Human Generated Data

Title

[Untitled]

Date

1972

People

Artist: Günther Vossieck, German born 1943

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, The Willy and Charlotte Reber Collection, Gift of Charlotte Reber, 1996.152.27

Human Generated Data

Title

[Untitled]

People

Artist: Günther Vossieck, German born 1943

Date

1972

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Busch-Reisinger Museum, The Willy and Charlotte Reber Collection, Gift of Charlotte Reber, 1996.152.27

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2019-11-09

Human 99.1
Person 99.1
Person 98.1
Person 94.6
Person 94.4
Person 88.3
Text 88.1
Clothing 83.1
Apparel 83.1
Helmet 83.1
Person 75.1
Page 73
People 72.4
Advertisement 71.4
Paper 63
Military 60.6
Military Uniform 58.6
Newspaper 56.7
Poster 53.2

Clarifai
created on 2019-11-09

people 98
print 95.7
newspaper 95.2
man 95.1
paper 94.1
war 91.3
adult 90.7
magazine 90.1
bill 88.7
illustration 88.3
group 87
layout 86.3
desktop 85.7
administration 85.6
text 85.4
information 84.7
page 83.7
business 83.1
document 82.7
presentation 82.4

Imagga
created on 2019-11-09

web site 100
daily 31.9
newspaper 28.5
business 25.5
product 21.3
paper 18.8
letter 18.3
vintage 18.2
money 17.9
finance 17.7
retro 17.2
creation 17
old 16.7
stamp 16.5
design 16.3
mail 16.3
philately 15.8
postmark 15.8
card 15.3
document 14.8
financial 14.3
circa 13.8
page 13
dollar 13
ancient 13
postage 12.8
envelope 12.7
currency 12.6
close 12
postal 11.8
aged 11.8
sign 11.3
template 11
cash 11
message 11
wealth 10.8
layout 10.7
drawing 10.3
bar 10.2
history 9.8
address 9.8
world 9.8
human 9.7
tax 9.7
menu 9.5
website 9.4
symbol 9.4
grunge 9.4
web 9.3
art 9.2
banking 9.2
global 9.1
modern 9.1
philatelic 8.9
idea 8.9
creative 8.8
editable 8.8
closeup 8.8
news 8.7
navigation 8.7
education 8.7
writing 8.5
communication 8.4
silhouette 8.3
banner 8.3
investment 8.2
man 8.1
bank 8.1
information 8
medical 7.9
text 7.9
people 7.8
income 7.8
international 7.6
chart 7.6
exchange 7.6
serious 7.6
bill 7.6
hobby 7.6
site 7.5
savings 7.5
company 7.4
form 7.4
graphic 7.3
office 7.2
collection 7.2
icon 7.1

Google
created on 2019-11-09

Vintage advertisement 88.5
Car 77.6
Vehicle 76.3
Newsprint 74.1
Paper 59.2
Retro style 57
Newspaper 56.8
Classic 56.7
History 54.1
Wheel 52.5
Family car 51.5
Illustration 50.4

Microsoft
created on 2019-11-09

text 100
newspaper 76.6

Color Analysis

Face analysis

Amazon

AWS Rekognition

Age 26-42
Gender Male, 54.6%
Fear 46.1%
Disgusted 45.2%
Confused 45.2%
Angry 45.8%
Sad 46.9%
Calm 48.3%
Happy 47.1%
Surprised 45.4%

AWS Rekognition

Age 18-30
Gender Male, 53.4%
Disgusted 45.1%
Calm 49.4%
Fear 45.3%
Angry 48.1%
Happy 45.2%
Confused 45.1%
Sad 46.6%
Surprised 45.3%

AWS Rekognition

Age 35-51
Gender Male, 54.8%
Fear 45%
Sad 45.3%
Calm 54.2%
Surprised 45.1%
Happy 45%
Confused 45%
Angry 45.4%
Disgusted 45%

AWS Rekognition

Age 41-59
Gender Male, 50.5%
Happy 49.5%
Angry 49.6%
Fear 49.5%
Confused 49.5%
Disgusted 49.5%
Sad 49.6%
Surprised 49.5%
Calm 50.3%

