Human Generated Data

Title

How the Dictatorship of the Parties Can Be Overcome

Date

1971

People

Artist: Joseph Beuys, German 1921 - 1986

Publisher: art intermedia, Cologne,

Classification

Multiples

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, The Willy and Charlotte Reber Collection, Louise Haskell Daly Fund, 1995.247

Copyright

© Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn

Human Generated Data

Title

How the Dictatorship of the Parties Can Be Overcome

People

Artist: Joseph Beuys, German 1921 - 1986

Publisher: art intermedia, Cologne,

Date

1971

Classification

Multiples

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, The Willy and Charlotte Reber Collection, Louise Haskell Daly Fund, 1995.247

Copyright

© Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2023-10-24

Advertisement 90.8
Poster 90.8
Can 60.8
Tin 60.8

Clarifai
created on 2018-08-20

tag 98.7
layout 98.6
information 98.5
World Wide Web 97.9
text 97.8
template 97.7
page 97.3
label 96.1
wheel 96
presentation 95.9
bill 95
booklet 94.1
facts 94
arrow 93.8
steps 93.7
procedure 92.9
number 92.5
navigation 91.9
diagram 91.5
graphic 91.4

Imagga
created on 2018-08-20

phonograph record 70.6
diagram 43.3
definition 40.2
associated 39.4
association 39.4
graphic 38.7
conceptual 37.9
element 37.2
advertise 36
advertising 35.5
creative 35.3
cloud 35.3
decorative 35.1
advertisement 34.7
backdrop 34.6
decor 34.5
cover 34.2
idea 33.8
design 33.8
business 33.4
data 31.1
decoration 30.4
art 29.6
drawing 29.2
collection 28.9
brochure 27.3
information 26.6
artwork 26.6
representation 25.6
composition 25.4
compact disk 25.4
carpet 25.3
collage 25.1
copy 23.9
letter 23.8
circle 22.4
keywords 20.7
global 18.2
mix 17.3
earth 16.5
slide rule 15.9
icon 15
ornament 14.7
mosaic 14.1
form 13.9
more 13.7
compass 13.4
modern 13.3
ornate 12.8
sign 12.8
analog computer 12.7
analysis 12.7
computer 12.5
globe 12
money 11.9
paper 11.8
map 11.7
currency 11.7
vintage 11.6
equipment 11.4
device 11.2
black 10.8
magnetic compass 10.7
instrument 10.6
exchange 10.5
old 10.4
health 10.4
antique 10.4
bowl 10.2
symbol 10.1
ellipse 9.9
retro 9.8
circular 9.7
bank 9.6
day 9.4
finance 9.3
market 8.9
best 8.8
ball 8.7
life 8.6
card 8.5
city 8.3
pattern 8.2
office 8
financial 8
text 7.9
find 7.8
info 7.8
stamp 7.7
industry 7.7
grunge 7.7
frame 7.5
shape 7.4
new 7.3

Google
created on 2018-08-20

font 60.5
label 54.1

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Can
Can 60.8%

Categories

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2018-08-20

a screenshot of a cell phone 66.8%
a close up of a device 66.7%
a close up of a logo 66.6%

Clarifai
created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-25

-100%

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-11

The image presents a circular diagram divided into two halves, each representing a distinct political ideology. The top half is colored green and labeled "Demokratie," while the bottom half is colored orange and labeled "Nein." The diagram features a central circle with a black border, surrounded by a series of concentric circles containing various words and phrases in German.

Key Features:

  • Central Circle: The central circle contains the word "Demokratie" in white text on a black background.
  • Concentric Circles: The concentric circles surrounding the central circle contain a mix of words and phrases in German, including:
    • "Souveran"
    • "Das Volk"
    • "Volksabstimmung"
    • "Verfassung"
    • "Bundesversammlung"
    • "Gesetzgebung"
    • "Verwaltung"
    • "Rechtsprechung"
    • "Interessenvertretung"
    • "Menschenrechte"
    • "Haben"
    • "Sein"
    • "Repräsentanz"
    • "Volksvertretung"
    • "Staat"
    • "Geld und Macht!"
    • "Souveran"
    • "Parteien"
    • "Hauptfunktionen"
    • "Verfassung"
    • "Legislative"
    • "Exekutive"
    • "Judikative"
    • "Das Volk"
    • "Und der Mensch?"
    • "Parteineinfluss"
    • "Auf die politische Willensbildung"
  • Color Scheme: The diagram features a color scheme with the top half in green and the bottom half in orange.
  • Background: The background of the diagram is white, with a gray border around the edges.

