Human Generated Data

Title

Untitled, from the portfolio "Saltoarte"

Date

1975

People

Artist: Ben Vautier, French 1935 - 2024

Publisher: POUR, Belgian

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, The Willy and Charlotte Reber Collection, Gift of Charlotte Reber, 1996.158.29

Copyright

© Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York / ADAGP, Paris

Human Generated Data

Title

Untitled, from the portfolio "Saltoarte"

People

Artist: Ben Vautier, French 1935 - 2024

Publisher: POUR, Belgian

Date

1975

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, The Willy and Charlotte Reber Collection, Gift of Charlotte Reber, 1996.158.29

Copyright

© Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York / ADAGP, Paris

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2019-11-08

Poster 98.2
Advertisement 98.2
Brochure 95.3
Paper 95.3
Flyer 95.3
Text 94.3
Page 77.9
Word 75.4
Label 64.3

Clarifai
created on 2019-11-08

template 99.9
number 99.7
page 99.7
layout 99.7
booklet 99.5
presentation 99.3
banner 98.9
label 98.7
card 98.6
form 98
World Wide Web 97.9
information 97.6
text 97.5
sign 96.7
stepping 96.1
bill 94.9
vector 94.8
cover 94.7
illustration 94.4
modern font 94

Imagga
created on 2019-11-08

menu 100
fare 100
food 65.4
design 38.9
definition 35.3
cloud 34.5
graphic 33.6
creative 29.2
decorative 28.4
art 27.1
business 26.8
association 26.6
conceptual 26.5
artwork 25.7
backdrop 25.6
idea 23.2
cover 23.2
information 22.2
data 21.9
brochure 21.5
advertisement 21.2
letter 21.1
copy 20.4
element 19.9
collection 19.8
composition 19.8
decoration 19.6
advertising 19.2
advertise 18.5
collage 18.3
paper 18.1
associated 17.8
decor 17.7
word 17
carpet 16.5
drawing 16.3
style 14.9
keywords 14.8
year 14.6
text 14
new 13.8
template 13.8
global 13.7
tag 13.4
modern 13.3
representation 13
month 12.7
calendar 12.6
date 12.6
day 12.6
stylized 12.5
journal 12.4
card 11.9
more 11.7
pattern 11.6
holiday 11.5
education 11.3
page 11.1
document 11.1
week 10.8
tags 10.8
ornament 10.4
season 10.1
monthly 9.9
daily 9.8
office 9.6
mix 9.6
development 9.5
draw 9.5
book 9.3
company 9.3
communication 9.2
financial 8.9
emphasize 8.9
mosaic 8.9
calender 8.9
felt 8.9
fluorescent 8.9
highlight 8.9
dye 8.8
organizer 8.8
diary 8.8
symbol 8.8
layout 8.7
ink 8.7
corporate 8.6
print 8.5
future 8.4
city 8.3
highlighter 7.9
planner 7.9
bright 7.9
brand 7.9
important 7.9
analysis 7.8
blank 7.7
winter 7.7
label 7.5
human 7.5
frame 7.5
retro 7.4
ornate 7.3
detail 7.2
world 7.1

Google
created on 2019-11-08

Text 92.7
Font 75

Microsoft
created on 2019-11-08

nintendo 100
text 100
screenshot 90.7
poster 80
orange 58.3
book 53.8

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Menu

Clarifai

No features identified

AWS Rekognition

Menu 91.9%

Categories

Imagga
created on 2019-11-08

text visuals 99.7%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2019-11-08

a close up of a piece of paper 76.2%
a close up of a device 71.4%
a screenshot of a cell phone 69.2%

Clarifai

No captions written

Salesforce

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-16

a photograph of a poster with a picture of a woman in a red dress

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-02-05

The image illustrates a piece of text titled "écrire la liberté" (which translates to "write freedom" in English) in bold, black letters against a white background. This title is overlaid on an orange, abstract, wave-like shape that adds a colorful, artistic touch to the otherwise text-dominant visual.

