Unable to open [object Object]: HTTP 0 attempting to load TileSource

Human Generated Data

Title

Untitled (Civil Works Administration demonstration, near the United States Customs House, New York City)

Date

December 1933-March 1934

People

Artist: Ben Shahn, American 1898 - 1969

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Bernarda Bryson Shahn, P1970.3969

Copyright

© President and Fellows of Harvard College

Human Generated Data

Title

Untitled (Civil Works Administration demonstration, near the United States Customs House, New York City)

People

Artist: Ben Shahn, American 1898 - 1969

Date

December 1933-March 1934

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Bernarda Bryson Shahn, P1970.3969

Copyright

© President and Fellows of Harvard College

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2023-10-06

Clothing 99.9
Coat 99.9
People 99.7
Wedding 95.9
Face 73.6
Head 73.6
Outdoors 68.5
Text 61.5
Parade 57.5
Protest 57.5
Cross 57.4
Symbol 57.4
Fashion 55.9
Overcoat 55.7
Architecture 55.2
Building 55.2
Monastery 55.2

Clarifai
created on 2018-05-10

people 99.7
group together 97.7
many 96.4
group 96.1
man 95.5
monochrome 94.9
adult 94.3
crowd 92.5
war 92.1
street 90.7
military 87.4
wear 84.2
soldier 82.6
winter 80.1
child 77.3
skirmish 74.3
city 74.2
light 74
snow 72.9
woman 70.7

Imagga
created on 2023-10-06

picket fence 41.5
fence 37.6
cemetery 36.9
architecture 28.3
structure 28.1
barrier 27.7
sky 27.6
city 25
building 23.6
landscape 23.1
pier 21
wall 20.7
old 19.5
water 19.4
obstruction 17.9
town 16.7
travel 16.2
house 15.4
history 15.2
river 15.1
urban 14.9
tourism 14.9
tower 14.8
sunset 13.5
sea 13.3
ship 12.5
skyline 12.4
rural 12.3
boat 12.1
ocean 11.9
grunge 11.9
support 11.8
landmark 11.7
panorama 11.4
hill 11.3
exterior 11.1
clouds 11
prison 10.8
vintage 10.8
construction 10.3
church 10.2
car 10.2
silhouette 9.9
device 9.9
barn 9.9
freight car 9.9
metal 9.7
black 9.6
scene 9.5
sunrise 9.4
power 9.2
tree 9.2
bridge 9.2
industrial 9.1
factory 9
scenery 9
retro 9
coast 9
night 8.9
scenic 8.8
light 8.7
culture 8.6
winter 8.5
famous 8.4
field 8.4
countryside 8.2
dirty 8.1
farm building 8
correctional institution 7.9
antique 7.8
cloud 7.8
industry 7.7
panoramic 7.7
outdoor 7.7
historical 7.5
monument 7.5
vacation 7.4
wheeled vehicle 7.4
steel 7.2
holiday 7.2
grass 7.1
stone 7.1
center 7

Google
created on 2018-05-10

Color Analysis

Face analysis

Amazon

AWS Rekognition

Age 39-47
Gender Male, 99.9%
Happy 38.7%
Confused 23.9%
Calm 12.7%
Sad 11.8%
Fear 7%
Surprised 6.9%
Angry 4.6%
Disgusted 3.5%

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person
Adult
Bride
Female
Woman
Hat

Clarifai

Person
Clothing
Human face

AWS Rekognition

Person 95.9%

Categories

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2018-05-10

a black and white photo of a building 64.5%
a large white building 53.3%
a black and white photo of a city 53.2%

Clarifai

No captions written

Salesforce

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-31

a photograph of a group of people standing in front of a building

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip-2 on 2025-07-07

a group of people holding signs in front of a building

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-11-20 on 2025-06-11

This is a negative photographic image showing a group of people gathered for a protest or demonstration. They are holding various signs with slogans advocating for labor rights and continued employment under the Civil Works Administration (CWA). Some visible phrases on the signs include "Join Relief Workers League," "Continue/Extend CWA Jobs," and "CWA Pay in Full Rain or Shine." There are also calls for unionization and recognition of workers' committees. The photo is likely from the Great Depression era, as the CWA was active during this time, created to provide jobs as part of New Deal efforts in the United States. The backdrop includes a building resembling public or civic architecture, reinforcing the idea that this event is tied to social and governmental issues.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-08-06 on 2025-06-11

The image is a negative photograph depicting a group of people holding protest signs. The people are gathered closely together, and the signs they hold contain various messages. Some of the signs read "JOIN RELIEF WORKERS LEAGUE, 29 E. 30 ST.," "CONTINUE CLEAN BOYS' CLOTHING C.W.A. JOBS," "C.W.A. PAY IN FULL - RAIN OR SHINE," and "WE WANT C.W.A. OR RELIEF." The scene appears to represent a protest or demonstration advocating for Civil Works Administration (C.W.A.) jobs and fair pay, likely during the Great Depression era, as the C.W.A. was a program employed to give jobs to unemployed workers during that time. The people are wearing hats and coats, suggesting it might be taken in a colder season. In the background, there are structures that could be part of a fair or exhibition space, given their architectural style. The contrast of the negative image makes dark elements light and light elements dark.