Overall Impression:

The diagram appears to be a political infographic, likely created to illustrate the differences between democratic and non-democratic systems. The use of a circular shape and concentric circles creates a sense of symmetry and balance, while the color scheme and labeling help to distinguish between the two ideologies. The inclusion of various words and phrases in German adds a layer of complexity and nuance to the diagram, suggesting that it may be intended for an audience familiar with the language.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-11

The image depicts a poster with a circular chart, divided into three sections: green, red, and black. The chart is titled "EIN VERGLEICH ZWEIER GESELLSCHAFTSFORMEN" (A Comparison of Two Social Forms) and features a central section labeled "DEMOKRATIE" (Democracy). The green section is labeled "JA" (Yes), while the red section is labeled "NEIN" (No).

The chart appears to be a comparison between democratic and non-democratic systems, with the green section representing the benefits of democracy and the red section representing the drawbacks of non-democracy. The black section serves as a border between the two, highlighting the differences between the two systems.

The poster also includes text in German, which translates to "A Comparison of Two Social Forms" and "Democracy vs. Non-Democracy." The overall design of the poster suggests that it was created to educate people about the importance of democracy and the dangers of non-democratic systems.

In summary, the image depicts a poster with a circular chart comparing democratic and non-democratic systems, highlighting the benefits of democracy and the drawbacks of non-democracy.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-06-04

The image is a poster that appears to be a political campaign material. The poster is titled "EIN VERGLEICH ZWEI GESELLSCHAFTSFORMEN" which translates to "A Comparison of Two Forms of Society." The poster is divided into two sections, with the left section labeled "JA" (Yes) and the right section labeled "NEIN" (No). The poster shows a circular diagram with the words "Demokratie" (Democracy) in the center, surrounded by various terms related to political systems and governance. The poster is likely advocating for a particular form of government, possibly direct democracy, as opposed to a party state. The poster also includes a contact information for the organization "Organisation der Nichtwähler für freie Volksabstimmungen" (Organization of Non-Voters for Free Referendums).

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-06-04

The image is a poster with a political theme, created by Joseph Beuys, a renowned German artist and activist. The poster is titled "EIN VERGLEICH ZWIER GESELLSCHAFTSFORMEN" (A Comparison of Two Societal Forms). It features a circular design divided into two sections, each representing a different societal form. The upper section is labeled "JA" (Yes) and is colored green, while the lower section is labeled "NEIN" (No) and is colored red.

In the green section, the text reads "DIREKTE DEMOKRATIE" (Direct Democracy) and includes phrases such as "SOUVERÄN DAS VOLK" (Sovereign People), "VOLKSABSTIMMUNG" (Popular Vote), and "VERGASSUNG" (Gasification), among others. The red section, labeled "PARTEINSTAAT" (Party State), includes phrases like "GELD UND MACHT!" (Money and Power!), "PARTEIEINFLUSS" (Party Influence), and "DAS VOLK" (The People), among others.

The poster also includes a contact information section for the "Organisation der Nichtwähler für freie Volksabstimmung" (Organization of Non-Voters for Free Popular Vote), with a phone number, address, and account number. The poster is printed on a transparent plastic sheet, suggesting it was intended for display or distribution.

The overall design and content of the poster convey a critical view of the party state system, advocating for direct democracy as a more desirable societal form. The use of contrasting colors and clear, bold text emphasizes the comparison between the two systems.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-06-05

Here's a description of the image based on the provided information:

Overall Impression:

The image is a photograph of a piece of artwork, specifically a printed design on what appears to be a plastic bag. The design is a diagram comparing two forms of government: "Direkte Demokratie" (Direct Democracy) and "Parteienstaat" (Party State). The design is visually stark, using mainly black, white, green, and red colors.