Below the title, the text is laid out in several paragraphs, formatted in blocks that extend alongside and underneath the orange shape. The content is written in French, and it appears to be a political or philosophical commentary, possibly an editorial or manifesto, discussing topics related to freedom, socialism, journalism, and political ideologies.

The text starts with a date and mentions several publications and groups, such as "Europe 74-Hebdo," "4 millions 4 - Hebdo," "Rénovation Wallonne," "FDF-Rassemblement Wallon," and "Notre Temps." The content seems to address political actions, intellectual movements, and the roles of different societal groups in striving for freedom and socialism.

The signature at the end of the text reads "BEN," which may refer to the author or the person responsible for this piece. The overall design of the image demonstrates a blend of textual and visual elements, giving it both a literary and artistic feel.

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-02-05

This image features a text-based composition with a large, abstract orange mark at the center that resembles a question mark or an ear. The dominant text near the top reads "écrire la liberté," which translates to "write freedom" or "writing freedom" in French. The body of the text appears to be a narrative or discussion in French, possibly related to the theme of freedom in the context of intellectual thought, media, and political ideology.

The layout is reminiscent of a newspaper or manifesto, discussing various topics related to society, politics, and individual rights. There are references to intellectuals, a newspaper’s responsibility, and the dynamics of movements related to freedom, culture, and politics.

Below the main body of text, on the bottom right, the signature "BEN" is visible, which might indicate the artist or author responsible for this work. The overall presentation suggests that this is an artistic or literary piece with a strong message about freedom, the role of intellectuals, and the importance of choice and voice in society.

Anthropic Claude

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-25

This appears to be a French language political or editorial text document with the title "écrire la liberté" (which translates to "writing freedom" in English). The layout suggests it's from a newspaper or magazine, with columns of text against a light background. There's an orange or salmon-colored graphic element or shape on the right side of the image. The text appears to be discussing political and social themes, with references to socialism, workers, and collective action. The document seems to be from a historical context, possibly from the 1970s based on the typography and layout style. The text is signed by "BEN" at the bottom. The overall design is minimalist and typical of political or intellectual publications from that era.

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2025-02-05

This appears to be a French political or editorial text document with the bold header "écrire la liberté" (which means "write freedom" in English). The layout shows a large block of text in French, with sections divided into paragraphs. What makes this image visually striking is the large orange or salmon-colored abstract shape that appears to be painted or printed as a background element, somewhat resembling a curved or flowing form. The text is primarily in black, making it stand out against both the pale background and the orange shape. The document appears to be from a publication or newspaper, discussing political and social themes based on the visible French text. The overall design is minimalist but effective, with the contrast between the text and the artistic element creating visual interest.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2025-02-05

The image shows a political poster or flyer with the title "écrire la liberté" which means "write freedom" in French. The background features a blurry orange shape that resembles a human hand or fist. The text is in French and appears to be advocating for political freedom, intellectual discussion, and rejecting revisionism and censorship. The tone seems to be a call to action, urging the reader to defend and fight for their political freedoms and right to freely express themselves through writing and intellectual discourse.

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2025-02-05

The image appears to be a poster or document with the title "écrire la liberté" (write the freedom). The text discusses various aspects of intellectual and political freedom, such as the role of the press, the importance of information, and the need to fight against oppression and exploitation of the masses. The poster seems to be advocating for the freedom of expression and the freedom to write and publish without censorship or restraint.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-12

The image features a French-language document with a striking design, characterized by a prominent orange heart shape and bold black text. The title, "écrire la liberté," is prominently displayed at the top, followed by a series of paragraphs that appear to be an excerpt from a larger text. The background of the document is a warm beige color, which provides a subtle contrast to the vibrant orange heart shape.

