Human Generated Data

Title

Don't! (or The Solid South against the Union)

Date

1876

People

Artist: Thomas Nast, American 1840 - 1902

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Purchase through the generosity of Melvin R. Seiden, M23242

Human Generated Data

Title

Don't! (or The Solid South against the Union)

People

Artist: Thomas Nast, American 1840 - 1902

Date

1876

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Purchase through the generosity of Melvin R. Seiden, M23242

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2022-03-04

Person 99.3
Human 99.3
Person 91.5
Art 91.2
Drawing 89.6
Person 87.5
Painting 87
Weapon 83.9
Weaponry 83.9
Person 79
Cannon 78.2
Sketch 76.9
Person 75.9
People 55.9

Clarifai
created on 2023-10-29

print 99.9
illustration 99.7
people 99.6
art 99.5
man 98.4
adult 97.8
cavalry 97.7
weapon 97.7
group 97.4
engraving 96
painting 94.8
veil 94.5
lithograph 94.4
sword 94
war 94
military 94
sepia pigment 92.7
wear 92.7
vintage 91.7
two 91.4

Imagga
created on 2022-03-04

old 33.4
sketch 32.2
antique 29.1
drawing 27
grunge 26.4
vintage 25
aged 23.5
ancient 23.3
paper 21.9
representation 20.7
texture 20.1
wall 18.8
art 18.2
architecture 18
decoration 17.8
historic 17.4
history 16.1
old fashioned 15.2
structure 15.1
retro 14.7
artistic 13.9
grain 13.8
travel 13.4
grungy 13.3
dirty 12.6
brown 12.5
worn 12.4
textured 12.3
pirate 12.2
grime 11.7
city 11.6
wallpaper 11.5
ornate 11
frame 10.8
material 10.8
building 10.4
historical 10.3
pattern 10.3
culture 10.2
landmark 9.9
detail 9.6
decay 9.6
stain 9.6
obsolete 9.6
tourism 9.1
design 9
fracture 8.7
crumpled 8.7
sculpture 8.6
ornament 8.6
damaged 8.6
blank 8.6
leaf 8.6
flower 8.5
page 8.3
traditional 8.3
style 8.2
paint 8.1
border 8.1
backgrounds 8.1
graphic 8
holiday 7.9
smudged 7.9
text 7.9
mottled 7.8
sepia 7.8
space 7.8
empty 7.7
rusty 7.6
monument 7.5
gold 7.4
effect 7.3
rough 7.3
color 7.2
vessel 7

Google
created on 2022-03-04

Art 80.3
Painting 77.4
Horse 76.2
Working animal 74.2
Illustration 70
Drawing 68.6
Visual arts 64.2
Pack animal 60.1
Artwork 60
Sketch 59.1
History 58.8
Printmaking 58.3
Line art 54.4
Spear 53.8
Paper product 53.6
Mythology 50.2

Microsoft
created on 2022-03-04

text 100
book 99.7
drawing 98.4
sketch 98.2
engraving 76.4
cartoon 72.3
illustration 53.7

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person
Painting
Person 99.3%
Person 91.5%
Person 87.5%
Person 79%
Person 75.9%
Painting 87%

Categories

Captions

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-01-29

This image is an illustration from Harper's Weekly, a prominent American political magazine of the 19th century. The illustration appears to be a satirical or metaphorical representation of political tensions or conflicts relating to post-Civil War America. Key elements of the illustration include: 1. The central image of a cannon, labeled "Solid South 1876," being aimed at a fortress flying an American flag, symbolizing the Union. 2. The cannon is being loaded and managed by men, suggesting an organized effort or campaign. 3. There are ruins and debris scattered around the cannon, with remnants from the Civil War, including broken cannons and structures, potentially representing the ongoing struggles and aftermath of the war. 4. The left side of the image contains references to the Emancipation Proclamation and the "National Debt," tying the scene to political and historical issues of the era, including the liberation of enslaved people and economic concerns. 5. There's an older flag labeled "Solid South 1861," indicating a reference to the Confederacy. 6. The image overall conveys a sense of tension between the reconstructed US government and lingering Confederate sentiments or opposition from the Southern states. The image suggests that even after the Civil War and during the Reconstruction era, there were significant conflicts and resistance from the Southern states (the "Solid South"), alluding to ongoing political strife and division in the United States.

