Human Generated Data

Title

natural. A conversation with Joseph Beuys [part]

Date

1985

People

Artist: Bernhard Johannes Blume, German 1937 - 2011

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, Gift of Anna and Bernhard Blume, 1996.14.C

Human Generated Data

Title

natural. A conversation with Joseph Beuys [part]

People

Artist: Bernhard Johannes Blume, German 1937 - 2011

Date

1985

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, Gift of Anna and Bernhard Blume, 1996.14.C

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2022-06-04

Person 99.2
Human 99.2
Person 96.3
Text 92.8
Person 88.6
Person 88.4
Person 88
Person 86.2
Indoors 85.5
Room 84.2
Person 83.3
Ping Pong 80.7
Sport 80.7
Sports 80.7
Person 73.6
Furniture 70.9
Person 69.2
Table 68.4
Person 64.6
Person 64.3
Piano 63.5
Musical Instrument 63.5
Leisure Activities 63.5
Newspaper 62.4
Person 62.1
Person 60.3
Person 56.4

Clarifai
created on 2023-10-29

people 100
adult 99.2
man 97.3
group together 97.2
group 97.1
one 94.3
many 93
woman 92.5
two 90.3
administration 89.1
several 87.8
furniture 87.6
wear 87.2
vehicle 86.8
education 86.6
three 84.1
recreation 83.7
child 83.5
war 82.8
leader 81.7

Imagga
created on 2022-06-04

bench 30.8
park bench 28.9
man 20.9
shop 20.4
seat 18.9
musical instrument 18.1
upright 17.7
room 17.4
piano 17.3
furniture 16.9
shoe shop 16.3
stringed instrument 16.2
keyboard instrument 15
old 14.6
case 14.5
people 14.5
person 14.2
percussion instrument 14.1
mercantile establishment 13.2
home 12.7
male 12
travel 11.3
interior 10.6
couple 10.4
decoration 10.1
business 9.7
building 9.6
sitting 9.4
house 9.2
vintage 9.1
place of business 8.8
portrait 8.4
silhouette 8.3
tourism 8.2
indoor 8.2
water 8
antique 8
adult 7.9
art 7.8
wall 7.7
happy 7.5
retro 7.4
vacation 7.4
design 7.3
color 7.2
lifestyle 7.2
black 7.2
chair 7.2
women 7.1
family 7.1
face 7.1
love 7.1
work 7.1
day 7.1

Google
created on 2022-06-04

Table 91.4
Coat 90
Font 78.1
Rectangle 74.1
Suit 71.2
Desk 70.5
Art 70
Monochrome photography 69.7
Event 68.3
Chair 67
Monochrome 66.5
History 65.3
Conversation 64.4
Publication 61
Advertising 60.6
Newspaper 58.9
Room 58.3
Visual arts 52.8
Vintage clothing 51.8
Illustration 51.6

Microsoft
created on 2022-06-04

text 99.7
person 90.1
man 54.8

Color Analysis

Face analysis

Amazon

Google

AWS Rekognition

Age 39-47
Gender Male, 97.1%
Disgusted 67.4%
Sad 12.5%
Confused 12.5%
Surprised 6.7%
Fear 6%
Calm 3.3%
Angry 1.5%
Happy 0.7%

AWS Rekognition

Age 21-29
Gender Male, 99.1%
Sad 99.5%
Calm 14.1%
Angry 13.9%
Surprised 8.7%
Fear 6.3%
Confused 1.4%
Disgusted 1.1%
Happy 0.3%

AWS Rekognition

Age 23-33
Gender Male, 100%
Calm 95.8%
Surprised 6.6%
Fear 6%
Confused 2.3%
Sad 2.2%
Angry 0.5%
Disgusted 0.3%
Happy 0.1%

AWS Rekognition

Age 6-12
Gender Female, 99.9%
Calm 42.9%
Happy 21.8%
Surprised 13%
Confused 10.4%
Disgusted 8.9%
Fear 6.8%
Sad 3.2%
Angry 1.4%

AWS Rekognition

Age 60-70
Gender Male, 100%
Calm 41.5%
Fear 30.6%
Sad 15.9%
Confused 7.8%
Surprised 7.7%
Disgusted 2.2%
Angry 0.9%
Happy 0.7%

AWS Rekognition

Age 36-44
Gender Female, 100%
Calm 99.8%
Surprised 6.3%
Fear 5.9%
Sad 2.2%
Confused 0%
Happy 0%
Disgusted 0%
Angry 0%

