Human Generated Data

Title

Industrial Problems, Coöperation: Italy. Turin. Alleanza Cooperativa: Coöperative Societies, Italy

Date

c. 1903

People

Artist: Unidentified Artist,

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Social Museum Collection, 3.2002.2121

Human Generated Data

Title

Industrial Problems, Coöperation: Italy. Turin. Alleanza Cooperativa: Coöperative Societies, Italy

People

Artist: Unidentified Artist,

Date

c. 1903

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Social Museum Collection, 3.2002.2121

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2019-06-06

Advertisement 97.9
Poster 97.9
Flyer 93.5
Paper 93.5
Brochure 93.5
Text 84.5
Outdoors 71.6
Building 71.1
Architecture 71.1
Nature 69.6
Tower 58.8

Clarifai
created on 2019-06-06

no person 97.3
collection 92.8
set 92.8
picture frame 92.1
retro 91.6
paper 91
layout 90
vintage 89
people 88.6
old 88
art 86.6
print 85.5
template 83.7
museum 83.6
illustration 83.5
card 82.4
antique 81.4
page 80.4
ancient 79.8
design 78.2

Imagga
created on 2019-06-06

money 46.8
daily 45.5
currency 43.1
blackboard 37.6
cash 37.5
dollar 35.3
paper 34.5
business 32.8
finance 31.3
bill 30.4
bank 29.6
web site 28.9
newspaper 28.5
banking 26.7
hundred 25.2
dollars 25.1
wealth 24.2
financial 24.1
savings 23.3
product 22.8
exchange 21
brass 19.9
us 19.3
note 18.4
creation 17.9
memorial 17.8
structure 17
investment 16.5
old 16
one 15.7
banknotes 15.7
notes 15.3
rich 14.9
close 14.8
bills 14.6
banknote 14.6
finances 14.4
pay 14.4
sign 14.3
loan 13.4
retro 12.3
symbol 12.1
states 11.6
vintage 11.6
payment 11.5
global 10.9
funds 10.8
history 10.7
market 10.7
debt 10.6
profit 10.5
economy 10.2
franklin 9.8
concepts 9.8
stamp 9.7
closeup 9.4
stock 9.4
commerce 9.3
billboard 9.2
hand 9.1
wages 8.8
economic 8.7
ancient 8.6
mail 8.6
post 8.6
grunge 8.5
signboard 8.5
design 8.4
number 8.4
letter 8.2
envelope 8.1
object 8.1
man 8.1
success 8
currencies 7.9
postmark 7.9
postage 7.9
antique 7.8
rate 7.8
collage 7.7
united 7.6
map 7.6
board 7.2
collection 7.2
black 7.2

Google
created on 2019-06-06

Text 90.8
Photographic paper 79.5
Architecture 72.6
History 72.6
Room 65.7
Collection 63.8
Photography 62.4
Paper 59.2
Art 58.1

Microsoft
created on 2019-06-06

scene 82.9
screenshot 75.2
room 57.5
building 55.2
different 41.7
several 11.6

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

No features identified

Clarifai

Poster
Tree
Building
Window
Furniture

Clarifai

Poster 72.2%

Categories

Imagga
created on 2019-06-06

text visuals 52.4%
paintings art 19.4%
interior objects 18%
streetview architecture 9%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2019-06-06

a display in a room 64.3%
a display case in a room 48.4%

Clarifai

No captions written

Salesforce

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-18

a photograph of a collection of photographs of old photographs of buildings

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip-2 on 2025-07-06

a large black and white photograph of a building with several pictures of it

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-11-20 on 2025-06-13

This image is a collage of six labeled photographs showcasing aspects of cooperative societies in Italy. The images are arranged on a gray background with descriptive labels below them.

From left to right, top to bottom, the photographs depict the following:

  1. Restaurant: A dining area with rows of tables and chairs, showcasing a cafeteria-style setup in a cooperative facility.
  2. Central premises: A large building, likely the headquarters or principal building of the cooperative society, emphasizing its architectural prominence.
  3. Milk for babies dispensary: A room containing rows of bottles on tables, likely used for distributing milk to infants as part of the cooperative's services.
  4. Exterior of the cooperative: The facade of a building marked "Alleanza Cooperativa Torinese," indicating the name and function of the cooperative society in Turin.
  5. Grocery department: The interior of a stocked grocery store, showing counters and shelves laden with goods, organized for customer access.
  6. Theatre: A room with numerous chairs neatly arranged, suggesting an auditorium or theater for cooperative members.

Additionally, there is a block of text below the photographs describing the Alleanza Cooperativa Torinese in Turin. It elaborates on its establishment in 1899, its offerings to cooperative members (e.g., grocery, bakery, clothing, medical care with a staff of doctors), and its membership growth over time. The collage conveys the diverse and community-oriented services provided by the cooperative society.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-08-06 on 2025-06-13

The image is a collage of six sepia-toned photographs depicting various aspects of cooperative societies in Italy, specifically associated with the "Alleanza Cooperativa, Torino". The photographs are arranged on a gray background with labels under each of them.