AWS Rekognition

Age 21-33
Gender Female, 50.1%
Disgusted 49.6%
Angry 49.6%
Calm 49.6%
Fear 49.6%
Confused 49.7%
Surprised 49.6%
Sad 49.8%
Happy 49.5%

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person
Helmet
Poster
Person 99.1%
Person 98.1%
Person 94.6%
Person 94.4%
Person 88.3%
Person 75.1%
Helmet 83.1%
Poster 53.2%

Categories

Captions

Clarifai
created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-25

a photograph of a book opened to show a page of a book -100%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-02-05

The image features a collage with a mix of text, charts, and a historical photograph.

On the left side, there are several charts and illustrations with German text explaining points related to Nazi propaganda from 1934. The charts depict various percentages and social statistics. Among the illustrations is one labeled "Wie oft ihnen die Ereignisbereiter?", which seems to discuss daily occurrences or influences.

Below the charts, a paragraph of German text explains that the graphics come from a Nazi propaganda book and comments on their use for distinguishing between "inferior" and "superior" people, reflecting a historical and biased viewpoint that promoted social Darwinism.

On the right side, there is a historical photograph of a Nazi rally featuring soldiers in uniform, flags, and a lion statue. Additionally, there is a speech bubble from one of the figures in the photograph, but the text is not entirely clear. Beneath the photo, there is a caption in German that references an event in Bamberg in 1969 involving Franz Josef Strauss and Marcel Hepp, interpreted through the lens of past propaganda techniques.

Overall, the image is a commentary on the use of propaganda and historical events.

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-02-05

The image is a composite of textual elements and photographs. On the left side, there are several quotes in German with a credit to "F.J. Strauß-Retter des Vaterlands" von Imanuel Geiss. Below the quotes, there is a selection of three infographics with German text, depicting data on smoking, alcohol consumption, and demographic projections.

The right side of the image shows a black-and-white photograph depicting a historical scene with a large crowd gathered to listen to a person addressing them. This individual is standing next to a sculpture of a lion, which adds a monumental and possibly political context to the scene. A speech bubble is added to the photograph, with a caption in German, which suggests the content of the dialogue being delivered to the audience.

The infographics and the photograph, paired with the speech bubbles and explanatory text, indicate that the image might be related to historical education or a presentation of propaganda materials, likely connected to events in Germany given the language and context implied.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2025-02-05

This image appears to be a historical document, likely from Nazi Germany, containing both text and illustrations. On the left side, there are three statistical graphics or charts from what's identified as 1934 Nazi propaganda materials. These diagrams appear to be showing demographic or population statistics.

The right side of the image shows a historical photograph taken at what appears to be a public gathering or rally. There's a large lion sculpture or statue visible in the background.

The text is in German and includes several quotes and explanatory text. The document appears to be analyzing or critiquing historical propaganda and its effects. The graphics and layout suggest this might be from an educational or historical analysis context, possibly examining the methods and impacts of Nazi propaganda during the 1930s.

The overall document seems to be making a point about how propaganda was used to categorize and discriminate against different groups of people, as evidenced by the statistical charts and accompanying text.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2025-02-05

The image depicts a large public gathering or rally in what appears to be post-World War 2 Germany based on the clothing styles and black and white photography. A man is standing on a raised platform and giving a speech to the large crowd assembled before him. The crowd seems to be mostly men, many in uniforms or suits. In the background, a large statue or monument can be seen. The text on the image is in German and contains several statistics, graphs and diagrams, though the details are difficult to make out due to the image resolution. The overall scene conveys a sense of a significant political event or speech occurring during a tumultuous time in German history.

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2025-02-05

The image appears to depict a propaganda display related to Nazi ideology and policies. It includes charts, graphs, and textual information that seems to be promoting nationalistic and anti-democratic ideologies. The central image shows a large statue or sculpture surrounded by a crowd of people listening to a speaker on a platform. The overall content suggests this was part of a Nazi-era propaganda campaign, though I will not identify or name any individuals shown in the image.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-15

The image presents a page from a book or magazine, featuring a mix of text and images. The left side is dedicated to text, while the right side showcases a photograph.