Anthropic Claude

Created by anthropic.claude-3-haiku-20240307-v1:0 on 2025-06-14

The image appears to depict a large crowd of people gathered for what seems to be a protest or demonstration. The crowd is holding various signs and banners with slogans and demands, suggesting they are advocating for a particular cause or issue. The scene is captured in a black and white photograph, giving it a historical feel. The crowd appears to be densely packed, with individuals wearing coats and hats, indicating the image was likely taken in a colder season or environment.

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-14

This is a black and white historical photograph showing what appears to be a labor protest or demonstration. The image shows a large group of people, likely workers, standing in a line holding protest signs. The signs reference "CWA" (Communications Workers of America) and include messages about pay, relief, and union rights. The protesters are dressed in what appears to be 1930s or 1940s era clothing, wearing coats and hats typical of that period. The signs they're holding include slogans like "JOIN RELIEF WORKERS LEAGUE" and "CONTINUE CWA JOBS." The photo appears to be taken at night or in low light conditions, and there are some buildings visible in the background. The image is credited to the Harvard University Art Museums.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-01

The image depicts a black-and-white photograph of a group of people, predominantly men, dressed in white attire and hats, holding signs with various messages. The signs are mostly illegible due to the low quality of the image, but some phrases can be discerned, such as "CONTINUE RELIEF WORKERS LEAGUE," "C.W.A. PAY IN FULL - RAIN OR SHINE," and "WE WORK $13." The background features a large building with a dome-shaped roof and a flagpole, suggesting that the event is taking place in front of a government building or other official structure.

The overall atmosphere of the image suggests a protest or demonstration, with the participants advocating for better working conditions and higher wages. The use of signs and banners is a common tactic employed by protesters to convey their message and draw attention to their cause. The image provides a glimpse into the labor movement of the past, highlighting the struggles and challenges faced by workers in their quest for fair treatment and better working conditions.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-01

The image depicts a group of people gathered in front of a building, holding signs and protesting. The image is in black and white, with a grainy quality that makes it difficult to discern details.

  • People:
    • A large group of people are standing in front of a building.
    • They are all wearing coats and hats, suggesting that the photo was taken on a cold day.
    • Some of the people are holding signs, while others are standing with their arms crossed or holding hands.
  • Signs:
    • The signs being held by the protesters are not legible due to the grainy quality of the image.
    • However, it appears that the signs are related to labor rights or unionization, as they mention "CWA" and "JOBS".
  • Building:
    • The building behind the protesters is a large, imposing structure with a domed roof.
    • It appears to be some kind of government or institutional building, given its size and architecture.
  • Other objects:
    • There are several other objects visible in the background of the image, including a flagpole and a streetlight.
    • These objects add to the sense of context and setting, but do not provide much additional information about the protesters or their cause.

Overall, the image suggests that the protesters are advocating for better working conditions and labor rights, possibly as part of a larger movement or campaign. The grainy quality of the image makes it difficult to discern details, but the overall message and tone of the image are clear.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-05-31

A black-and-white photo shows a group of people standing in a row in front of a building. They are wearing white hats, coats, and pants. Some of them are holding signs with written messages, while others are holding a stick with a flag. The building has a dome-shaped roof and a flag on top. In the distance, there is a lamppost. There is a watermark on the bottom left corner.

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-05-31

The image depicts a nighttime scene of a large group of people, possibly workers, standing in a row and holding placards with written messages. The people are dressed in white coats, which could indicate a specific occupation or uniform. The placards have slogans like "JOIN RELIEF LEAGUE," "CONTINUE CWAJ JOBS," and "CWA PAY IN FULL," suggesting that the protest is related to labor rights and workers' demands.

The setting appears to be outdoors, with a building in the background that has a flag on top, possibly indicating a government or institutional building. The image has a monochromatic filter, giving it a historical or vintage feel. The watermark in the bottom left corner reads "President and Fellows of Harvard College (Harvard University Art Museums)," indicating that the image is part of a collection or archive.

Overall, the image portrays a protest or demonstration by workers demanding better working conditions, fair wages, and recognition of their rights. The use of placards and the organized formation of the protesters suggest a well-coordinated and planned event, possibly part of a larger movement or campaign for labor rights.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-06-05

Certainly! Here's a description of the image based on the content provided:

General Description:

The image shows a group of people participating in a protest or demonstration. They are holding signs with slogans and demands related to work, pay, and union representation. The setting appears to be an outdoor public space, possibly in front of a building.

Details:

  • Protesters: The group consists primarily of adults, dressed in overcoats, hats, and similar attire typical of the early to mid-20th century. They are positioned in rows, suggesting an organized march or demonstration.