The overall aesthetic of the document suggests that it may be a promotional material or a call to action, possibly related to a social or political movement. The use of bold text and a striking design element draws attention to the importance of writing and freedom, while the beige background provides a sense of calmness and balance.

In terms of the content, the text appears to be a passionate plea for the importance of writing and its role in promoting freedom. The author emphasizes the power of words to shape our understanding of the world and to inspire change, and encourages readers to take action and make their voices heard. The tone is energetic and motivational, with a sense of urgency and importance.

Overall, the image presents a compelling and thought-provoking message that highlights the significance of writing and freedom. The use of a striking design element and bold text effectively grabs the viewer's attention and draws them into the message, making it a powerful and effective promotional tool.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-12

The image is a French-language poster with the title "écrire la liberté" in large, bold text at the top. The background of the poster features a beige color with an orange watercolor design that resembles a handprint or a splash of paint.

Title and Text:

  • The title "écrire la liberté" is written in large, bold text at the top of the poster.
  • Below the title, there are several paragraphs of text in French, which appear to be discussing the importance of freedom and the role of writing in promoting it.
  • The text is written in a clear and readable font, making it easy to understand for those who speak French.

Design Elements:

  • The background of the poster features a beige color with an orange watercolor design that resembles a handprint or a splash of paint.
  • The design element adds a touch of creativity and visual interest to the poster, making it more engaging and attention-grabbing.
  • The use of orange as the primary color for the design element creates a sense of warmth and energy, which complements the theme of freedom and creativity.

Overall Impression:

  • The poster effectively conveys the message of promoting freedom and creativity through writing.
  • The use of a clear and readable font, combined with the visually appealing design element, makes the poster easy to understand and engaging to look at.
  • The overall impression of the poster is one of positivity and empowerment, encouraging viewers to take action and express themselves through writing.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-02-05

The image appears to be a poster or a page from a magazine. The poster is white in color, with some text written on it. The text is in French, and it reads "Écrire la liberté" in bold letters. There is a red and orange-colored object in the center of the poster, which seems to be a human figure. The poster seems to be a call to action, encouraging people to write for freedom.

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-02-05

The image is a printed page from a magazine or a pamphlet. It features a bold and eye-catching design with a large, stylized orange shape resembling a flame or a wave. The words "écrire la liberté" are prominently displayed in black, French text, translating to "write freedom" in English. The text is accompanied by a series of smaller, italicized French phrases and sentences, which appear to be excerpts from an article or an essay. The background of the page is a light beige color, and the overall design has a modern and artistic feel.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-05-22

The image is a poster with a bold, striking design. The central element is the phrase "écrire la liberté" (write freedom) in large, black, sans-serif font. The words are placed against a background of a stylized, abstract, orange shape that appears to be a vibrant, organic form.

Beneath the title, the poster features a substantial block of text, written in French, that is likely the content of the poster's message. The text is presented in a smaller font size and is arranged in a clear, multi-paragraph format. The text discusses the importance of free press and the fight for socialism. At the bottom-right corner, a smaller "BEN" appears, possibly indicating the name of the designer or printing company.

The overall aesthetic of the poster is clean, modern, and visually engaging, with the orange shape providing a strong contrast to the black and white text. It conveys a sense of energy, urgency, and commitment to the ideals of freedom and socialism.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-05-22

The poster contains a large orange graphic, possibly a question mark shape, above a heading written in bold, orange letters that reads "écrire la liberté".

Below the heading is text in French, with a brief intro that reads "Octobre 74. Tiens, un nouveau canard." Then the poster describes a newspaper called "Europe 74-Hebdo", followed by a long paragraph about the paper.

The next paragraph asks the question "Mais à quoi donc correspond une telle profusion de nouveaux journaux?". A bulleted list of several reasons follow.

Finally, the last paragraph explains the political choices of the authors of the poster, ending by encouraging others to join with their criticisms, ideas, and their willingness to fight for socialism.