AWS Rekognition

Age 22-30
Gender Male, 99.8%
Calm 95.3%
Surprised 7.2%
Fear 6%
Sad 2.6%
Confused 0.4%
Disgusted 0.4%
Angry 0.3%
Happy 0.2%

AWS Rekognition

Age 22-30
Gender Female, 85.7%
Calm 51.5%
Sad 25.1%
Confused 22.3%
Surprised 7.2%
Fear 6.2%
Angry 2.2%
Disgusted 1.6%
Happy 0.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 45-53
Gender Female, 100%
Sad 100%
Fear 6.8%
Surprised 6.4%
Calm 1.6%
Confused 0.8%
Disgusted 0.7%
Angry 0.5%
Happy 0.2%

AWS Rekognition

Age 29-39
Gender Female, 99.7%
Fear 69.6%
Happy 21.2%
Surprised 13.9%
Angry 4.1%
Sad 4.1%
Calm 2.7%
Disgusted 2.5%
Confused 0.9%

AWS Rekognition

Age 30-40
Gender Female, 99.7%
Calm 69.4%
Sad 54.6%
Surprised 6.4%
Fear 5.9%
Happy 1.3%
Angry 0.4%
Disgusted 0.3%
Confused 0.2%

AWS Rekognition

Age 21-29
Gender Male, 92.9%
Confused 73.9%
Calm 16.1%
Surprised 7.1%
Fear 6.1%
Sad 3.1%
Disgusted 2.7%
Angry 1.9%
Happy 0.5%

AWS Rekognition

Age 23-33
Gender Male, 100%
Calm 98.2%
Surprised 6.5%
Fear 5.9%
Sad 2.2%
Confused 0.5%
Disgusted 0.2%
Angry 0.1%
Happy 0.1%

AWS Rekognition

Age 23-31
Gender Female, 97.7%
Calm 78.8%
Happy 11.4%
Surprised 6.9%
Fear 6.5%
Sad 2.9%
Disgusted 2.8%
Angry 1.5%
Confused 0.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 35-43
Gender Male, 99.6%
Calm 67%
Sad 58.8%
Surprised 6.4%
Fear 6.1%
Angry 1.2%
Confused 0.8%
Disgusted 0.8%
Happy 0.2%

AWS Rekognition

Age 21-29
Gender Male, 94.8%
Calm 77.7%
Fear 10%
Sad 9%
Surprised 6.8%
Disgusted 0.8%
Happy 0.5%
Confused 0.5%
Angry 0.4%

AWS Rekognition

Age 25-35
Gender Female, 99.8%
Sad 100%
Disgusted 8.1%
Surprised 6.3%
Fear 5.9%
Happy 0.3%
Angry 0.3%
Calm 0.3%
Confused 0.3%

AWS Rekognition

Age 16-22
Gender Female, 69%
Fear 97.6%
Surprised 7%
Sad 2.5%
Calm 0.7%
Angry 0.1%
Happy 0.1%
Disgusted 0.1%
Confused 0.1%

AWS Rekognition

Age 24-34
Gender Female, 63.9%
Sad 90.5%
Calm 24.1%
Fear 23.2%
Surprised 7.6%
Confused 2.7%
Happy 2.4%
Disgusted 1.3%
Angry 1.1%

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Possible
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very likely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Possible

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Possible

Google Vision

Surprise Very unlikely
Anger Very unlikely
Sorrow Very unlikely
Joy Very unlikely
Headwear Very unlikely
Blurred Very unlikely

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person
Piano
Person 99.2%
Person 96.3%
Person 88.6%
Person 88.4%
Person 88%
Person 86.2%
Person 83.3%
Person 73.6%
Person 69.2%
Person 64.6%
Person 64.3%
Person 62.1%
Person 60.3%
Person 56.4%
Piano 63.5%

Captions

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-02-18

The image appears to be a black and white photograph, depicting a scene that looks like it could be from a classroom or some sort of meeting. In the foreground, there's an old-fashioned table with turned legs, on which a crucifix and what might be bottles are placed. In the background, there's a group of individuals seated on benches or chairs, facing towards the front as if they're attending a lecture or presentation. The room looks quite traditional with wooden paneling, which gives it an historic feel.

