Human Generated Data

Title

Untitled (prisoners on work detail)

Date

c. 1914-1918

People

Artist: Unidentified Artist,

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Gift of Richard E. Bennink, 2.2002.4129

Human Generated Data

Title

Untitled (prisoners on work detail)

People

Artist: Unidentified Artist,

Date

c. 1914-1918

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Gift of Richard E. Bennink, 2.2002.4129

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2022-03-12

Person 95.3
Human 95.3
Person 95.2
Person 93.6
Architecture 90.6
Building 90.6
Person 90
Person 89.9
Person 87.1
Horse 86.8
Animal 86.8
Mammal 86.8
Person 82.1
Person 81.7
Person 80.3
Person 80.2
Person 80.1
Person 77.3
Pillar 76.2
Column 76.2
Horse 75.9
Person 74.3
Text 72.7
Person 69.3
Outdoors 68.9
Housing 65
Person 64.3
Nature 63.4
Tree 63.3
Plant 63.3

Clarifai
created on 2023-10-22

winter 97.5
no person 95.7
temperature 93.5
rain 93.3
people 92.6
old 91.3
art 90
snow 89.4
wood 89.1
cold 87.9
smoke 87.3
fall 86.8
weather 86.8
tree 85.5
sepia 84.8
retro 83.4
war 83.3
thermometer 82.4
dark 82.1
nature 81.3

Imagga
created on 2022-03-12

book jacket 30.1
pole 27
gravestone 23.7
jacket 23.4
structure 22.8
rod 20.4
memorial 19
old 18.8
wrapping 18.7
grunge 17
frame 16.6
toiletry 16.3
stone 14.6
covering 13.9
black 13.8
design 13.5
vintage 13.2
art 13.1
perfume 13
film 12.6
pattern 12.3
retro 12.3
antique 12.2
digital 12.1
border 11.8
dirty 11.7
ancient 11.2
rough 10.9
text 10.5
negative 10.5
texture 10.4
architecture 10.4
sky 10.2
paper 10.2
light 10.2
material 9.8
computer 9.6
damaged 9.5
decoration 9.5
grungy 9.5
graphic 9.5
column 9.4
strip 8.7
movie 8.7
messy 8.7
city 8.3
symbol 8.1
tower 8
metal 8
mess 7.8
photographic 7.8
forest 7.8
frames 7.8
ornament 7.8
layer 7.7
mask 7.7
support 7.7
decorative 7.5
wood 7.5
screen 7.5
book 7.4
element 7.4
landscape 7.4
environment 7.4
entertainment 7.4
historic 7.3
new 7.3
color 7.2
building 7.2
history 7.1

Google
created on 2022-03-12

Microsoft
created on 2022-03-12

tree 99.9
outdoor 98.9
text 98.6

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person
Horse
Person 95.3%
Person 95.2%
Person 93.6%
Person 90%
Person 89.9%
Person 87.1%
Person 82.1%
Person 81.7%
Person 80.3%
Person 80.2%
Person 80.1%
Person 77.3%
Person 74.3%
Person 69.3%
Person 64.3%
Horse 86.8%
Horse 75.9%

Categories

Captions

Clarifai
created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-05

a photograph of a group of people standing around a pile of logs -100%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-11-20 on 2025-06-11

This historical image appears to depict a group of individuals, labeled as "Prisonniers au Travail" ("Prisoners at Work"), engaged in work outdoors. It is a stereoscopic photograph, with identical left and right images intended for 3D viewing. The scene is set in a wooded area, where several people are clustered together, possibly performing labor tasks, surrounded by logs and tree branches. In the background, there are two trucks parked on a dirt path, along with additional individuals standing. The photograph's muted tones and visual content suggest it dates from a wartime or labor camp setting.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-08-06 on 2025-06-11

The image is a stereoscopic photograph from a two-dimensional image divided into two parts to create the illusion of depth. It depicts a scene of prisoners at work in a forested area. Visible are a group of individuals gathered near several trucks, likely engaged in labor tasks. Fallen branches and logs are scattered on the ground, with two prominent bare trees in the foreground. The people in the photograph appear to be closely grouped, possibly taking a break or awaiting instructions. The environment is wooded, with trees devoid of leaves, indicating a time of year like late fall or winter. The photograph is monochrome, and text is printed on the strip between the two sides of the stereo image, reading "79. PRISONNIERS AU TRAVAIL. S T L." indicating the image's title or description, "Prisoners at Work."

