Human Generated Data

Title

Industrial Problems, Coöperation: France. Paris. "La Bellevilloise": Coöperative Societies, France: "La Bellevilloise" Socialist Coöperative Society in Paris 1907.

Date

1907

People

Artist: Unidentified Artist,

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Social Museum Collection, 3.2002.2094

Human Generated Data

Title

Industrial Problems, Coöperation: France. Paris. "La Bellevilloise": Coöperative Societies, France: "La Bellevilloise" Socialist Coöperative Society in Paris 1907.

People

Artist: Unidentified Artist,

Date

1907

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Social Museum Collection, 3.2002.2094

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2019-06-06

Advertisement 95.3
Human 91.2
Person 91.2
Brochure 85.4
Flyer 85.4
Paper 85.4
Collage 74.4
Transportation 71.6
Vehicle 71.6
Train 71.6
Text 60
Poster 59.9
Page 59.2
Building 58.5
Diagram 56.3
Plot 56.3
Plan 56.3

Clarifai
created on 2019-06-06

street 96.4
people 96.2
city 95.3
art 93
architecture 91.8
no person 90.6
building 89.6
water 88.9
print 88.7
landscape 88.6
house 88
illustration 87.5
travel 86.9
town 85.8
urban 85.7
painting 85.3
museum 85.3
vintage 84.2
exhibition 83.9
sea 83.6

Imagga
created on 2019-06-06

billboard 100
signboard 100
structure 81.5
web site 28.1
sky 24.9
architecture 21.9
city 21.6
building 20.7
landscape 18.6
silhouette 14.9
old 14.6
business 14
construction 13.7
travel 13.4
urban 13.1
sunset 12.6
water 12
winter 11.9
sea 11.7
house 11.7
transportation 11.7
snow 11.6
modern 11.2
tower 10.7
tourism 10.7
design 10.7
skyline 10.4
cold 10.3
summer 10.3
street 10.1
light 10
frame 10
office 10
reflection 9.8
vacation 9.8
river 9.8
trees 9.8
night 9.8
grunge 9.4
clouds 9.3
transport 9.1
landmark 9
new 8.9
sun 8.9
scene 8.7
cloud 8.6
holiday 8.6
engineering 8.6
space 8.5
cityscape 8.5
black 8.4
evening 8.4
ocean 8.3
vintage 8.3
outdoors 8.2
technology 8.2
scenery 8.1
home 8
male 7.8
season 7.8
antique 7.8
color 7.8
beach 7.6
bridge 7.6
drawing 7.5
retro 7.4
rough 7.3
tourist 7.3
road 7.2
art 7.2
history 7.2
glass 7

Google
created on 2019-06-06

Text 86.9
Photographic paper 83.4
Snapshot 82
Room 74.4
Architecture 72.6
Photography 62.4
Building 55.4
House 53.7
Illustration 50.4
Art 50.2

Microsoft
created on 2019-06-06

building 62.9
screenshot 22.6

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person
Train
Poster
Person 91.2%
Train 71.6%
Poster 59.9%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2019-06-06

a close up of a sign 70.4%
a close up of a box 45.9%

Clarifai
created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-17

a photograph of a black and white photo of a train on the tracks -100%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-11-20 on 2025-06-12

This image is a historical photograph showing two different perspectives of a cooperative society in France, specifically "La Bellevilloise" Socialist Cooperative Society in Paris, 1901. The photo is divided into two sections:

  1. Left image: This shows the exterior of the cooperative's premises. The street is cobblestone, and the entrance to the offices, bakery, and classroom is visible, surrounded by a fence and gate. There is a chimney or smokestack rising from a building in the background, suggesting the presence of industrial activity. A person is standing outside by the gate, adding to the lived atmosphere of the scene.

  2. Right image: This depicts the interior of a room identified as the "Director's Room." The room contains a large wooden table surrounded by chairs, indicating a meeting area. The walls are decorated with framed documents, artwork, and charts, giving evidence of administrative activities. There's a counter and wooden paneling that makes the room feel official and functional.

