Human Generated Data

Title

You Have Not Converted a Man Because You Have Silenced Him

Date

1968

People

Artist: Ben Shahn, American 1898 - 1969

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Stephen Lee Taller Ben Shahn Archive, Gift of Dolores Taller, M24943

Copyright

© Estate of Ben Shahn / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York

Human Generated Data

Title

You Have Not Converted a Man Because You Have Silenced Him

People

Artist: Ben Shahn, American 1898 - 1969

Date

1968

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Stephen Lee Taller Ben Shahn Archive, Gift of Dolores Taller, M24943

Copyright

© Estate of Ben Shahn / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2022-05-28

Drawing 94.2
Art 94.2
Advertisement 83.1
Face 82.7
Poster 82.4
Sketch 79.4
Text 73.3
Paper 71.7
Flyer 71.4
Brochure 71.4
Portrait 63.6
Photography 63.6
Photo 63.6

Clarifai
created on 2023-10-30

vector 98.6
chalk out 98.2
illustration 95.8
man 93.2
no person 93.1
people 92.9
sketchy 91.7
retro 89.8
freehand 87.8
typography 87.7
graphic design 86.4
sketch 86.2
adult 85.5
scribble 84.8
design 84.6
art 84.4
paper 84.3
text 84
nature 82.5
card 82.4

Imagga
created on 2022-05-28

sketch 71.9
drawing 69.6
representation 41
cartoon 34
art 29
black 24.1
design 20.9
outline 19
clip art 17.7
creation 16.8
graphic 16.1
silhouette 15.8
amulet 15.7
reflection 15.4
man 14.8
picture 14.2
animal 13.2
style 12.7
charm 12.4
shape 12
people 11.2
dance 10.6
set 10.2
symbol 10.1
painting 10
human 9.8
fun 9.8
contour 9.7
grunge 9.4
mine 9.3
hand 9.2
element 9.1
retro 9
cute 8.6
sign 8.3
toy 8.3
funny 8.3
artwork 8.3
book 8.3
pattern 8.2
children 8.2
group 8.1
icon 7.9
paper 7.9
holiday 7.9
plaything 7.9
drawn 7.9
comic 7.8
line 7.7
graphics 7.7
horse 7.6
decoration 7.5
excavation 7.4
cheerful 7.3
color 7.3
mammal 7.3
activity 7.2
little 7.1
creative 7.1

Google
created on 2022-05-28

Beard 90.1
Jaw 87.7
Gesture 85.3
Font 84
Art 81.4
Facial hair 79.2
Poster 79.1
Visual arts 67.5
Drawing 67.5
Elbow 66.6
Illustration 65.8
Rectangle 65
Line art 62.7
Moustache 62.2
Ink 61.8
Self-portrait 61.6
Paper 57.1
Human leg 55.4
Fictional character 54.3
Chest 54.2

Microsoft
created on 2022-05-28

text 99.9
sketch 99.2
drawing 99
cartoon 92.1
illustration 87.7
person 60.7
human face 60.2

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Poster
Poster 82.4%

Categories

Imagga

text visuals 92.8%
paintings art 6.7%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2022-05-28

text 39.7%

Clarifai
created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-02

a photograph of a drawing of a man with a mask on -100%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4 on 2024-12-05

This is an artistic poster featuring a combination of text and imagery. On the top half of the poster, there's a black and white sketch of a person's face and hands. The expression on the face is solemn or contemplative, with eyes that appear to be looking straight ahead, and the hands are positioned as if the person is deep in thought, with the chin resting on the hands.

The bottom half of the poster contains a quote in large, orange block letters that reads, "YOU HAVE NOT CONVERTED A MAN BECAUSE YOU HAVE SILENCED HIM." The quote is attributed to "(John, Viscount Morley, On Compromise, 1874)" and is included just below the larger text in the same shade of orange, but in a smaller font.

On the bottom of the poster, in small yet bold text, the phrase "Great Ideas of Western Man…one of a series" can be seen, followed by "Container Corporation of America," which is probably the organization that created or sponsored the poster.