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-01-29

The image appears to be a political cartoon from a historic publication, possibly depicting a scene related to American Civil War era sentiments. On the left side, there is a large pile of broken objects and debris labeled with words such as "Emancipation" with A. Lincoln, "Paroled," and "RUN" with "Not to be Recognized by the N.O." At the base of this pile, two human skulls are visible, and there are pieces of paper that read "Repudiation," suggesting a rejection or denial of some sort. In the center is a large cannon with "The Solid South" and the date "1880" embossed on it, which seems to point toward the post-Civil War concept of the Southern United States as a monolithic political entity. To the right of the cannon, a group of men are standing by another cannon being prepared to fire, with some onlookers witnessing the event. A flag that reads "The Solid South Union" is raised nearby. In the background, there is a fort with an American flag, and ships are present in the distant water. The scene creates a sense of rebuilding or preparing for action, and the broken and discarded items on the left could represent the remnants of policies or ideas from the Civil War and Reconstruction era that were being left behind or rejected by certain political factions at the time. The setting appears somewhat chaotic with a variety of objects strewn about, symbolizing potentially the turmoil or fragmented nature of the political landscape during that period. The words "Harper's Weekly" at the top suggest that this illustration was published in that periodical which was known for its illustrations and political cartoons of the period. The presence of Abraham Lincoln's name associated with 'Emancipation' indicates that this cartoon may be referencing the aftermath of the Civil War and the ongoing impact of Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation and other wartime measures.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2025-01-29

This is a political cartoon from Harper's Weekly, appearing to be from the American Civil War era. The image shows a military fortification with cannons and a Union flag flying above. In the foreground, there are large artillery pieces or "solid shot" ammunition, and some soldiers are depicted manning what appears to be defensive positions. There's a fort visible in the background across what seems to be a body of water. The scene appears to be depicting a military defensive position, possibly Fort Sumter or another Union stronghold. The style is typical of 19th-century editorial illustrations, with detailed crosshatching and shading techniques. The word "DON'T!" appears below the image, suggesting this may be a warning or statement about military readiness or defense.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2025-01-29

The image appears to be an old political cartoon or engraving depicting war and destruction. In the foreground, there are large broken cannons and other military equipment lying in ruins. Soldiers can be seen walking through the debris. In the background, there is a fort or castle flying a flag that says "South Division", likely indicating this depicts the aftermath of a battle during the American Civil War between Union and Confederate forces. The overall scene conveys a sense of the devastation and upheaval caused by war.

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2025-01-29

This image appears to be a satirical cartoon or illustration from Harper's Weekly, dating back to a time period when the United States was divided, likely around the time of the American Civil War. The image depicts a chaotic and disorganized scene, with various symbols and elements representing the conflict and turmoil of the era. There are several human figures visible, but I will not identify or name them specifically, as per the instructions provided. Instead, I can describe the overall scene and the symbolic nature of the different elements portrayed.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-13