Anthropic Claude

Created by anthropic.claude-3-haiku-20240307-v1:0 on 2025-06-15

The image appears to be a historical black and white photograph depicting a scene from what seems to be a military or wartime context. The photograph shows a group of people, likely soldiers or military personnel, standing or walking amidst a landscape of fallen trees and debris. The image has a somber and grim atmosphere, suggesting a scene of destruction or aftermath of some conflict. The text "1919 PARIS PEACE TRAVAIL S.T.L." is visible in the center of the image, providing some contextual information about the time period and location.

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-opus-20240229-v1:0 on 2025-06-15

The image is a stereoscopic photograph showing a group of people, likely prisoners or workers, standing in a wooded area with cut logs and tree stumps around them. The men are wearing similar dark colored clothing and hats. There are two identical side-by-side photographs, as was common in early stereoscopic photography to create a 3D effect when viewed through a special device. The text "379. PRISONNIERS AU TRAVAIL" is printed vertically between the two photographs, which translates from French to "Prisoners at work".

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-15

This appears to be a stereoscopic photograph (two side-by-side images meant to be viewed in 3D) from what looks like the early 20th century. The scene shows several people and some vehicles in a wooded or forested area with fallen logs on the ground. There are bare trees in the background, suggesting it was taken during winter or late fall. Some vintage automobiles can be seen parked in the background. The image has a sepia or brownish tone typical of photographs from that era. There appears to be text or labeling in the center strip between the two images, which was common for stereoscopic photographs of that time period.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-02

The image is a sepia-toned photograph, likely from the early 20th century, depicting a scene of prisoners working in a wooded area. The photograph is divided into two halves by a vertical line, with the left half showing a group of prisoners gathered around a pile of logs and trees, while the right half appears to be a continuation of the scene.

In the foreground, several prisoners are visible, some of whom are wearing uniforms or clothing that suggests they may be prisoners of war or political prisoners. They are engaged in various activities, such as cutting down trees or hauling logs, and appear to be working under the supervision of guards or overseers.

In the background, there are several trees and a few buildings or structures that are not clearly visible due to the sepia tone and the distance from the camera. The overall atmosphere of the photograph suggests a sense of hardship and labor, with the prisoners working in a rugged and unforgiving environment.

The image also includes a vertical strip of text that runs down the center of the photograph, which appears to be a caption or label that provides additional information about the image. The text is written in French and reads "179. PRISONNIERS AU S.T.L. TRAVAIL," which translates to "179. Prisoners at S.T.L. Work." This suggests that the photograph was taken at a specific location, possibly a prison or labor camp, and that it was intended to document the working conditions of the prisoners.

Overall, the image provides a poignant glimpse into the lives of prisoners during a time of conflict or political upheaval, and serves as a powerful reminder of the human cost of war and oppression.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-02

This image is a black-and-white photograph of a group of people in a wooded area, with a caption in French that reads "179. PRISONNIERS AU S.T.L. TRAVAIL." The image appears to be a stereograph, with two identical views side by side.

In the foreground, there are several logs and branches scattered on the ground. In the background, there are trees and what appears to be a vehicle or truck. A group of people, possibly prisoners, are standing around the vehicle, some of whom are wearing uniforms or hats. The overall atmosphere of the image suggests a sense of work or labor, possibly in a prison camp or other institutional setting.