The poster is signed "BEN" at the bottom right corner.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-09

The image is a poster or flyer in French, with the prominent title "Écrire la liberté" (Write Freedom) at the top. The background features an abstract, orange-colored shape that appears to be a stylized letter "P" or a similar form. The text below the title is divided into two columns and is written in a mix of black and orange fonts.

The text appears to be a political or social manifesto, discussing themes of freedom, social change, and the role of media and journalism. Here is a summary of the content:

  1. Introduction and Context:

    • The text begins by mentioning a date, October 7, and a location, Tiens, where a new song was heard.
    • It discusses the progress and the need for a new song, emphasizing the importance of renewal and progress.
  2. Critique of Existing Media:

    • The text critiques existing newspapers and media, describing them as outdated and not reflecting the true needs and aspirations of the people.
    • It mentions the lack of intellectual depth and the superficial treatment of important issues in current media.
  3. Vision for a New Journal:

    • The text proposes the creation of a new type of newspaper or journal that would be more intellectually stimulating and socially relevant.
    • It emphasizes the need for a journal that is not just a product of capitalist interests but one that serves the people and promotes socialist ideals.
  4. Call to Action:

    • The text calls for the creation of a new journal that would be a tool for social change and intellectual growth.
    • It encourages the formation of a collective effort to produce this new journal, emphasizing the importance of collaboration and community involvement.
  5. Financial and Organizational Aspects:

    • The text discusses the financial and organizational aspects of creating such a journal, emphasizing the need for collective funding and support.
    • It highlights the importance of transparency and collective decision-making in the production and distribution of the journal.
  6. Conclusion:

    • The text concludes with a call to action, urging readers to join the effort to create this new journal and to contribute their ideas, criticisms, and support.
    • It emphasizes the need for a collective effort to achieve true freedom and social change.

Overall, the poster is a call to action for the creation of a new, intellectually stimulating, and socially relevant journal that serves the people and promotes socialist ideals.

Qwen

No captions written

Text analysis

Amazon

liberte
ecrire
progressistes
chaque
Octobre
dans
Les
d'abord
tun
conflit.
unnouveaucanard:
Rossel
Tiens.
millions
-Hebdox
propre
peu
Tiens. encore d'edition
presse Rossel Les ces choixpolitiques d'abord
d'edition
encore
entreprise.
vent.
progressistes belges souhai vent. dans entreprise, sa propre
ces
presse
usine:
Hebdo
belges
largue
leDirecteur..
de
Europe 74- -Hebdox dans
nouvelles
quartier,
leretenaient de largue les amarres qui quartier, chaque conflit.
Octobre 74. Tiens. unnouveaucanard: entreprise. ou usine: dans chaque
sa
les amarres qui
souhai
choixpolitiques
leretenaient
M.
ecrire Ia liberte
I'organisation
Europe 74-
entreprise,
millions 4. Hebdo tun peu sor. M. leDirecteur.. OU
74.
4.
sor.
OU
Ia
ou

