Human Generated Data

Title

Untitled (Division IX, May Day Parade, Communist Party route, Twenty-fifth Street between Fifth and Sixth Avenues, New York City)

Date

May 1, 1935

People

Artist: Ben Shahn, American 1898 - 1969

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Bernarda Bryson Shahn, P1970.4032

Human Generated Data

Title

Untitled (Division IX, May Day Parade, Communist Party route, Twenty-fifth Street between Fifth and Sixth Avenues, New York City)

People

Artist: Ben Shahn, American 1898 - 1969

Date

May 1, 1935

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Gift of Bernarda Bryson Shahn, P1970.4032

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2023-10-06

People 100
Crowd 99
Person 95.8
Adult 95.8
Male 95.8
Man 95.8
Person 95.5
Person 95.1
Person 95
Person 94.7
Person 93
Person 91.3
Face 90.2
Head 90.2
Person 88.6
Person 87.9
Person 85.7
Person 85.3
Person 84.2
Person 82.9
Person 79.5
Audience 79.1
Person 73.5
Person 72.3
Person 68.1
Person 66.5
Person 65.5
Person 62.8
Person 62.7
Person 61.3
Person 61.2
Person 61
Text 56.6
Parade 56.2
Protest 56.2
Person 55.2

Clarifai
created on 2018-05-10

people 99.8
group 98.3
many 97.9
man 97.3
adult 97.2
group together 92.4
crowd 91.4
wear 90.5
woman 89.6
monochrome 88.4
administration 87.5
war 87.3
child 80.6
no person 79.1
military 79.1
art 78.9
vehicle 78.1
street 77.9
veil 75.7
room 72.6

Imagga
created on 2023-10-06

graffito 100
decoration 72.4
freight car 65.6
car 50.8
wheeled vehicle 39.4
vehicle 26.7
grunge 24.7
old 24.4
texture 20.8
vintage 19.8
wall 17.6
city 17.4
pattern 17.1
paper 16.5
retro 16.4
aged 16.3
antique 15.6
art 14.3
landscape 14.1
ancient 13.8
brown 13.2
conveyance 13.1
empty 12.9
paint 12.7
travel 12.7
architecture 12.5
design 12.4
grungy 12.3
building 12.2
scene 12.1
frame 11.6
urban 11.4
artistic 11.3
tourism 10.7
group 10.5
rough 10
material 9.8
business 9.7
surface 9.7
textured 9.6
damaged 9.5
winter 9.4
house 9.2
dirty 9
snow 8.9
text 8.7
worn 8.6
rusty 8.6
blank 8.6
construction 8.6
color 8.3
wood 8.3
outdoors 8.2
water 8
yellow 7.9
forest 7.8
black 7.8
space 7.8
decay 7.7
stain 7.7
industry 7.7
wallpaper 7.7
concrete 7.7
sky 7.6
walking 7.6
park 7.4
grain 7.4
transport 7.3
industrial 7.3
landmark 7.2

Google
created on 2018-05-10

Microsoft
created on 2018-05-10

old 55.3
shop 12.4

Color Analysis

Face analysis

Amazon

AWS Rekognition

Age 16-22
Gender Male, 86.5%
Sad 99.6%
Calm 18.4%
Fear 7.1%
Surprised 6.6%
Disgusted 5.7%
Angry 4.7%
Happy 2.1%
Confused 0.9%

AWS Rekognition

Age 16-22
Gender Male, 99.4%
Happy 54.5%
Calm 24.3%
Fear 8.1%
Surprised 7.9%
Sad 5%
Confused 3%
Disgusted 2.8%
Angry 1.3%

AWS Rekognition

Age 19-27
Gender Male, 99.7%
Calm 84.1%
Surprised 6.6%
Fear 6.5%
Happy 4.7%
Sad 3.9%
Disgusted 2.5%
Angry 1.5%
Confused 0.5%

AWS Rekognition

Age 22-30
Gender Male, 85.3%
Disgusted 37.8%
Sad 37.5%
Calm 15.7%
Fear 8.6%
Surprised 7.7%
Angry 6.5%
Confused 5.6%
Happy 2.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 19-27
Gender Male, 97.3%
Calm 96.5%
Surprised 6.3%
Fear 5.9%
Sad 2.3%
Angry 1.7%
Disgusted 0.5%
Confused 0.5%
Happy 0.3%

AWS Rekognition

Age 23-31
Gender Male, 89.2%
Calm 57.9%
Happy 27.4%
Sad 8.3%
Surprised 6.6%
Fear 6.2%
Disgusted 1.7%
Confused 1.2%
Angry 0.4%

AWS Rekognition

Age 27-37
Gender Male, 99.5%
Calm 94.7%
Surprised 6.3%
Fear 5.9%
Sad 3%
Happy 1.4%
Angry 0.7%
Confused 0.3%
Disgusted 0.2%

AWS Rekognition

Age 25-35
Gender Male, 99.9%
Calm 70.1%
Happy 16.7%
Surprised 6.6%
Fear 6%
Disgusted 5%
Sad 4%
Angry 1.6%
Confused 1.3%