Text and Layout:

  • Title: The title at the top reads "EIN VERGLEICH ZWEIER GESELLSCHAFTSFORMEN" (A Comparison of Two Forms of Society).

  • Labels "JA" and "NEIN": Large "JA" (Yes) and "NEIN" (No) labels on the upper left and lower left, respectively, suggest a question or opinion being addressed. "JA" is associated with direct democracy, and "NEIN" is associated with party state.

  • Diagram: The central element is a circular diagram divided into two halves. The upper half is green and the lower half is red. Each half contains a list of concepts and phrases.

  • Direct Democracy (Green Half): The green half focuses on concepts like:

    • "DAS VOLK" (The People) as sovereign
    • "VOLKSABSTIMMUNG" (Referendum)
    • "VERFASSUNG" (Constitution)
    • "GESETZGEBUNG" (Legislation)
    • "VERWALTUNG" (Administration)
    • "RECHTSPRECHUNG" (Jurisprudence)
    • "INTERESSENGRUPPEN" (Interest Groups)
    • The idea that in a true democracy, all people have rights.
  • Party State (Red Half): The red half emphasizes the dominance of parties and the associated issues:

    • "GELD UND MACHT!" (Money and Power!)
    • "SOUVERÄN: PARTEIEN" (Sovereign: Parties)
    • "HAUPTFUNKTIONÄRE" (Principal Functionaries)
    • It suggests that decisions are controlled by parties, with limited input from the people.
  • Text Under the Diagram:

    • "NUR ALS WÄHLER UND ALS STEUERZAHLER INTERESSANT" (Only of Interest as Voters and Taxpayers).
    • "- VOLKSEINFLUSS" (People's Influence) and "PARTEIENEINFLUSS -" (Party Influence), pointing out their effects on political will.
  • Other Text:

    • On the top right, it gives information on an organization for free referendums.
    • At the bottom, information about the artist and work are written.

Visual Elements:

  • Colors: The green and red color scheme reinforces the contrasting ideas (green often being associated with positive, natural, or democratic values, and red with caution or potential problems related to party control).

  • Arrows: Arrows show which form of government the given section leads to, either democracy or party state.

Interpretation:

The artwork is clearly a critique of a party state, contrasting it negatively with the concept of direct democracy. The diagram is designed to visually and textually highlight the differences and perceived shortcomings of a system where political parties hold excessive power, rather than the direct involvement of the people.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-06-05

The image is a political poster from 1971 by Joseph Beuys, comparing direct democracy and a "Party State". It is designed as a circular diagram, with "JA" (Yes) for direct democracy at the top and "NEIN" (No) for the party state at the bottom.

Key elements and their positions:

  • Top (Green - "JA" for Direct Democracy):
    • Lists features of direct democracy, such as popular sovereignty ("Das Volk"), popular vote (Volksabstimmung), a constitution (Verfassung), and the right to choose representatives and the ability to dismiss them through a veto.
    • Features the slogan "In Einer Wirklichen DEMOKRATIE" ("In a Real Democracy").
  • Bottom (Red - "NEIN" for Party State):
    • Lists features of the party state, such as party control ("Parteien"), control over money and power, control of legislative, executive, and judicial functions, and diminishing importance of the individual as a voter.
    • Features the slogan "Geld und Macht" ("Money and Power").
  • Arrows and relationships:
    • Arrows connect elements across the diagram, visually illustrating relationships and contrasts between the two systems.
  • Other elements:
    • At the top, there's the logo of the "Organization of Non-Voters for Free Popular Vote" (Organisation der Nichtwähler für Freie Volksabstimmung) with contact details.
    • At the bottom: A note saying "Nur als Wähler und als Steuerzahler Interessant" ("Only as a voter and as a taxpayer interesting")
    • Also, the phrase "-Volkseinfluss (People's Influence)" in green color and "Parteieneinfluss- (Party influence)" in red color.