Left Side:

  • The text is written in German and appears to be an article or essay.
  • It includes several paragraphs of text, with some sections highlighted in bold or italicized font.
  • There are also several illustrations and diagrams scattered throughout the text, including a pie chart and a bar graph.
  • The text is presented in a formal, academic style, suggesting that the article may be from a scholarly or educational publication.

Right Side:

  • The photograph depicts a man standing in front of a crowd, pointing at something in the distance.
  • He is dressed in a military uniform and has a stern expression on his face.
  • Behind him, a large statue of a lion's head is visible, with a crowd of people gathered around it.
  • The background of the photograph is a clear blue sky, suggesting that the scene is set outdoors.
  • The overall atmosphere of the photograph appears to be one of authority and power, with the man in the uniform commanding attention from the crowd.

Overall:

  • The image suggests that the article or essay on the left side may be discussing themes related to power, authority, and social control.
  • The photograph on the right side reinforces this idea, depicting a scene of a powerful figure addressing a crowd.
  • The use of formal language and academic-style illustrations on the left side adds to the sense of seriousness and importance, while the photograph on the right side provides a more dynamic and engaging visual element to the page.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-15

The image appears to be a page from a book or document, featuring a mix of text and images. The text is written in German, and the images include a black-and-white photograph of a man standing in front of a crowd, as well as several smaller images and graphics.

Key Elements:

  • Text: The text is written in German and appears to be discussing a topic related to politics or history.
  • Photograph: The photograph shows a man standing in front of a crowd, with his right arm raised and pointing to the left. He is wearing a military-style uniform and has a serious expression on his face.
  • Smaller Images and Graphics: There are several smaller images and graphics scattered throughout the page, including a pie chart, a bar graph, and a series of small illustrations.

Overall Impression:

The image suggests that the document is discussing a serious topic, possibly related to politics or history. The use of a photograph and smaller images and graphics adds visual interest to the page and helps to break up the text. However, without being able to read the text, it is difficult to determine the specific topic or message being conveyed.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-02-05

The image is a two-page spread from a book or magazine. The left page contains text and three circular diagrams with accompanying text. The text is in German and discusses the concept of "Volksgemeinschaft," or "people's community," and its evolution over time. The diagrams illustrate the changing composition of the population in terms of social class and political affiliation. The right page features a black-and-white photograph of a crowd gathered in front of a statue of a lion, with a man in uniform addressing the crowd. The photograph is accompanied by a quote from a book by Manuel Geiss, which reads: "Zuweilen zeugen solche Vorfälle wie in Bamberg 1969 mit seinem berühmten APO-Tierarzt 'Hochverrat', enthüllte sein persönlicher Referent Marcel Hepp eine Stimme vor der Bundestagswahl am 28. 9. 1969 in Gegenwart von Straus: 'Wenn eine CSU ihre Stämme hält, ist das nur auf das Tierarzt zurückzuführen.'" The quote discusses a famous incident in Bamberg in 1969 involving a veterinarian who was accused of high treason, and how the incident was used by a political party to gain support before an election.

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-02-05

The image shows a spread from a magazine or book with a photograph on the right side and text on the left side. The photograph depicts a man in a military uniform standing in front of a crowd of people. The man appears to be giving a speech or making a statement. The text on the left side is written in German and discusses the concept of "Volksteile" or "people's parts" and how they were used as propaganda tools during the Nazi era. The text also mentions the use of animal imagery in Nazi propaganda and how it was used to dehumanize certain groups of people. The spread is likely discussing the use of propaganda and the manipulation of language and imagery to control and influence the masses.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-06-03

Here's a description of the image based on the provided information:

Overall Impression:

The image shows an open book spread, presenting a critical analysis of language and imagery. The left page contains text and charts, while the right page features a manipulated photograph. The overall tone is academic, critical, and concerned with the potential for misuse of language and imagery.