Google

liberté écrire la Octobre 74. Tiens, un nouveau canard: Europe 74-Hebdo», il a largué les amarres qui le retenaientau trust de presse Rossel. Les progressistes belges lui souhaitent bon vent. Tiens, encore un nouveau canard!: 4 millions 4- Hebdo». En soulevant un peu ses nouvelles plumes, on retrouve la couleur de «Rénovation Wallone et un parfum FDF-Rassemblement Wallon. Tiens, en voilà encore un: Notre Temps Celui-là est né d'un ceuf qui a mis longtemps à éclore. Il paralt qu'il appartient à ses lecteurs, et que ceux-ci négocient avec Messieurs Perin et Gol une prochaine fusion avec 4 millions 4 En attendant, de droite, de gauche ou du centre, du moment que l'on appartient à l'intelligentia, on peut y écrire. Tiens, revoilà POUR. Celui-là, je le connais. J'ai lu son manifeste politique: il est au service des luttes, à la base, avec les travailleurs et étudiants qui rejettent le système capitaliste et qui veulent, chaque jour, pratiquer une recherche du socialisme. entreprise, université ou usine; dans chaque quartier, dans chaque conflit. Il faudra appliquer ces choix politiques d'abord dans sa propre entreprise, sa propre maison d'édition opterpour l'organisa tion capitaliste du travail (u bien sür, M. le Directeur...), ou l'organisation socialis te, égalitariste, de la production. Pour nous, ces choix sont faits. C'estune équipe unie sur un projet politique commun, qui dirige collectivement ce journal. Cette arme au service des luttes, ne dépend ni de la publicité, ni de la finance, ni des partis POUR est un instrument qui ne sert qu'un camp et qui ne donne la parole qu'aux gens en lutte contre le système qui nous opprime. Mais POUR, vous l'avez sous les yeux. Vous pouvez le lire, l'analyser et le juger. Nous n'avons pas à en parler plus longtemps. Parcontre, ce qui ne se lit pas, et qui pourtant est une garantie de la solidité de nos choix politiques - C'estle fait que nous sommes auto-producteurs, que nous avons à notre disposition une imprimerie qui fut construite patiemment, pour que notre survie ne dépende pas de la censure d'un trust de l'imprimerie. C'estque nous refusons toute hiérarchie des taches et des fonctions au sein de notre groupe. Cela veut dire que nous n'accordons pas plus de valeur au fait d'écrire un article qu'au fait de le photocomposer ou de l'imprimer, de faire la cuisine ou de nettoyer une machine. Car nous savons que la hiérarchie des fonctions est un des éléments essentiels du maintien d'une caste d'exploiteurs. C'estque chaque membre de l'équipe réalise un ensemble de taches manuelles et intellectuelles et que nous opérons une rotation des fonctions dans le groupe. C'estque le salariat a été aboli au profit de la thèse marxiste des besoins nécessaires à la juste reproduction des forces de travail. C'estque financièrement nous ne dépendons que des ventes, abonnements (vite abonnez-vous) et du soutien politique des lecteurs, sympathisants et militants de POUR. Alors, si les premiers pas de ce projet politique vous plaisent, si vous voulez construire avec nous le chemin de la liberté, nous vous attendons avec vos critiques, vos idées, votre force de travail, vos outils, votre soif de lutter pour le socialisme. Mais à quoi donc correspond une telle profusion de nouveaux journaux? - A l'exigence d'une masse d'intellectuels, de jeunes étudiants et d'ouvriers qui en ont marre de se nourrir exclusivment de l'information produite par les trusts de presse du capital? Celle qui nous bombarde d'informations, d'images, de sujets; qui nous détourne des vrais problèmes; qui vise à abêtir, à aliéner, à endormir ou sécuriser les masses exploitées, de manière à mieux les dominer, tout en réalisant de substanciels bénéfices sur le produit de consommation qu'est leur torchon imprimé. A la volonté de quelques intellectuels d'avoir leur journal? A l'opportunisme habile de politiciens qui visent à récupérer l'exigence de libertés et la dynamique née des mouvements de masse (avortement, culture, plan VDB, mouvements sociaux, etc...)