Human Generated Data

Title

Birds over the City

Date

1968

People

Artist: Ben Shahn, American 1898 - 1969

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Stephen Lee Taller Ben Shahn Archive, Gift of Dolores Taller, M24942

Copyright

© Estate of Ben Shahn / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York

Human Generated Data

Title

Birds over the City

People

Artist: Ben Shahn, American 1898 - 1969

Date

1968

Classification

Prints

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Stephen Lee Taller Ben Shahn Archive, Gift of Dolores Taller, M24942

Copyright

© Estate of Ben Shahn / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2022-02-26

Art 97.7
Drawing 93.9
Modern Art 93.1
Painting 81.3
Bird 81.1
Animal 81.1
Sketch 72.5
Bird 72.1
Bird 68.9
Text 64.6
Bird 63.7
Poster 60.2
Advertisement 60.2
Doodle 58.2
Graphics 56.9

Clarifai
created on 2023-10-29

no person 97.7
art 96
people 95.8
man 95.8
retro 95.6
travel 95.1
vintage 94.6
illustration 94.4
woman 93.8
adult 93.3
sun 91.4
city 91.2
outdoors 90.8
street 90.6
architecture 89.3
old 89.1
wear 89
vacation 88.8
fashion 88.7
urban 88.6

Imagga
created on 2022-02-26

sketch 100
drawing 100
representation 79.8
art 30
amulet 25.9
silhouette 24.9
design 24.3
graphic 21.2
man 20.9
charm 20.4
decoration 18.4
cartoon 17.9
decorative 16.7
clip art 16.7
black 15.7
retro 15.6
pattern 14.4
vintage 13.3
ornament 13
symbol 12.8
creative 12.4
artistic 12.2
artwork 11.9
style 11.9
element 11.6
flower 11.6
male 11.4
floral 10.2
paint 10
fashion 9.8
grunge 9.4
frame 9.3
sport 9.1
people 8.9
decor 8.9
curve 8.8
ancient 8.7
line 8.6
animal 8.5
character 8.5
tree 8.5
one 8.2
person 7.9
season 7.8
elegant 7.7
wallpaper 7.7
set 7.7
hand 7.6
horse 7.6
elegance 7.6
sign 7.5
fun 7.5
swirl 7.4
border 7.3
music 7.2
modern 7
leaf 7

Google
created on 2022-02-26

Botany 88.1
Jaw 87.7
Organism 85.8
Gesture 85.3
Art 83.5
Line 82.2
Font 78.7
Illustration 76.9
Beard 75.5
Painting 73.4
Plant 73.3
Drawing 72.4
Visual arts 69.6
Design 68.3
Graphics 67.5
Line art 66
Poster 65.2
Tree 64.2
Facial hair 62.5
Artwork 61

Microsoft
created on 2022-02-26

text 99.9
drawing 99.6
sketch 99
book 98.7
art 98.6
cartoon 98.4
illustration 96.1
child art 90.5
painting 89.5

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Bird
Poster
Bird 81.1%

Categories

Imagga

paintings art 99.8%

Captions

Microsoft
created on 2022-02-26

a close up of a book 51.8%
a book on a table 45.5%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-05-13 on 2025-01-28

The image showcases a piece of abstract art. The upper part of the artwork contains illustrations of large birds, possibly in flight, shaded in a gradient of grey. The lower part features architectural elements, reminiscent of a stylized building facade, with arches and windows filled with blocks of primary colors—blue, red, and yellow. The signature "Ben Shahn" is visible in the lower right corner.

Created by gpt-4 on 2025-01-28

The image features an artwork with a stylized portrayal of a building, possibly a house or a station, created with bold black outlines on a lighter background. The building has a series of arches with a curved roofline, and various colored rectangles suggesting windows or doors. Above the building are two birds in flight, drawn with a sketchy, dynamic style that captures their movement. The birds seem to be eagles or some kind of raptors, and the one on the right is depicted with its wings fully extended. The drawing communicates a sense of freedom and movement through the depiction of the birds, contrasted with the solid, anchored structure of the building below.