The artist's signature, "Ben Shahn," is positioned just below the quote on the lower right side of the image. The overall design suggests a blend of art and philosophy, aiming to provoke thought on the topic of communication and persuasion.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2024-12-05

This is an illustration featuring an abstract sketch of a man's face, drawn in a rough, expressive style. The figure's hands are prominently shown in a contemplative or possibly restrained gesture. To the right of the illustration, there is a bold, orange text in all capital letters that reads:

"YOU HAVE NOT CONVERTED A MAN BECAUSE YOU HAVE SILENCED HIM (John, Viscount Morley, On Compromise, 1874)"

The poster is signed by Ben Shahn. At the bottom of the poster, there is text that states:

"Great Ideas of Western Man... one of a series
CCA Container Corporation of America"

This poster is part of a series highlighting significant ideas from Western thought, produced by the Container Corporation of America.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2024-12-05

This image appears to be a poster or advertisement with a sketch-like illustration of a person's face and an accompanying text message. The text states "YOU HAVE NOT CONVERTED A MAN BECAUSE YOU HAVE SILENCED HIM". The overall impression seems to convey a message about silencing or suppressing someone rather than truly converting or changing their perspective. The art style is expressive and rough, emphasizing the sentiment expressed in the text.

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2024-12-05

This is a striking black and white illustration with orange text, appearing to be part of a series called "Great Ideas of Western Man" by Container Corporation of America. The artwork features a sketchy, expressionist-style drawing of a contemplative figure in black and white. The text reads "YOU HAVE NOT CONVERTED A MAN BECAUSE YOU HAVE SILENCED HIM" and is attributed to John, Viscount Morley "On Compromise, 1874."

The illustration uses loose, gestural brushstrokes to create a pensive mood, with the figure appearing to be in deep thought. The contrast between the rough black brushwork and the clean orange typography creates a powerful visual impact. The message speaks to the importance of genuine dialogue and understanding versus merely silencing opposition - a timeless commentary on freedom of expression and meaningful discourse.

This appears to be part of a larger series of philosophical quotes and artistic interpretations that were used in corporate advertising by the Container Corporation of America, which was known for its sophisticated approach to advertising in the mid-20th century.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2024-12-05

The image is a poster with a quote and an illustration. The quote is in large orange text and reads, "YOU HAVE NOT CONVERTED A MAN BECAUSE YOU HAVE SILENCED HIM." The quote is attributed to John Viscount Morley, On Compromise, 1874.

  • The quote is written in large orange text.
  • The quote is attributed to John Viscount Morley, On Compromise, 1874.
  • The quote is about the importance of listening to others and not silencing them.
  • The quote is a reminder that true conversion comes from understanding and empathy, not from forcing one's beliefs on others.

The image also features an illustration of a man's face and body, drawn in black and white. The man is depicted with his hand raised to his chin, as if he is deep in thought. The illustration is simple but effective, conveying a sense of contemplation and introspection.

  • The illustration is of a man's face and body.
  • The man is depicted with his hand raised to his chin.
  • The illustration is simple but effective.
  • The illustration conveys a sense of contemplation and introspection.

Overall, the image is a powerful reminder of the importance of listening to others and not silencing them. The quote and illustration work together to convey a message that is both thought-provoking and visually striking.

  • The image is a powerful reminder of the importance of listening to others and not silencing them.
  • The quote and illustration work together to convey a message that is both thought-provoking and visually striking.
  • The image is a call to action, encouraging viewers to think critically about their own beliefs and behaviors.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2024-12-05

The image features a poster with a quote and an illustration. The quote, in orange text, reads: "YOU HAVE NOT CONVERTED A MAN BECAUSE YOU HAVE SILENCED HIM." Below the quote, in smaller black text, is the attribution: "(John Viscount Morley, On Compromise, 1874)."

To the left of the quote is a black-and-white illustration of a man's head and torso, depicted in a contemplative pose with his hand raised to his chin. The background of the poster is off-white, and at the bottom, there is a line of small black text that reads: "Great Ideas of Western Man... one of a series" followed by a logo for the Container Corporation of America.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-02-28

The image is a poster featuring a drawing of a man's face with a quote written in bold orange letters. The quote reads, "You have not converted a man because you have silenced him." The drawing of the man's face is in black and white, and it has a serious expression. The poster also includes the name of the artist, Ben Shahn, and the year of creation, 1974. The poster is part of a series called "Great Ideas of Western Man" and was created for the Container Corporation of America.