Left Page:

  • The page includes a series of quotations, likely from a politician named F.J. Strauss. These quotes are derogatory and dehumanizing, using terms like "ungewaschene" (unwashed), "Verdreckten" (dirty), and "Viecher" (creatures).
  • Below the quotes are three informational graphics/charts. From the text, we know they come from an NS (National Socialist, or Nazi) propaganda book from 1934. They are illustrating supposed "costs" of "low-value" individuals and how their numbers might supposedly increase over generations, diminishing the "high-value" population.

Right Page:

  • The right page features a composite photograph or photomontage.
  • In the photo, Adolf Hitler is shown in a familiar pose, standing on a platform, pointing and gesturing towards a crowd.
  • Above and slightly behind him is a large, monumental statue of a lion.
  • A speech bubble emanates from Hitler with a quote that can be translated as "These people behave like animals on which the application of the laws made for them is not possible anymore."

Overall Interpretation:

The book spread appears to be analyzing the use of dehumanizing language and imagery in political rhetoric. The quotes on the left page and the Nazi-era charts demonstrate how some politicians and regimes have used language and "scientific" data to denigrate and marginalize certain groups of people. The photomontage juxtaposes Hitler with the lion statue, possibly connecting his words to the idea of people as animals or beasts. The text likely emphasizes the dangers of such rhetoric and the potential for dehumanization to lead to discrimination and violence. The focus is on Franz Josef Strauß and the use of animal references to stoke anxieties and potentially dehumanize political opponents.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-06-03

The image is a page from a publication. On the left side of the page, there is text in German with quotes and diagrams that appear to be from a Nazi propaganda book. The text discusses the Nazi's views on "inferior" people. On the right side, there is a photo of Adolf Hitler giving a speech, with a large lion statue behind him. A speech bubble comes from Hitler, stating, "These people behave like animals, which makes the application of the laws not possible." The text at the bottom of the page states that the image is intended to be ironic. It also contains a quote from Imanuel Geiss on the use of animalistic language in politics.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-09

The image is a two-page spread from a book or magazine. It includes a combination of text, graphics, and a historical photograph. Here is a detailed summary of each element:

Left Page:

  1. Text Excerpt:

    • The text is a quote from "F. J. Strauß - Retter des Vaterlands" by Imanuel Geiss. It criticizes Franz Josef Strauß, describing him as a "Wohlstandsrandalierer" (prosperity vandal) and an "Organisierte Bande politischer Landstreicher" (organized gang of political vagabonds). It accuses him of creating a modern zoological garden filled with predators like Rauschgift (drugs), Masismus (possibly a typo for Masochism), and freier Liebe (free love). The text also mentions that Strauß is driven by a need for power and that he is a "verdrehte Vietkonganhänger" (twisted Vietnam supporter) who drives public history distortion.
  2. Graphics:

    • There are three graphics, likely from a 1934 NS-Propagandabuch (Nazi propaganda book). These graphics seem to illustrate statistical data related to the elimination of "minderwertigen" (inferior) people from society. The graphics include:
      • A pie chart showing the distribution of different types of "minderwertigen."
      • A bar graph comparing the number of "minderwertigen" before and after certain measures.
      • A diagram illustrating the financial burden of "minderwertigen" on the state.
  3. Commentary:

    • The commentary below the graphics explains that these visuals were used to justify the elimination of certain groups of people deemed inferior by the Nazi regime. It highlights the propaganda techniques used to dehumanize and rationalize the persecution of these individuals.

Right Page:

  1. Photograph:

    • The photograph shows Franz Josef Strauß speaking at a podium in front of a large crowd. He is gesturing with his hand, and there is a statue of a lion behind him. The setting appears to be an outdoor event.
  2. Speech Bubble:

    • A speech bubble next to Strauß contains a quote from him, stating that the animals in the zoo are there to be viewed and not to be fed by visitors.
  3. Caption:

    • The caption below the photograph explains that Strauß gave this speech in Bamberg in 1969. It mentions that he was referring to a personal referent, Marcel Hepp, and that the CSU (Christian Social Union) did not want to comment on the incident.