From left to right and top to bottom, the photographs are labeled as follows:

  1. Restaurant: This shows a long dining area with rows of tables and chairs arranged in a narrow, elegant room.
  2. Central premises: This image features the exterior of a large, imposing building with classical architectural details, likely the primary location of the cooperative society.
  3. Milk for babies (Dispensary): A room filled with tables on which there are numerous bottles, possibly milk bottles, likely representing a milk distribution or caregiving service.
  4. Alleanza Cooperativa Torino (Front Facade): This shows the front of the cooperative's building, with signage and display windows.
  5. Grocery Department: An interior view of a bustling grocery section filled with shelves stocked with a variety of goods.
  6. Theatre: This image captures the interior of a theater, with rows of chairs and decorative elements visible, suggesting cultural or social events are held here.

In the bottom left corner, there is a block of text explaining the historical context of the "Alleanza Cooperativa, Torino", noting its foundation in 1886 as a manufacturing society and later transformation in 1899 into a cooperative society aimed at providing affordable services like food, milk, and medical care for its members.

Anthropic Claude

Created by anthropic.claude-3-haiku-20240307-v1:0 on 2025-06-19

This image appears to be a collage of photographs depicting various cooperative societies in Italy. The collage includes images of a restaurant, a central premises, a hall for public meetings, a cooperative forum, a grocery department, and a theater. The images provide a visual representation of the different facilities and activities associated with these cooperative societies in Italy.

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-19

This image appears to be a collection of historical photographs showing various aspects of cooperative societies in Italy. The page contains 6 black and white photographs arranged in two rows, with captions beneath them.

The top row shows:

  1. What appears to be a restaurant or dining hall with tables and chairs
  2. An exterior view of a building
  3. What looks like a storage or dispensary area with bottles or containers

The bottom row shows:

  1. A storefront with "ALLEANZA COOPERATIVA" signage
  2. What appears to be a grocery department with a curved counter display
  3. What looks like a theater or meeting hall with rows of seats

There is also some text at the bottom of the page providing historical context about an Italian cooperative alliance, though the text is not entirely legible in this image.

The photos appear to be from the early 20th century and document various facilities and operations of Italian cooperative societies, which were important social and economic institutions in Italy during that period.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-11

The image is a page from an old scrapbook or photo album, featuring six sepia-toned photographs of various rooms and spaces within a cooperative society in Italy. The photographs are arranged in two rows of three, with each photo accompanied by a caption in small white text.

  • The top row shows:
    • A restaurant with tables and chairs.
    • A central promenade with a large building in the background.
    • A milk room for dairy dispensary.
  • The bottom row shows:
    • A grocery department with shelves and counters.
    • A theatre with a stage and audience seating.
    • A description of the cooperative society, including its history and purpose.
  • The background of the page is a light gray color, with a darker gray border around the edges.
  • The overall atmosphere of the image suggests a sense of community and cooperation, highlighting the various amenities and services provided by the cooperative society to its members.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-11

The image presents a collection of six sepia-toned photographs, each depicting a different aspect of cooperative societies in Italy. The photographs are arranged in two rows of three, with the top row featuring images of a restaurant, central premises, and milk for babies dispensary. The bottom row showcases a grocery department, a theatre, and an exterior view of a cooperative store.

Each photograph is accompanied by a caption that provides context and information about the scene depicted. The captions are written in black text on a white background, making them easy to read against the sepia-toned images.

The overall atmosphere of the image suggests a sense of community and cooperation, highlighting the importance of these organizations in providing essential services and amenities to their members. The use of sepia tones gives the image a nostalgic feel, evoking a sense of history and tradition.

In summary, the image is a visual representation of the cooperative societies in Italy, showcasing their various activities and services through a series of photographs and captions. It provides a glimpse into the lives of the people involved in these organizations and highlights the significance of cooperation and community in achieving common goals.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-06-05

The image is a collage of several black-and-white photographs, each depicting different aspects of the Cooperative Societies in Italy. The photographs are arranged in a grid format, with a title at the top reading "Cooperative Societies, Italy." The images include a restaurant, a central premise, a milk dispensary for babies, a grocery department, and a theater. The collage also includes a caption that provides information about the cooperative societies, including their origins in 1899 and their various branches and services. The caption also mentions the impact of the cooperative societies on the community, such as reducing the death rate of children and providing medical care to members.

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-06-05

The image is a collection of photographs of different buildings, which are labeled with their names. The photographs are old, and they have a black-and-white filter. The buildings are in Italy, and the text "Cooperative Societies, Italy" is written at the top of the image. The buildings are of different sizes and styles, and some of them have signs on them. The buildings are surrounded by other buildings and trees.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-06-01

Here is a description of the image:

The image is a composite of several black-and-white photographs, organized within a gray border. The title at the top reads "Cooperative Societies, Italy".