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-02-28

The image is a poster that features a quote from John, Viscount Morley, and a drawing of a man's face. The quote, "You have not converted a man because you have silenced him," is written in bold, orange letters on the right side of the poster. The drawing on the left side of the poster is a stylized depiction of a man's face, with exaggerated features and a contemplative expression. The drawing is in black and white, and the background of the poster is a light beige color. The poster also includes the text "Great Ideas of Western Man... one of a series" and the logo of the Container Corporation of America, which suggests that it is part of a series of posters produced by the company.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-04-27

The image is a vintage poster with a black and white sketch of a man deep in thought on the left side. The man's face is drawn with simple lines, and his hand is raised to his chin in a pondering gesture. The right side of the poster features a quote in large, orange, blocky letters that reads: "YOU HAVE NOT CONVERTED A MAN BECAUSE YOU HAVE SILENCED HIM." Below the quote, in smaller print, is the attribution: "(John, Viscount Morley, On Compromise, 1874)." The artist's signature, "Ben Shahn," is visible beneath the man's sketch. At the bottom, a slogan states "Great Ideas of Western Man... one of a series" followed by the logo of the "Container Corporation of America."

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-04-27

The image is a poster with a stark, expressive design featuring a drawing of a man deep in thought. The drawing is done in a loose, sketchy style, primarily using black lines and shading on a cream-colored background. The man's face is centrally positioned, with one hand resting on his chin in a contemplative gesture. His form is partially rendered, suggesting a bust, with details like the suggestion of clothing and the hint of a background.

To the right of the man's image, bold orange text states, "YOU HAVE NOT CONVERTED A MAN BECAUSE YOU HAVE SILENCED HIM." This quote, attributed to John Viscount Morley (On Compromise, 1874), is arranged vertically in a block letter style, drawing the eye.

Below the quote and image, the artist's signature "Ben Shahn" can be seen. Further below, text reads "Great Ideas of Western Man... one of a series" and the Container Corporation of America logo. The overall design of the poster is impactful, using strong visuals and a clear message to convey a philosophical statement.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-04-27

The image is a poster featuring a quote from John Viscount Morley, dated 1674. The quote reads: "You have not converted a man because you have silenced him." The text is prominently displayed in large, orange, block letters.

To the left of the text, there is a stylized black and white illustration of a person with their hand covering their mouth, suggesting a gesture of silence or contemplation. The illustration is done in a loose, sketchy style with bold lines.

At the bottom of the poster, there is a smaller text that reads "Great Ideas of Western Man... one of a series" along with the logo of the Container Corporation of America. The poster is signed by Ben Shahn, who is likely the artist responsible for the illustration.

Overall, the poster combines a powerful quote with a thought-provoking image to convey a message about the importance of genuine dialogue and understanding rather than mere silencing of opposition.

Text analysis

Amazon

YOU
HAVE
NOT
MAN
Corporation
CONVERTED
Great
BECAUSE
HiM
series
one
Container Corporation of America
Container
America
Ideas
of
A
Western
SiLENCED
Great Ideas of Western Man... one of a series
CCA
Viscount
On
a
Man...
(John,
Compromise,
(John, Viscount Morley, On Compromise, 1874)
1874)
Morley,
BenShahon

Google

YOU HAVE NOT CONVERTED A MAN BECAUSE YOU HAVE SILENCED HiM (John, Viscount Morley On Compromise, 1874) Ben Shaton Great Ideas of Western Man... one of a series CCA Container Corporation of America *
YOU
HAVE
NOT
CONVERTED
A
MAN
BECAUSE
SILENCED
HiM
(
John
,
Viscount
Morley
On
Compromise
1874
)
Ben
Shaton
Great
Ideas
of
Western
Man
...
one
a
series
CCA
Container
Corporation
America
*