of brightness and contrast.
  • Style: The style of the painting is reminiscent of abstract art, with a focus on geometric shapes and bold color choices.

Overall Impression:

The image presents a striking and thought-provoking piece of art that invites the viewer to contemplate the relationship between light and dark, as well as the power of color to evoke emotion and mood. The use of concentric circles creates a sense of movement and energy, drawing the viewer's eye inward and outward in a dynamic dance.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-01-10

The image depicts an abstract artwork, primarily composed of concentric circular forms. The central element is a large, dark circular void, surrounded by numerous concentric rings of varying shades of gray. The rings gradually lighten as they move outward from the center, creating a gradient effect. The outermost ring is white, and the background around the circle is a solid, darker gray. The edges of the image show signs of wear and aging, with some flaking and discoloration, suggesting the artwork is on an aged surface.

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-01-10

The image depicts a circular object with a spiral pattern that is painted in a grayscale color scheme. The spiral appears to be a tunnel with a dark center, giving the illusion of depth and perspective. The spiral is painted with a combination of gray and white colors, creating a sense of movement and depth. The background of the image is a solid gray color, which provides a contrast to the spiral and emphasizes its shape and pattern.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-04-28

Here's a description of the image:

Overall:

The image is a minimalist abstract composition. It features a series of concentric circles, creating an optical illusion of depth or a tunnel effect. The color palette is limited to shades of gray, white, and black.

Details:

  • Concentric Circles: The artwork is centered around a series of evenly spaced, concentric circles. These circles gradually decrease in size as they move toward the center.
  • Color Gradient: Each ring has a different shade of gray, ranging from white on the outside to dark gray or black at the innermost circle. This color gradient contributes to the perception of depth.
  • Background: The circles are set against a dark gray background. The edges of the background have some age-related wear and tear (cracking/peeling) that adds to the artwork's texture and suggests it may be an older piece.
  • Illusion: The arrangement of the circles and the color gradient create a strong illusion of depth, like looking into a tunnel or a deep hole.
  • Materials: The piece appears to be a painted artwork on paper or a similar surface.

Overall Impression:

The artwork is simple yet captivating. The starkness of the color palette and the repetitive concentric circles create a visually intriguing and possibly meditative effect. It has an austere and somewhat somber quality.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-04-28

The image is a monochromatic painting or illustration featuring concentric circles. The circles are rendered in shades of gray, progressing from light gray on the outer edge to nearly black at the center. The effect is an optical illusion of depth, creating the impression of a tunnel or vortex drawing the viewer's eye inward. The background surrounding the circles is a similar shade of dark gray. The artwork appears to be painted on a surface that shows signs of age or damage, such as tears and imperfections along the edges. The composition is simple yet striking, relying on the contrast and gradation of tones to create a dynamic visual effect.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-05-24

The image depicts an abstract painting with a central circular design composed of concentric rings. The rings alternate in shades of gray, creating a gradient effect that transitions from lighter shades on the outer rings to darker shades towards the center. The innermost circle is the darkest, almost black, giving the impression of depth and a tunnel-like effect. The background of the painting is a dark gray, which contrasts with the lighter, off-white border around the canvas. The edges of the painting show signs of wear and tear, with some peeling and cracking visible, indicating its age or exposure to elements over time. The overall composition is minimalistic and geometric, focusing on the interplay of light and dark tones within the circular forms.

Qwen

Created by Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct on 2025-07-11

The image is a central composition featuring a series of concentric circles. The circles vary in size and are painted in shades of gray, creating a gradient effect from lightest to darkest. The outermost circle is white, followed by lighter gray, and then darker gray, culminating in a black central circle. The background appears to be a dark gray or black, providing a stark contrast to the lighter tones of the circles. The image has a simple yet striking design, likely intended to evoke a sense of depth and visual interest. The edges of the image show signs of wear, with cracks and peeling paint, suggesting it is an older work of art.

Created by Qwen/Qwen2.5-VL-72B-Instruct on 2025-07-11

This image appears to be an abstract artwork featuring concentric circles. The circles are arranged in a gradient of shades from white to black, creating a tunnel-like effect that draws the viewer's eye towards the center. The background is a solid gray color, which contrasts with the white and black circles. The edges of the circles are not perfectly smooth, adding a hand-drawn or painted quality to the image. The artwork seems to be on a piece of paper or canvas with some visible wear and tear, including scratches and creases, suggesting it might be an older piece or intentionally distressed. The overall effect is one of depth and movement, inviting the viewer to explore the visual illusion created by the circular patterns.