The image depicts a cartoon titled "A. Lincoln" and "The South in Arms," created by Thomas Nast for Harper's Weekly in 1861. The cartoon is a satirical representation of the American Civil War, specifically focusing on the conflict between the Union and the Confederacy. **Key Elements:** * **Lincoln:** The cartoon features a large, imposing figure of Abraham Lincoln, the 16th President of the United States, who is shown as a giant, muscular man with a stern expression. He is depicted as a powerful force, symbolizing the strength and determination of the Union. * **The South in Arms:** On the right side of the cartoon, a group of Confederate soldiers are shown, armed and ready for battle. They are depicted as smaller and weaker compared to Lincoln, highlighting the perceived inferiority of the Confederacy. * **Fort Sumter:** In the background, Fort Sumter, a federal fort in Charleston Harbor, South Carolina, is visible. The fort was the site of the first battle of the Civil War, which took place on April 12-13, 1861. * **Symbolism:** The cartoon uses symbolism to convey its message. The large size of Lincoln's head and body represents the power and strength of the Union, while the smaller size of the Confederate soldiers represents the weakness and inferiority of the Confederacy. The fort in the background serves as a reminder of the conflict that sparked the war. * **Style:** The cartoon is drawn in a detailed and realistic style, with intricate lines and shading. The use of chiaroscuro, a technique that uses strong contrasts between light and dark to create a sense of volume and depth, adds to the overall effect of the cartoon. **Overall:** The cartoon "A. Lincoln" and "The South in Arms" is a powerful and thought-provoking representation of the American Civil War. Through its use of symbolism and detailed drawing, it conveys the message that the Union is strong and determined, while the Confederacy is weak and inferior. The cartoon serves as a reminder of the conflict that shaped the United States and continues to be an important part of American history.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-13

This image is a political cartoon from Harper's Weekly, dated 1865. The cartoon depicts a scene with two large cannons, one labeled "Solid South 1876" and the other "Solid South 1861." A group of men are shown attempting to load the cannons, while a man in the center appears to be sleeping or dead, with a flagpole behind him bearing a flag that reads "Solid South of the Union." The cartoon also features various other elements, including a man sitting on the ground, a sign that reads "Emancipation Proclamation A. Lincoln," and a building in the background. The overall tone of the cartoon appears to be critical of the Solid South, a term used to describe the Democratic Party's dominance in the Southern United States during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The cartoon may be suggesting that the Solid South is trying to revive its power and influence, but is ultimately unsuccessful due to the efforts of those who oppose it. The image is likely intended to be humorous and satirical, using exaggeration and irony to make a point about the political climate of the time.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-01-29

The image is a black-and-white drawing of a war scene. There are three men standing in front of a cannon, and one of them is holding a stick. The cannon has the words "SOLID SOUTH 1876" written on it. There is a flag with the words "THE SOLID SOUTH A GANG AGAINST THE UNION" written on it. There are also some broken cannons and other objects on the ground.

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-01-29

This image is a black-and-white illustration that depicts a scene from the American Civil War. The image features a flagpole with a flag that reads "The Solid South A Can't Gain The Union" and a cannon with the words "Solid South 1876" on it. There are several soldiers standing around the cannon, and one of them is holding a rifle. In the background, there is a fort with a flag flying on top, and a ship is sailing on the water. The image also includes a watermark that reads "HARPER'S WEEKLY" and the date "1876."

Text analysis

Amazon

WEEKLY
TION
PAROLED
EMANCIPA TION
SOUTH
EMANCIPA
1876
1865
HARPER'S WEEKLY
UNION
RUIN
NATIONAL
SOLID
THE
OLID
GRANT
SOLID 1876 SOUT THE
SOUT
CLAIMS
HARPER'S
SOLID SOUTH
SOUTHERN
PROCLAMATION
RUIN y
SOLID 186, THE SOUTH 1865
A.LINCOLN.
A
-
y
RIFLE
...
892
RIFLE CLUB
SOUTHERN -
CLUB
MINUTE
DON'T!
MUST
- GAINST3
DEAD S. GRANT
DEMOCRATS
MARTI
S.
ME
E
DEBT
186,
MINE
MINUTE SODIUL
MINE =
THE WAIT USIGN TOR
ALEGAD
=
TIC E
898
91603442 THE 244 MARTI
GAINST3
ALEGAD the
TIC
244
WAIT
SODIUL
KOREA
DEAD
USIGN
KE
Th Not
91603442
FIGGEN
the
TOR
MDIA

Google

HARPERS WEEKLY SOLID DON'T! SOUTH 1865
HARPERS
WEEKLY
SOLID
DON'T!
SOUTH
1865