Overall Theme:

The spread appears to be a critical examination of Franz Josef Strauß's political rhetoric and actions, comparing them to Nazi propaganda techniques. It uses historical graphics and a contemporary photograph to illustrate the parallels and contrasts between the two periods.

Text analysis

Amazon

Rausch-
lassen
gefallen,
nicht
Kritik
gern
aber
Bande
Verdreckten.'
dagegen.
uns
"Organisierte
Wir lassen uns Kritik gefallen, aber nicht von Ungewaschenen
Notstand
Maoismus
Wir
"allenfalls
politischer
moderner
Landstreicher",
Ungewaschenen
sich
"Wohlstandsrandalierer", "Organisierte Bande politischer Landstreicher",
"verdreckte
wulrden,
ein
von
haben
mehr haben hatte ich nichts dagegen.
Garten.
Sie
hatte
etwas
"allenfalls ein moderner zoologischer
ich
nichts
und
Maoismus und freier Liebe ernahrt.'
Garten. in dem man sich von Rausch-
den
ernahrt.'
man
mehr
oben."
freier Liebe
Sie haben den Notstand da oben."
"Wenn Sie etwas Hirn wulrden, so
dem
Hirn
da
zoologischer
"Wohlstandsrandalierer",
"Wenn
in
so

Google

Wir lassen uns Kritik gern gefallen, aber nicht von Ungewaschenen und Verdreckten," "Wohlstandsrandalierer", "Organisierte Bande politischer Landstreicher", "allenfalls ein moderner zoologischer Garten, in dem man sich von Rausch- gift, Maoismus und freier Liebe ernährt." "Wenn Sie etwas mehr Hirn haben würden, so hätte ich nichts dage gen Sie haben den Notstand da oben. verdreckte Vietkonganhänger, die da öffentlich Geschlechtsverkehr treiben." "Sie haben sich in Bamberg auch benommen wie die Viecher.. ." Diese Personen benehmen sich wie Tiere, auf die die Aswenhung der 1ür Menschen gemachten Gesetze nicht moglich ist (Zitate aus "F.J. Strauß-Retter des Vaterlands" von Imanuel Geiss) Was hoften die erbminderwertigenAngenommen ein Volk betehe aus Es koften täglich: STAMMVATER KALLIKAK Andang des Jalhunderts EnKüppelBlinder 5-b ein Geheakranker4 Aein Verbrecher 350 HOUVECE 50%s fathtriceerlede ha Gt inaVebindung en deherANfasnung mt ciner Schch d hat&nde n den oGndem lees he dem 1Ed he 496 Daon nd u 2 Akaholker Daven d: r 4Gefunde 1Entgleper ns ARohler 495 d tige Z d erdew wnd hat 1d 480 NACH 100 JAHREN , Geh o 3Vee BeomOal 00m g h 493 23% HOoNanc MAgm R% NACH300 JAHREN Ein Arbeter hat toglidh mit feiner fanilie 3-4 RM QUszugebms 4%woown MN 96% Die drei Grafiken stammen aus einem NS-Propa gandabuch des Jahres 1934. Das waren die Lehrbeispiele, die das Volk vorbereiten sollten, künftig zwischen minderwertigen und hochwertigen Menschen zu unter- scheiden. Das Lernziel lautete: Die Beseitigung minderwertiger Volksteile ist eine Notwendigkeit! Auch Strauß' Aussprüche charakterisieren einen Teil der Bevölkerung eindeutig als minderwertig. Besonders meinungsbildend wirken seine Diffamierungen auf jene, die nie gelernt haben, Vorurteile rational zu überprüfen. Und besonders verständnisvoll reagieren diejeni gen, die eine Unterscheidung