Overall message:
The poster advocates for direct democracy by contrasting it with the perceived drawbacks of a party state, using a clear, visually engaging design to present its argument. It encourages people to vote for direct democracy.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-09

The image is a political poster from 1971 designed by Joseph Beuys. It is titled "Ein Vergleich zweier Gesellschaftsformen," which translates to "A Comparison of Two Societal Forms." The poster contrasts direct democracy with a party state system.

Key Elements:

  1. Title and Headers:

    • The top of the poster reads "EIN VERGLEICH ZWEIER GESELLSCHAFTSFORMEN" (A Comparison of Two Societal Forms).
    • On the left side, it says "DIREKTE DEMOKRATIE" (Direct Democracy).
    • On the right side, it says "ORGANISATION DER NICHTWÄHLER FÜR FREIE VOLKSABSTIMMUNG UND DIREKTE INFORMATION DÜSSELDORF" (Organization of Non-Voters for Free Referendum and Direct Information Düsseldorf).
  2. Visual Comparison:

    • The poster is divided into two main sections:
      • The upper section is labeled "JA" (Yes) and represents direct democracy.
      • The lower section is labeled "NEIN" (No) and represents a party state.
    • A circular diagram in the center visually compares the two systems.
  3. Circular Diagram:

    • Upper Half (Green):
      • Labeled "DEMOKRATIE" (Democracy).
      • Keywords include "SOUVERÄN: DAS VOLK" (Sovereign: The People), "VOLKSABSTIMMUNG" (Referendum), "VERFASSUNG" (Constitution), "FUNDESVERSAMMLUNG" (Founding Assembly), "GESETZGEBUNG" (Legislation), "VERWALTUNG" (Administration), "RECHTSPRECHUNG" (Judiciary), "INTERESSENGRUPPEN" (Interest Groups), "MENSCHEN" (People), "IN EINER WIRKLICHEN DEMOKRATIE" (In a Real Democracy).
      • The text emphasizes the people's direct involvement and sovereignty.
    • Lower Half (Red):
      • Labeled "PARTEIENSTAAT" (Party State).
      • Keywords include "GELD UND MACHT" (Money and Power), "SOUVERÄN: PARTEIEN" (Sovereign: Parties), "VERFASSUNG" (Constitution), "FUNDESVERSAMMLUNG" (Founding Assembly), "LEGISLATIVE" (Legislative), "EXEKUTIVE" (Executive), "JUDICATIVE" (Judiciary), "DAS VOLK UND DER MENSCH" (The People and the Individual).
      • The text highlights the control by political parties and the influence of money and power.
  4. Bottom Text:

    • The bottom section includes a statement: "NUR ALS WÄHLER UND ALS STEUERZAHLER INTERESSANT" (Only Interesting as Voters and Taxpayers).
    • It contrasts "VOLKSEINFLUSS" (People's Influence) in green with "PARTEIENEINFLUSS" (Party Influence) in red.
    • The phrase "AUF DIE POLITISCHE WILLENSBILDUNG" (On Political Will Formation) is also present.
  5. Additional Information:

    • The poster includes contact information for the organization: "ANDREASSTR. 25, TELEFON 4439, DÜSSELDORF, KONTO: DEUTSCHE BANK NR. 8431314."
    • It is noted that the poster was produced by Joseph Beuys, art intermedia EDITION, and was printed on polyethylene with flexographic printing, with a print run of 10,000 copies in 1971.

Summary:

The poster is a visual and textual comparison between direct democracy and a party state system. It advocates for direct democracy, emphasizing the sovereignty of the people and their direct involvement in political processes, while criticizing the party state system for being controlled by political parties and influenced by money and power.