  • Signs: The protesters are carrying signs with a variety of messages, including:

    • "Cognize W.A. Job Grievance Committees"
    • "Join Relief Workers League, 29 E. 20 St."
    • "Continue Extend C.W.A. Jobs!"
    • "C.W.A. Pay In Full - Rain or Shine"
    • "Demand Right to Organize on C.W.A. Jobs"
    • "We Want C.W.A Union Relief"
    • "Relief Workers League"
    • "$13,00 C.W.A"
  • Background: The background contains buildings, one with a cupola.

  • Overall Impression:

    The image conveys a sense of organized action and the pursuit of better working conditions and economic relief. It speaks to historical movements and the struggle for workers' rights.

If you would like a specific part of the image described in more detail, just let me know!

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-06-05

Here's a description of the image:

Overall Impression:

The image is a black and white, seemingly inverted photograph depicting a labor protest. A large group of people are marching, holding signs and protesting. The picture appears to have been taken outdoors.

Key Elements:

  • Protesters: The main subject is a large group of people, likely workers, marching in a line. They are holding up signs with various demands and slogans, indicating that it is a labor protest.
  • Signs: The signs held by the protestors are the focal point of the image. From the cropped images, the signs read "COGNIZE W.A. JOB GREIVANCE OMMITTEES," "JOIN RELIEF WORKERS LEAGUE 29 E. 20 ST.," "CONTINUE EXTEND C.W.A. JOBS!", "C.W.A. PAY IN FULL - A RAIN - SHINE UTS," "DEMAND RIGHT TO ORGANIZE ON C.W.A JOBS," "MONS 10A - WE WORK $13.00," "CONTINUE EXTEN C.W.A.J" and "WE WA C.W.A. UNION RELIE". The content of the signs suggests issues related to employment, labor rights, and possibly working conditions.
  • Architecture in the Background: Buildings with decorative architectural details are visible in the background. These structures might be a city hall, a courthouse, or another public building.
  • Setting: The setting appears to be an urban environment, likely a street where the protestors are marching.

Overall, the image captures the essence of a historical labor protest, and shows the workers are advocating for improvements in their jobs or conditions of employment.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-03

The image depicts a group of people participating in a protest or rally. The crowd is predominantly composed of women, dressed in long coats and hats, which suggests the event took place during the early to mid-20th century. They are holding signs with various slogans related to labor rights and the Civil Works Administration (CWA). Some of the visible signs read:

  • "RECOGNIZE CWA JOB REPLACEMENT COMMITTEES"
  • "JOIN RELIEF WORKERS LEAGUE 24 E 20th"
  • "CONTINUE EXTEND CWA JOBS"
  • "CWA PAY DAY IN FULL - A RAIN OR SHINE"
  • "DEMAND RIGHT TO ORGANIZE ON ALL CWA JOBS"
  • "CONTINUE EXTEND CWA JOBS AT UNION WAGES"
  • "RECOGNIZE CWA JOB REPLACEMENT COMMITTEES"

The setting appears to be outdoors, possibly in an urban area, as there are buildings visible in the background. The overall atmosphere of the image conveys a sense of solidarity and collective action among the participants. The photograph is in black and white, which further supports the historical context of the event.

Qwen

No captions written

Text analysis

Amazon

Fellows
Harvard
Museums)
College
and
Art
UTS
University
UNION
WE
CONTINUE
COGNIZE
President and Fellows of Harvard College (Harvard University Art Museums)
(Harvard
RELIEF
IN
RAIN
of
WE W
REL
DEMAND
OR
ORGANIZE
C.W.A.
LEAGUE
JOBS!
W
D
EXTEND
OMMITTEES
JOB
WORKERS
RIGHT
JOIN
AT
SHINE
P1970.3969.0000
A
ON
C.W.A.PAY
President
REIVANCE
104
W.A. JOB
WORA
IN FULL- A
$13.000
W.A.
WEWORK
MOSES 104 EXTEN
EXTEN
in
C.W.A
CONTI C.W.A
C.W.A.PAY D 100 ORGANIZE
19
CONTI
C.W.A.J
RAIN m
MOSES
FULL-
19 E. 20st.
LEAL
E.
20st.
m
RLLIC
13
DEATH
2L
S
a DEATH
CWAJOBS
100
a
NOW
SC

Google

WE W CONTIR CWA CoGNIZE W.A. JOB REIVANG OMMITTES DEMAND REL JOI CONTINUE EXTEND LEA WORKERS LEAGUE I C.W. SHINE İTS @ President and Fellows of Harvard College (Harvard University Art Museums) P1970.3969.0000
WE
W
CONTIR
CWA
CoGNIZE
W.A.
JOB
REIVANG
OMMITTES
DEMAND
REL
JOI
CONTINUE
EXTEND
LEA
WORKERS
LEAGUE
I
C.W.
SHINE
İTS
@
President
and
Fellows
of
Harvard
College
(Harvard
University
Art
Museums)
P1970.3969.0000