? Ce ne sont pas les premiers éditos ou les discussions de cafés qui fourniront la réponse à ces questions. Chacun de ces organes politiques se trouvera bien vite obligé à montrer son vrai visage, à choisir son camp; la situation sociale explosive les y poussera. Et il ne suffira pas de le choisir théoriquement son camp, il faudra le choisir pratiquement, à la base, dans chaque BEN
liberté
écrire
la
Octobre
74.
Tiens,
un
nouveau
canard:
Europe
74-Hebdo»,
il
a
largué
les
amarres
qui
le
retenaientau
trust
de
presse
Rossel.
Les
progressistes
belges
lui
souhaitent
bon
vent.
encore
canard!:
4
millions
4-
Hebdo».
En
soulevant
peu
ses
nouvelles
plumes,
on
retrouve
couleur
«Rénovation
Wallone
et
parfum
FDF-Rassemblement
Wallon.
en
voilà
un:
Notre
Temps
Celui-là
est
d'un
ceuf
mis
longtemps
à
éclore.
Il
paralt
qu'il
appartient
lecteurs,
que
ceux-ci
négocient
avec
Messieurs
Perin
Gol
une
prochaine
fusion
attendant,
droite,
gauche
ou
du
centre,
moment
l'on
l'intelligentia,
peut
y
écrire.
revoilà
POUR.
Celui-là,
je
connais.
J'ai
lu
son
manifeste
politique:
au
service
des
luttes,
base,
travailleurs
étudiants
rejettent
système
capitaliste
veulent,
chaque
jour,
pratiquer
recherche
socialisme.
entreprise,
université
usine;
dans
quartier,
conflit.
faudra
appliquer
ces
choix
politiques
d'abord
sa
propre
maison
d'édition
opterpour
l'organisa
tion
travail
(u
bien
sür,
M.
Directeur...),
l'organisation
socialis
te,
égalitariste,
production.
Pour
nous,
sont
faits.
C'estune
équipe
unie
sur
projet
politique
commun,
dirige
collectivement
ce
journal.
Cette
arme
ne
dépend
ni
publicité,
finance,
partis
POUR
instrument
sert
qu'un
camp
donne
parole
qu'aux
gens
lutte
contre
nous
opprime.
Mais
POUR,
vous
l'avez
sous
yeux.
Vous
pouvez
lire,
l'analyser
juger.
Nous
n'avons
pas
parler
plus
longtemps.
Parcontre,
se
lit
pas,
pourtant
garantie
solidité
nos
-
C'estle
fait
sommes
auto-producteurs,
avons
notre
disposition
imprimerie
fut
construite
patiemment,
pour
survie
dépende
censure
l'imprimerie.
C'estque
refusons
toute
hiérarchie
taches
fonctions
sein
groupe.
Cela
veut
dire
n'accordons
valeur
d'écrire
article
qu'au
photocomposer
l'imprimer,
faire
cuisine
nettoyer
machine.
Car
savons
éléments
essentiels
maintien
d'une
caste
d'exploiteurs.
membre
l'équipe
réalise
ensemble
manuelles
intellectuelles
opérons
rotation
salariat
été
aboli
profit
thèse
marxiste
besoins
nécessaires
juste
reproduction
forces
travail.
financièrement
dépendons
ventes,
abonnements
(vite
abonnez-vous)
soutien
sympathisants
militants
Alors,
si
premiers
plaisent,
voulez
construire
chemin
liberté,
attendons
vos
critiques,
idées,
votre
force
travail,
outils,
soif
lutter
quoi
donc
correspond
telle
profusion
nouveaux
journaux?
A
l'exigence
masse
d'intellectuels,
jeunes
d'ouvriers
ont
marre
nourrir
exclusivment
l'information
produite
par
trusts
capital?
Celle
bombarde
d'informations,
d'images,
sujets;
détourne
vrais
problèmes;
vise
abêtir,
aliéner,
endormir
sécuriser
masses
exploitées,
manière
mieux
dominer,
tout
réalisant
substanciels
bénéfices
produit
consommation
qu'est
leur
torchon
imprimé.
volonté
quelques
intellectuels
d'avoir
journal?
l'opportunisme
habile
politiciens
visent
récupérer
libertés
dynamique
née
mouvements
(avortement,
culture,
plan
VDB,
sociaux,
etc...)?
Ce
éditos
discussions
cafés
fourniront
réponse
questions.
Chacun
organes
trouvera
vite
obligé
montrer
vrai
visage,
choisir
camp;
situation
sociale
explosive
poussera.
Et
suffira
théoriquement
camp,
pratiquement,
BEN