zwischen 'Hochwertigen' und 'Minderwertigen' schon einmal gelernt haben. Wer inmmer noch keinen Zusammenhang zwischen der nationalsozialistischen Haltung gegenüber bestimmten Minderheiten und der Minderheitenhetze des Franz Josef Strauß erkennt, der schaue sich die Fotomontage rechts an und beachte, wie erschrek- kend 'sinnvoll' das Tierzitat wirkt. Zu welchen Zwecken Strauß solche Vorfälle wie in Bamberg 1969 mit seinem berüchtigten APO-Tierzitat aufbauscht, enthüllte sein persönlicher Referent Marcel Hepp einen Tag vor der Bundestagswahl am 28. 9. 1969 in Gegenwart von Strauß:" Wenn die CSU ihre Stimmen hält, ist das nur auf das Tierzitat zurückzuführen." (Imanuel Geiss) te
Wir
lassen
uns
Kritik
gern
gefallen,
aber
nicht
von
Ungewaschenen
und
Verdreckten,"
"Wohlstandsrandalierer",
"Organisierte
Bande
politischer
Landstreicher",
"allenfalls
ein
moderner
zoologischer
Garten,
in
dem
man
sich
Rausch-
gift,
Maoismus
freier
Liebe
ernährt."
"Wenn
Sie
etwas
mehr
Hirn
haben
würden,
so
hätte
ich
nichts
dage
gen
den
Notstand
da
oben.
verdreckte
Vietkonganhänger,
die
öffentlich
Geschlechtsverkehr
treiben."
"Sie
Bamberg
auch
benommen
wie
Viecher..
."
Diese
Personen
benehmen
Tiere,
auf
Aswenhung
der
1ür
Menschen
gemachten
Gesetze
moglich
ist
(Zitate
aus
"F.J.
Strauß-Retter
des
Vaterlands"
Imanuel
Geiss)
Was
hoften
erbminderwertigenAngenommen
Volk
betehe
Es
koften
täglich:
STAMMVATER
KALLIKAK
Andang
Jalhunderts
EnKüppelBlinder
5-b
Geheakranker4
Aein
Verbrecher
350
HOUVECE
50%s
fathtriceerlede
ha
Gt
inaVebindung
en
deherANfasnung
mt
ciner
Schch
d
hat&nde
n
oGndem
lees
he
1Ed
496
Daon
nd
u
2
Akaholker
Daven
d:
r
4Gefunde
1Entgleper
ns
ARohler
495
tige
Z
erdew
wnd
hat
1d
480
NACH
100
JAHREN
,
Geh
o
3Vee
BeomOal
00m
g
h
493
23%
HOoNanc
MAgm
R%
NACH300
Ein
Arbeter
toglidh
mit
feiner
fanilie
3-4
RM
QUszugebms
4%woown
MN
96%
Die
drei
Grafiken
stammen
einem
NS-Propa
gandabuch
Jahres
1934.
Das
waren
Lehrbeispiele,
das
vorbereiten
sollten,
künftig
zwischen
minderwertigen
hochwertigen
zu
unter-
scheiden.
Lernziel
lautete:
Beseitigung
minderwertiger
Volksteile
eine
Notwendigkeit!
Auch
Strauß'
Aussprüche
charakterisieren
einen
Teil
Bevölkerung
eindeutig
als
minderwertig.
Besonders
meinungsbildend
wirken
seine
Diffamierungen
jene,
nie
gelernt
haben,
Vorurteile
rational
überprüfen.
Und
besonders
verständnisvoll
reagieren
diejeni
gen,
Unterscheidung
'Hochwertigen'
'Minderwertigen'
schon
einmal
haben.
Wer
inmmer
noch
keinen
Zusammenhang
nationalsozialistischen
Haltung
gegenüber
bestimmten
Minderheiten
Minderheitenhetze
Franz
Josef
Strauß
erkennt,
schaue
Fotomontage
rechts
an
beachte,
erschrek-
kend
'sinnvoll'
Tierzitat
wirkt.
Zu
welchen
Zwecken
solche
Vorfälle
1969
seinem
berüchtigten
APO-Tierzitat
aufbauscht,
enthüllte
sein
persönlicher
Referent
Marcel
Hepp
Tag
vor
Bundestagswahl
am
28.
9.
Gegenwart
Strauß:"
Wenn
CSU
ihre
Stimmen
hält,
nur
zurückzuführen."
(Imanuel
te