AWS Rekognition

Age 23-31
Gender Female, 96.9%
Calm 89%
Surprised 7.3%
Fear 6%
Happy 3.1%
Sad 2.6%
Confused 1.8%
Angry 1.4%
Disgusted 0.9%

AWS Rekognition

Age 29-39
Gender Male, 74.5%
Happy 45.3%
Calm 41.4%
Surprised 7.2%
Fear 6.2%
Angry 3.4%
Confused 3.4%
Sad 3.1%
Disgusted 1.3%

AWS Rekognition

Age 31-41
Gender Male, 70.9%
Sad 99.9%
Disgusted 9.1%
Calm 6.7%
Surprised 6.6%
Fear 6.1%
Confused 1.5%
Happy 1.2%
Angry 0.6%

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person
Adult
Male
Man
Person 95.8%
Person 95.5%
Person 95.1%
Person 95%
Person 94.7%
Person 93%
Person 91.3%
Person 88.6%
Person 87.9%
Person 85.7%
Person 85.3%
Person 84.2%
Person 82.9%
Person 79.5%
Person 73.5%
Person 72.3%
Person 68.1%
Person 66.5%
Person 65.5%
Person 62.8%
Person 62.7%
Person 61.3%
Person 61.2%
Person 61%
Person 55.2%
Adult 95.8%
Male 95.8%
Man 95.8%

Captions

Clarifai
created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-31

a photograph of a large group of people standing in front of a building -100%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-11-20 on 2025-06-09

This image is a photographic negative, capturing a street scene featuring a large gathering of people. Most attendees appear to be dressed in formal or semi-formal attire, such as suits, hats, and coats, indicative of an early 20th-century setting. Some individuals are holding signs or banners, suggesting a protest, demonstration, or organized event.

The storefronts in the background provide context to the location—it includes businesses such as "Harry Charnas & Co." advertising "Paper, Twine, Notions," and "Slumberland" as well as "Klapper & Brucken Sewing Machines." These names hint at a commercial district. Details are inverted due to the negative format, with light areas appearing dark and vice versa.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-08-06 on 2025-06-09

The image is a photographic negative showing a large group of people gathered in a city street, possibly during a protest or public gathering. The crowd consists of predominantly men, many wearing hats and suits, indicative of early to mid-20th century fashion. Several people are holding signs, though the text is difficult to discern due to the negative format. Surrounding the group are commercial storefronts with visible signage. One sign reads "SLUMBERLAND" and another "HARRY CHARNAS & CO", suggesting the presence of businesses related to bedding and paper goods. The atmosphere appears busy and lively, as one might find in a bustling urban area.

Anthropic Claude

Created by anthropic.claude-3-haiku-20240307-v1:0 on 2025-06-19

The image appears to be a black and white photograph depicting a crowded street scene. There is a large crowd of people visible, many of whom are wearing hats and coats, suggesting this is likely an urban setting from an earlier time period. The buildings and storefronts in the background indicate this is a commercial area, with signs for businesses like "Slumberland" and "Paper Chapins & Co." visible. The overall scene conveys a sense of activity and bustling energy in this crowded public space.

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-opus-20240229-v1:0 on 2025-06-19

The black and white image shows a large crowd of men gathered in front of a building with "SLUMBERLA" written on it. The men are wearing hats and suits typical of the early 20th century time period. Some are holding signs or banners, though the text is not clearly legible in the image. The density of the crowd and the formal attire suggest this was likely an important event or gathering taking place on a city street, with the "SLUMBERLA" building as a backdrop.

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-19

This is a black and white historical photograph showing a large crowd gathered on what appears to be a city street. The image shows storefronts in the background with visible business signs, including one that reads "SLUMBERLA" (partially visible) and "HARRY GRABINAS & CO." The crowd appears to be predominantly composed of people wearing hats and coats, which suggests this was taken in an earlier era, likely early 20th century. The density of the crowd and their formal attire suggests this might be some kind of public gathering, protest, or event. The image has the characteristic look of vintage photography, with some graininess and imperfections typical of photographs from that period. According to the citation at the bottom, this image is from the Harvard University Art Museums collection.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-05-30

The image depicts a black-and-white photograph of a crowd gathered in front of a building, with the word "SLUMBERLA" visible on the top right corner. The crowd is densely packed, with people standing shoulder-to-shoulder, and appears to be engaged in some sort of event or protest. Some individuals are holding signs or banners, although the text is not legible.

In the background, several storefronts are visible, including one with the sign "HARRY CHABINAS & CO PAPER TWINE NOTIONS" and another with the sign "SCHILLER & SON INC." The overall atmosphere of the image suggests a sense of community and activism, with the crowd gathered together to express their views or support a cause.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-05-30

The image is a black-and-white photograph of a crowd of people gathered in front of several storefronts.

The crowd is densely packed and appears to be made up of men, many of whom are wearing hats. Some individuals are holding signs or banners, but the text on these is too small to be legible.