Anthropic Claude

Created by claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022 on 2025-01-28

This is an artistic composition that combines several elements in a surreal style. The top portion features a boldly drawn face rendered in simple black lines showing eyes and a nose against a beige background. Around this central face are several gray birds in flight, creating a dreamy, ethereal quality. The bottom half of the image shows an architectural drawing of what appears to be a modernist building or structure with arches, rectangles, and geometric shapes. There are touches of color - blue, yellow, and red rectangles - that add visual interest to the otherwise monochromatic scheme. The style appears to be a combination of ink drawing and watercolor or wash techniques. The composition creates an interesting juxtaposition between the organic, flowing elements of the face and birds above, and the rigid, geometric architecture below.

Created by claude-3-opus-20240229 on 2025-01-28

The image appears to be an abstract drawing or painting featuring multiple overlapping elements in shades of gray, black and rust tones against a pale sepia background. The focal point is a stylized human face made up of loosely sketched lines and shapes, with large almond-shaped eyes that gaze directly at the viewer. Above the face hovers what looks like a bird or angel with outspread wings. In the lower portion, an architectural structure with arched openings and colored rectangular shapes is rendered in a cubist, fragmented style. The overall composition has a surreal, dreamlike quality, blending figurative and geometric motifs in an expressive, gestural manner characteristic of modern art movements like surrealism and abstract expressionism. The artist's signature "Berman" is visible in the bottom right corner.

Created by claude-3-haiku-20240307 on 2025-01-28

The image appears to be an abstract, surreal painting or drawing. It features a prominent face-like figure with exaggerated features, including large eyes and an elongated nose. This central figure is surrounded by various abstract shapes, lines, and symbols, including what seem to be birds or bird-like creatures in flight. The background depicts a stylized architectural or cityscape-like structure, with arches, windows, and other geometric elements. The overall style and composition create a dreamlike, whimsical, and imaginative visual narrative without any clear, literal representation of reality.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-14

The image is a painting by Marc Chagall, titled "Man and Birds." It depicts a man's face in the top left corner, with a bird perched on his nose. The man's face is rendered in shades of gray and black, with a few strokes of color added to give it a sense of depth and texture. Below the man's face, there is a building with arched windows and doors, painted in a more abstract style. The building is depicted in a range of colors, including blue, yellow, orange, and red. In the background, there are several birds flying around the man's head, their wings spread wide as they soar through the air. The birds are also depicted in shades of gray and black, with some subtle hints of color added to give them a sense of life and movement. Overall, the image is a beautiful and imaginative depiction of a man and his surroundings, with a focus on the beauty and wonder of the natural world. The use of abstract shapes and colors adds a sense of depth and complexity to the image, making it a truly unique and captivating work of art.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-03-14

This image is a painting by Pablo Picasso, titled "The Face of Peace," created in 1962. The painting features a large face with a prominent nose and eye, accompanied by a bird in flight. Below the face, there is a building with arched windows and a doorway, as well as another bird perched on the roof. The painting is rendered in a muted color palette, with shades of beige, gray, and black, and features bold brushstrokes and geometric shapes. The overall effect is one of simplicity and elegance, with a focus on the beauty of form and line.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-01-28

The image is a black and white artwork with a beige background. It depicts a human face with a bird perched on its nose and two other birds flying above. The face has two eyes, a nose, and a mouth. The artwork also includes a structure that resembles a building with several windows and doors. The artwork has a signature at the bottom right corner.

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-01-28

The image depicts a stylized illustration that combines abstract and figurative elements. At the top, there is a large, semi-abstract face with exaggerated features. The face has large, almond-shaped eyes, a prominent nose, and a slightly open mouth. The face appears to be composed of flowing, wavy lines that give it a dynamic and somewhat ethereal quality. Surrounding the face are several birds, depicted in a semi-realistic style with detailed feathers. These birds seem to be flying or floating around the face, adding a sense of movement and life to the composition. Below the face and birds, there is a cityscape rendered in a more geometric and stylized manner. The buildings are composed of angular shapes, arches, and windows, with a mix of colors such as blue, yellow, and red. The architecture suggests a modern or futuristic setting, contrasting with the more organic and fluid style of the face and birds. The overall composition is balanced, with the face and birds occupying the upper part of the image and the cityscape taking up the lower part. The image is signed "Bon Shakir" in the bottom right corner, indicating the artist's name. The artwork appears to be a print or a poster, given its clean lines and bold use of color. The combination of abstract and figurative elements, along with the contrast between the organic face and the geometric cityscape, creates a visually engaging and thought-provoking piece.

Text analysis

Amazon

Dias

Google

Bal s
Bal
s