The caption suggests that the image is part of a larger collection or series, and the number "179" may indicate the image's place within that series. The use of French language and the reference to "S.T.L." (which could stand for "Service du Travail Libéré" or "Service du Travail Libre") suggest that the image may be related to a specific historical context or event, such as World War I or II.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-06-04

The image appears to be a sepia-toned photograph taken in a forest setting. It features two distinct scenes, separated by a black vertical line in the center. On the left side, there are several people gathered around a tree, and some of them are wearing hats. The scene on the right side is similar, with people gathered around another tree, and some of them are wearing hats as well. The image has a vintage and nostalgic feel, possibly depicting a historical event or a moment in the past.

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-06-04

The image is a black-and-white photograph of a scene from a forest. The image is divided into two halves by a vertical line. On either side of the line, the same scene is depicted. On the left side, there are two trucks parked on a dirt road, with people standing near them. Some people are walking on the road, and some are standing near the trees. The ground is covered with dried leaves and branches.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-05-06

The image is a stereograph depicting prisoners at work, labeled "Prisonniers au Travail. S.T.L." (Prisoners at Work, S.T.L.). The scene appears to be set in a wooded area with a dirt path running through it.

In the foreground, there are piles of logs and branches scattered on the ground. A figure lies on the logs, possibly resting or exhausted.

In the middle ground, a group of individuals is gathered. Some appear to be sitting, while others are standing near a pair of vans. The people standing appear to be guards or supervisors, while those sitting may be the prisoners at work.

The background consists of a dense forest with bare trees, suggesting it might be autumn or winter. The sky is overcast, creating a somber atmosphere.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-05-06

Here's a description of the image:

Overall Impression:
The image is a stereoscopic photograph, a type of photo intended to create a 3D effect when viewed through a special viewer. The scene appears to be a wartime setting, possibly related to prisoner of war labor. The quality of the photograph suggests it's likely from the early 20th century.

Scene Details:

  • Location: The setting is a wooded area or forest. Bare trees indicate it might be autumn or early spring.
  • Subject: A group of people, likely prisoners of war, are gathered in the foreground. Some appear to be resting or waiting. There are fallen tree trunks, some with what appear to be clothing draped over them in the foreground, and a group of men near a road.
  • Vehicles: Two vans, possibly military vehicles, are parked further back in the scene.
  • People: Several figures are visible, in various clothing. Some appear to be soldiers or guards, others likely prisoners.
  • Text: The middle of the image bears a text saying "179. PRISONNIERS AU TRAVAIL. S.T.L." likely indicating the subject of the photograph (prisoners at work) and possibly a location or organization.

Composition:

The photograph is composed with the subjects in a way that highlights their presence and their activities. The stereoscopic format, intended for 3D viewing, adds depth to the scene.

Overall Atmosphere:

The image has a somber and documentary feel. The context of the scene suggests a wartime situation where prisoners are engaged in forced labor.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-07

The image is a historical black-and-white photograph that appears to be a stereograph, which is a type of photograph designed to be viewed with a stereoscope to create a 3D effect. The scene depicts a group of people, identified as prisoners, engaged in labor. The text on the central vertical strip reads "179. PRISONNIERS AU S.T.L. TRAVAIL," which translates from French to "179. PRISONERS AT S.T.L. WORK."

In the image, several prisoners are seen working outdoors, likely in a forested area, as there are numerous trees in the background. The prisoners are engaged in what appears to be logging activities, as there are large logs on the ground. Some prisoners are handling the logs, while others are standing or moving around. A few vehicles, possibly trucks, are visible in the background, suggesting that they might be used for transporting the logs.

The overall atmosphere of the image conveys hard labor and the conditions under which the prisoners are working. The scene is set in a natural environment, with the presence of trees and open space. The photograph captures a moment in time, providing a glimpse into the labor practices involving prisoners during that period.

Text analysis

Amazon

AU
S.T.L.
TRAVAIL.
179. PRiSONNiERS AU
PRiSONNiERS
179.

Google

TRAVAIL. S.T.L.
TRAVAIL.
S.T.L.