In the background, there are several storefronts with signs that read "SLUMBERLAND," "HARRY CHARNAS & CO. PAPER-TWINE NOTIONS," and "FABER SCHILLER & SON INC." The buildings appear to be made of stone or brick and have ornate details such as carved facades and decorative trim.

The overall atmosphere of the image suggests that it was taken during a public event or protest, possibly in the early 20th century. The presence of signs and banners indicates that the crowd is gathered for a specific purpose, although the exact nature of the event is unclear.

The image provides a glimpse into the past, capturing a moment in time when people came together to express their views or celebrate an occasion. Despite the lack of color, the photograph still conveys a sense of energy and community, inviting the viewer to imagine the scene unfolding before them.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-05-29

This black-and-white photograph shows a crowd of people gathered in front of a building. The building has signs on the front that read "SLUMBERLA" and "HARRY CHARNAS & CO." The people in the crowd are wearing hats and some are holding signs. There is a man standing on a platform in front of the crowd, and there are other people standing on the side of the building. The image has a watermark in the bottom left corner that reads "President and Fellows of Harvard College (Harvard University Art Museums)."

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-05-29

The image is a black-and-white photograph showing a large crowd of people gathered in front of a building. The crowd appears to be engaged in some kind of event or gathering, possibly a rally or protest. The people are dressed in a variety of clothing styles, including suits, dresses, and hats. Some of the individuals are holding signs or banners, suggesting that they are part of a protest or demonstration. The building in the background has a large sign that reads "SLUMBERLA" and "HARRY CHARNAS & CO." It is unclear what kind of event or gathering is taking place, but the large crowd and the presence of signs and banners suggest that it is a significant event.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-05-24

Here's a description of the image:

The image captures a crowded street scene, seemingly a protest or gathering, in a grayscale negative. The crowd is tightly packed, with many individuals wearing hats and suits, indicating a historical period likely prior to the mid-20th century.

Shops and storefronts line the street in the background, with signs and businesses visible, including one for "SLUMBERLA" and "HARRY CHARNAS & CO - PAPER-TWINE NOTIONS." The image appears to be taken from a ground-level perspective, looking up at the crowd and the buildings. Some individuals in the crowd are holding signs, though the specific messages are difficult to discern in the negative format. The image has a historical feel, suggesting a significant event or demonstration from the past.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-05-24

Here is a description of the image:

This appears to be a photographic negative of a historical event, possibly a protest or gathering in a city. The image has a high-contrast, inverted appearance due to being a negative, which can make details hard to discern.

In the background, we see storefronts with signs. Some of the legible signs read "KLAPPER & BRUCKNER SEWING MACHINES", "THUR SCHILLER & SON INC", "SLUMBERLA", and "HARRY CHARNAS & CO PAPER-TWINE-NOTIONS". The storefronts and architectural details suggest the image was taken in an urban setting.

In the foreground, there is a large crowd of people. Many are wearing hats and coats, typical attire for an older era. Their faces are difficult to see clearly due to the negative effect. There's at least one sign being held in the crowd, but the text is hard to read. The overall impression is of a bustling and potentially crowded public space.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-02

The image depicts a large crowd gathered on a city street, likely during the early 20th century. The photograph appears to be taken from an elevated position, providing a bird's-eye view of the scene. The crowd is densely packed, and most people are wearing hats, which was common attire during that period.

In the background, several storefronts are visible. On the left side, there is a sign for "Superior Bruckner Sewing Machines" and "Bruckner Sewing Machines." Another sign reads "Schiller & Son Inc.," indicating a business at 2426. On the right side, there is a sign for "Harry Charnas & Co.," which appears to be a store selling paper and twine. Additionally, there is a sign for "Slumberland" above one of the storefronts.

The crowd seems to be focused on something in the middle of the street, possibly an event or a parade, as many people are looking in the same direction. The overall atmosphere suggests a public gathering or celebration. The architecture and signage hint at an urban setting, possibly in a commercial district.

Text analysis

Amazon

Harvard
College
Art
and
University
SLUMBERLA
President and Fellows of Harvard College (Harvard University Art Museums)
(Harvard
Museums)
of
Fellows
SEWING
MACHINES
HARRY
SCHILLER
28-30
CHARNAS
MOTORS
NOTIONS
CKNER
BRI
PAPER-TWINE- NOTIONS
PAPER-TWINE-
President
24-26
28
P1970.4032.0000
SON
INC
UNIT
CO
&
SET
KLAPPER
El
sewing MOTORS El MACHINES BRI CKNER
MAHLR SCHILLER 24-26 & SON INC
SET UNIT CO
HARRY CHARNAS 28 e CO -
DANCERS
-
e
sewing
F
MAHLR
BBUCKNER

Google

SLUMBERL SEWING 24 26 SCHILLER& President and Fellows of Harvard College (Harvard University Art Museums) P1970.4032.0000
SLUMBERL
SEWING
24
26
SCHILLER&
President
and
Fellows
of
Harvard
College
(
University
Art
Museums
)
P1970.4032.0000