The right side of the image has text in what seems to be German, indicating that this might be from a book or printed material discussing some philosophical or intellectual topics. Unfortunately, I cannot provide context on the conversation in the text or its participants due to the instructions provided.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-02-18

The image is a black and white photograph showing a group of people gathered around a wooden table in an indoor setting. The table is sturdy with ornate legs, and there is a cross placed on it. The group appears to be engaged in a discussion or meeting, with some individuals standing and others sitting closely around the table. The room has a wooden floor, and a single chair is positioned next to the table. Text in German is printed on the right side of the image, consisting of a conversation between individuals referred to as Beuys and Blume.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2025-02-18

The image shows a large group of people gathered around what appears to be a table or podium. They seem to be in a formal setting, with many of them dressed in coats and jackets. The group is diverse, with both men and women of various ages. There appears to be text overlaid on the image, though I cannot read or decipher the language. The overall scene conveys a sense of a formal gathering or meeting of some kind.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2025-02-18

The image shows two black and white photos. The top photo depicts a child sitting alone at a desk or table. The bottom photo shows a group of people, including children, gathered around a table or desk. The text on the left side of the image appears to be in German and seems to be discussing the two photos, though I cannot provide details on what it specifically says.

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2025-02-18

This black and white photograph shows what appears to be some kind of public discussion or presentation. There's a large wooden table or desk in the foreground, and a crowd of people gathered around it. The scene appears to be documentative in nature, possibly from an academic or political context. There's German text visible on the right side of the image, suggesting this may be from a German publication or documentation. The setting seems to be indoors, and the furniture visible has a traditional, heavy wooden style characteristic of institutional or formal settings.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-12

The image presents a collage of three black-and-white photographs, accompanied by a typed text in German. The photographs depict scenes from a play or performance, while the text appears to be a script or dialogue for the same production.

  • Top Left Photograph:
    • A wooden table with a chair on one side and a person's legs visible underneath.
    • The table has ornate legs and appears to be made of wood.
    • The person's legs are partially hidden by the table, but they seem to be wearing dark pants.
  • Bottom Left Photograph:
    • A man sitting at a table, facing a group of people.
    • The man is wearing a suit and a hat, and he has a glass in front of him.
    • The group of people is standing behind him, looking at him with interest.
    • There is a white cross on the table in front of the man.
  • Right Side of the Image:
    • A typed text in German, which appears to be a script or dialogue for the play or performance.
    • The text is written in a formal font and includes stage directions and character names.
    • The text is divided into sections, each with a heading and a block of text underneath.

Overall, the image suggests that the play or performance is a dramatic or theatrical production, possibly with a religious or moral theme. The use of a cross in the bottom left photograph adds to this interpretation, and the formal font used in the typed text reinforces the idea that the production is a serious and artistic endeavor.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-12

The image is a black-and-white photograph of a man sitting at a table, surrounded by a group of people. The man is wearing a suit and hat, and he appears to be speaking or lecturing to the group. The table in front of him has a cross on it, which may be a symbol of his message or theme.

To the right of the photo, there is a text box with German writing. The text appears to be a transcript of the man's speech or lecture, and it may provide context or additional information about the scene depicted in the photo.

Overall, the image suggests that the man is a religious leader or speaker, and that he is addressing a group of people on a topic related to Christianity or spirituality. The presence of the cross on the table reinforces this interpretation, as it is a common symbol of Christianity.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-02-18

The image is a collage of two black-and-white photographs with accompanying text in German. The top photograph shows a person sitting at a wooden desk, possibly in a classroom or study setting. The person is wearing a hat and appears to be engaged in a serious conversation or activity. The desk is cluttered with various items, including a book and a glass. The background is blurred, suggesting movement or focus on the person at the desk.

The bottom photograph depicts a group of people gathered in what seems to be a meeting or assembly. The group is diverse in age and gender, with some individuals standing and others seated. The setting appears to be indoors, possibly a conference room or a hall. The people are engaged in conversation, and some are looking towards the center of the group.

The text accompanying the images is written in German and appears to be a dialogue between two individuals, referred to as "Beuys" and "Blume." The dialogue touches on themes of Christianity, nature, and the role of art in society. Beuys expresses his lack of interest in traditional Christianity, stating that he does not consider himself a Christian. Blume, on the other hand, acknowledges his own problems and struggles with the concept of Christianity.

The dialogue also discusses the idea of a "totalitarian plane" and the desire for freedom and orientation in life. Beuys emphasizes the importance of nature and the world, suggesting that a particular plane of understanding might not be sufficient. Blume questions whether it is possible to achieve such a plane and whether it is necessary to strive for it.

Overall, the image and accompanying text seem to explore philosophical and existential themes, with a focus on the relationship between art, nature, and spirituality. The use of black-and-white photography adds a sense of timelessness and seriousness to the collage.