Text analysis

Amazon

JA
EIN
ZWEIER
EINER
DER
NR:
FÜR
EIN VERGLEICH ZWEIER GESELLSCHAFTSFORMEN
TEL:
DIREKTE
VERGLEICH
39
DEMOKRATIE
NR: 8431314
25
DIREKTE DEMOKRATIE
ORGANISATION DER NICHTWÄHLER
FÜR FREIE VOLKSABSTIMMUNG
8431314
DEUTSCHE
GESELLSCHAFTSFORMEN
BANK
WIRKLICHEN
FREIE
NICHTWÄHLER
KONTO: DEUTSCHE BANK
ANDREASSTR. 25
48
IN
VOLK
TEL: 1 48 39
ALS
ORGANISATION
WIR
KONTO:
ABWAHL!
DÜSSELDORF
LTUNG
VOLKSABSTIMMUNG
ALLE!
MENSCHEN
SEINE
MIT
VERWA
ANDREASSTR.
DAS
SIND
HABEN
RICHTER
WÄHLT
UM
GENUGT
UND
REPRASENTANZ
NUR
VOLKSVETO
BEAMTEN
SOZIALE
IST
DIE
KEINE
POLITISCHE
INFORMATIONSSTELLE
GEHT
SICH
AUCH
NICHT!
VERFASSUNG
EIN ENTSCHEIDEND
ALLE
SOUVERANE
NICHT
VOLKSA
ES
ENTSCHEIDEND
PARTEIBUCH
FREIES
VOLK GIBT
1
SETZGEBUNG
GE SETZGEBUNG
FACHMINISTER
DEMOKRATISCHE
GE
ERESSENGRUPPEN
RECHTSPRECHUNG VERWA LTUNG
PARTEIGANGER
RECHTE.
ÜBER
RECHTSPRECHUNG
SELBST!
:DAS VOLK
ALLE,
UNABHANGIGE
SOUVERÁN
VOLKSA BSTIMMUNG
PARTEILOSE!
:DAS
BUNDESVERSAMMLUNG
BSTIMMUNG
INT

Google

EIN VERGLEICH ZWEIER GESELLSCHAFTSFORMEN DIREKTE DEMOKRATIE ORGANISATION DER NICHTWÄHLER FÜR FREIE VOLKSABSTIMMUNG INFORMATIONSSTELLE DÜSSELDORF ANDREASSTR. 25 TEL: 148 39 KONTO: DEUTSCHE BANK NR: 8431314 SOUVERAN DAS VOLK VOLKSABSTIMMU ERFASSUNC INDESVERSAMMLU GESETZGEBr 40 VERWALTUN TSPRECHUN MENSC IN EINER WIRKLICHE DEMOKRATIE PARTEIENSTAAT GELD UND MACHT UVER HE HAUPTUNN ENNOIEUNDESVERSAM ASSU LEGISLATIVE UTIVE JUDIKATIVE NEIN UND DER MEN NUR ALS WAHLER UND ALS STEUERZAHLER INTERESSANT ■一VOLKSEINFLUSS PARTEIENEINFLUSs AUF DIE POLITISCHE WILLENSBILDUNG Joseph Beuys, art intermedia EDITION, Tragetasche aus Polyäthglen mit Filzplastik, 1. Auflage 10000 Exemplare, 1971 107
EIN
VERGLEICH
ZWEIER
GESELLSCHAFTSFORMEN
DIREKTE
DEMOKRATIE
ORGANISATION
DER
NICHTWÄHLER
FÜR
FREIE
VOLKSABSTIMMUNG
INFORMATIONSSTELLE
DÜSSELDORF
ANDREASSTR.
25
TEL:
148
39
KONTO:
DEUTSCHE
BANK
NR:
8431314
SOUVERAN
DAS
VOLK
VOLKSABSTIMMU
ERFASSUNC
INDESVERSAMMLU
GESETZGEBr
40
VERWALTUN
TSPRECHUN
MENSC
IN
EINER
WIRKLICHE
PARTEIENSTAAT
GELD
UND
MACHT
UVER
HE
HAUPTUNN
ENNOIEUNDESVERSAM
ASSU
LEGISLATIVE
UTIVE
JUDIKATIVE
NEIN
MEN
NUR
ALS
WAHLER
STEUERZAHLER
INTERESSANT
VOLKSEINFLUSS
PARTEIENEINFLUSs
AUF
DIE
POLITISCHE
WILLENSBILDUNG
Joseph
Beuys,
art
intermedia
EDITION,
Tragetasche
aus
Polyäthglen
mit
Filzplastik,
1.
Auflage
10000
Exemplare,
1971
107