The individual photos depict:

  1. Restaurant: A long, narrow space filled with tables and chairs, suggesting a dining establishment.
  2. Central Premises: An exterior shot of a large, stone building that appears to be the central location of the cooperative society.
  3. Milk for Babies Dispensary: An interior scene featuring rows of baby bottles, indicating a place where milk is dispensed to infants.
  4. Alleanza Co-Operativa, Torino: The exterior of a building named "Alleanza Co-Operativa Torino", suggesting it is a branch of the cooperative society in Turin. Below this image is a paragraph detailing the society's activities and impact, including owning various establishments, providing sterilized milk, and lowering infant mortality rates.
  5. Grocery Department: A wide, panoramic view of a grocery store interior, showcasing shelves stocked with products.
  6. Theatre: A scene of a stage and rows of chairs, signifying a theatre or performance space.

The arrangement and content of the images suggest a presentation or report on the various aspects and services provided by cooperative societies in Italy, specifically highlighting their reach and impact on the community.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-06-01

Here's a description of the image:

Overall Impression:

The image is a mounted collection of black and white photographs. The theme is "Cooperative Societies, Italy," and it seems to be a historical document or album page.

Individual Photographs and Locations:

  • Top Row:

    • Restaurant: A long dining room, with tables and chairs lining both sides of a central aisle.
    • Central Premises: A large, formal building with multiple floors, a facade with many windows.
    • Milk for Babies Dispensary: A room with rows of bottles or containers, likely where milk was dispensed.
  • Bottom Row:

    • Alleanza Co-Operativa, Torino: This features the building frontage, the name prominently displayed.
    • Grocery Department: A detailed view of a well-stocked grocery store. There is a central counter or display.
    • Theatre: Shows a theatre space with rows of chairs.

Additional Details:

  • Text: Below the photographs, there is a description about "Alleanza Co-Operativa, Torino,". It is in several paragraphs providing context about the societies.
  • Age: The style of photography and the subjects (e.g., "Milk for Babies Dispensary") suggest this is a historical image, possibly from the late 19th or early 20th century.
  • Purpose: Likely the image was created to document the activities and facilities of cooperative societies in Italy.

If you would like to focus on a certain area, let me know!

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-05

The image is a collage of six photographs showcasing different aspects of cooperative societies in Italy, specifically the Alleanza Cooperativa in Turin. Each photograph is labeled to describe the scene depicted. Here is a detailed summary of each part:

  1. Restaurant: This image shows the interior of a restaurant. The dining area features tables and chairs arranged neatly, with a well-lit and inviting atmosphere.

  2. Central Premises: This photograph depicts the exterior of a large building, which serves as the central premises of the cooperative society. The architecture is grand, with multiple stories and a classic design.

  3. Milk or Babies Department: This image shows a spacious room filled with cribs or small beds, likely used for infants or young children. The room appears to be well-organized and clean.

  4. Grocery Department: This photograph captures the interior of a grocery department. The shelves are stocked with various goods, and the layout suggests a well-organized retail space.

  5. Barber: This image shows the interior of a barber shop. The space is equipped with barber chairs and other necessary tools, indicating a place for haircuts and grooming services.

Additionally, there is a text box at the bottom left of the image providing context about the Alleanza Cooperativa in Turin. It mentions that the cooperative society has around 10,000 members and offers various services, including a restaurant, grocery department, and other amenities. The text also highlights the cooperative's financial stability and the benefits it provides to its members, such as regular medical attention and access to a library.

Overall, the image provides a comprehensive view of the facilities and services offered by the Alleanza Cooperativa in Turin, illustrating its role in the community.

Qwen

No captions written

Text analysis

Amazon

Italy
Couperative
Couperative Societies, Italy
Societies,
heusre.
Centrl
Restaurant. Centrl LIK DAepensarmy.
Restaurant.
DAepensarmy.
LIK
Oroeerz

Google

Coöperative Societies, Italy Restauant. Central preison. K or abies Diepersery ALLEANZAC ALLEANIA CO-0PATTVA, 2ORINO, en of e inn eher or metbern cr othertne. Thentre Orocery Depar tsens. Cante, Thtn bestle wd th infant nortality ie etated to heve brouht ts ispensnry an sgainst 180 per 10o0 in the ton generally. 2h ponbers fron r eost.
Coöperative
Societies,
Italy
Restauant.
Central
preison.
K
or
abies
Diepersery
ALLEANZAC
ALLEANIA
CO-0PATTVA,
2ORINO,
en
of
e
inn
eher
metbern
cr
othertne.
Thentre
Orocery
Depar
tsens.
Cante,
Thtn
bestle
wd
th
infant
nortality
ie
etated
to
heve
brouht
ts
ispensnry
an
sgainst
180
per
10o0
in
the
ton
generally.
2h
ponbers
fron
r
eost.