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-02-18

The image is a collage of two photographs with a text overlay on the right side. The top photograph depicts a man standing behind a table with a book on it. He is wearing a white shirt and a tie, and he appears to be addressing a group of people who are seated and standing around him. The setting looks like a classroom or a meeting room.

The bottom photograph shows a group of people gathered around a table, with one man sitting at the head of the table. He is wearing a hat and a jacket, and he appears to be speaking to the group. The group is diverse, with people of different ages and genders. The setting looks like a community meeting or a discussion group.

The text overlay on the right side of the image is in German and appears to be a quote or a statement. It is difficult to make out the exact words, but it seems to be related to the theme of the photographs, which is people coming together to discuss important issues.

Text analysis

Amazon

bin
einen
von
aber
als
habe
der
Erfahr-
ich
oder
Plan
du
zur
noch habe ich als
Ich
und
eher
den.
wirklich
Auch
Das gebe ich zu. Ich bin
Keinen
Beuys:
Plan zur Rettung der
Da
Du
eher partikulare Erfahr-
Rettung
ungen. Keinen
Beuys: Auch den.
den
ist
noch
gebe
Das
in
kein
wie
Beuys: Nein, aber das
ungen.
dein
das
Beuys: Durchblick ist
du nur mal begreifen
Nein,
Oder
keinen
Durchblick
nicht
begreifen
Natur, zur Rettung der
nur
Kunstler wirklich einen
mußt
Natur
zu.
partikulare
Nur
mal
auch
Du willst den Schritt
willst
überhaupt
Blume:
3
nicht tun...
Den
Welt. Ich habe überhaupt
leidenswillig wie du -
Oberblick,
Natur,
tun...
du -
Schritt
Christusprinzip ist
von Natur und Welt.
leidenswillig
keinen Durchblick. Oder ?
Beuys: Das ist dein Problem.
nicht Christus.
?
Kunstler
Christusprinzip
Christus.
Blume: Da habe ich Probleme.
auch in dir, das mußt
Selbstaufopferung ?
Selbstaufopferung
Durchblick.
Welt.
so
kein Christustyp.
so leidensfahig oder
Weder
Blume: Den Schritt der -
dir,
Problem.
Christustyp.
Probleme.
leidensfahig
keinen Totalitäts-Begriff
Blume.
Totalitäts-Begriff
der -
DISI

Google

ist nicht Christus. Beuys: Nein, aber das Christusprinzip ist auch in dir, das mußt du nur mal begreifen. Blume. Blume: Da habe ich Probleme. Beuys: Das ist dein Problem. Du willst den Schritt nicht tun... Blume: Den Schritt der Selbstaufopferung ? Beuys: Auch den. Blume: Das gebe ich zu. Ich bin kein Christustyp. Weder so leidensfähig oder leidenswillig wie du - noch habe ich als Künstler wirklich einen Plan zur Rettung der Natur, zur Rettung der Welt. Ich habe überhaupt keinen Totalitäts-Begriff von Natur und Welt. Nur eher partikulare Erfahr- ungen. Keinen Überblick, keinen Durchblick. Oder ? Beuys: Durchblick ist unmittel- bar möglich! Es geht auch nicht um totalitäre Pläne oder aufgezwungene Rezep- turen, sondern um die freie Vernunft und den Willen jedes Einzelnen - "natur- orientierter zu leben" und das heißt, sich an der Neugestaltung des Wirtschaftslebens zu beteiligen.
ist
nicht
Christus
.
Beuys
:
Nein
,
aber
das
Christusprinzip
auch
in
dir
mußt
du
nur
mal
begreifen
Blume
Da
habe
ich
Probleme
Das
dein
Problem
Du
willst
den
Schritt
tun
...
Den
der
Selbstaufopferung
?
Auch
gebe
zu
Ich
bin
kein
Christustyp
Weder
so
leidensfähig
oder
leidenswillig
wie
-
noch
als
Künstler
wirklich
einen
Plan
zur
Rettung
Natur
Welt
überhaupt
keinen
Totalitäts
Begriff
von
und
Nur
eher
partikulare
Erfahr
ungen
Keinen
Überblick
Durchblick
Oder
unmittel
bar
möglich
!
Es
geht
um
totalitäre
Pläne
aufgezwungene
Rezep
turen
sondern
die
freie
Vernunft
Willen
jedes
Einzelnen
"
natur
orientierter
leben
heißt
sich
an
Neugestaltung
des
Wirtschaftslebens
beteiligen