The overall presentation highlights the cooperative's physical and organizational structure in 1901, reflecting its community-oriented and socialist ethos.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-08-06 on 2025-06-12

The image is a historical photograph from a collection titled "Cooperative Societies, France." It consists of two photographs side by side mounted on a page.

The left photograph shows the exterior entrance to the offices, bakery, and classroom of a cooperative society. It features a street scene with cobblestone pavement and several buildings in the background, one of which has a tall chimney. A section of the street is bordered by a brick wall and a metal gate, and there is a person standing near the gate.

The right photograph depicts the interior of a Director's Room. The room is furnished with a long wooden table surrounded by chairs, and the walls are decorated with patterned wallpaper and several framed pictures or documents. Above the table, there are light fixtures hanging from the ceiling.

Below the photographs are labels describing each image. The left one is labeled "Entrance to the Offices, Bakery, and Classroom," and the right one is labeled "Director's Room." At the bottom, there is a note saying "'La Bellevilloise' Socialist Cooperative Society in Paris 1901."

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-03

The image is a sepia-toned photograph of two black-and-white images, showcasing the entrance to the offices, bakery, and classroom of the Société Coopérative in Paris, France.

Image 1: Entrance to the Offices, Bakery, and Classroom

  • The image on the left features a cobblestone street with a tall, narrow building in the background.
  • A group of people are standing outside the building, while a person is walking down the street.
  • The building has a large door and a smaller door to the right, with a staircase leading up to the second floor.
  • The sky above is overcast.

Image 2: Director's Room

  • The image on the right shows a room with a long table and chairs, a fireplace, and a wall adorned with framed pictures.
  • The room has a high ceiling and a large window on the back wall.
  • The walls are decorated with various items, including a clock, a vase, and a few pieces of artwork.
  • The overall atmosphere of the room appears to be formal and professional.

Additional Text

  • At the top of the image, a small text reads "Cooperative Societies, France."
  • Below the images, a caption states "La Belleville 'Société Coopérative Society in Paris 1907."
  • The background of the image is a light gray color, with a darker gray border around the edges.

Overall, the image provides a glimpse into the daily life and activities of the Société Coopérative in Paris, France, during the early 20th century.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-03

The image presents a vintage-style poster or page from an old book, featuring two black-and-white photographs of a cooperative society in France. The title "Cooperative Societies, France" is displayed at the top, with the photographs arranged side by side below.

Photograph 1: Entrance to the Offices, Bakery, and Classroom

  • A man stands in front of a building with a flagpole.
  • The building appears to be a mix of residential and commercial spaces.
  • The surrounding area features a cobblestone street and trees in the background.

Photograph 2: Director's Room

  • A long table with chairs is positioned in the center of the room.
  • The walls are adorned with framed pictures and other decorations.
  • The room has a formal atmosphere, suggesting it may be used for meetings or gatherings.

Additional Text

  • Below the photographs, a caption reads "La Bellevilloise Socialist Cooperative Society in Paris 1907."
  • This text provides context for the images, indicating that they depict a specific cooperative society in Paris during the early 20th century.

Overall, the image offers a glimpse into the daily life and operations of a cooperative society in France during the early 20th century.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-06-02

The image consists of two photographs of a cooperative society in France. The first photo shows the entrance to the offices, bakery, and classroom. The second photo shows the director's room, which has a long table and chairs, a cabinet, and a chandelier. The image has a vintage filter and has a watermark in the bottom right corner.

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-06-02

The image is a black-and-white photograph with two distinct sections. The left section shows a street view with cobblestone pavement, a flagpole, and a building with a sign that reads "La Bellevilleoise Socialist Cooperative Society in Paris 1907." The right section depicts an interior of a room, likely a director's room, with a long wooden table, chairs, and various decorative elements on the walls, including picture frames and a chandelier. The photograph is framed with a white border and has a caption at the bottom that reads "Cooperative Societies, France."

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-05-30

Here is a description of the image you sent:

This is a composite image, or photographic page, with two black and white photographs mounted on a light gray background. The page is labeled "Cooperative Societies, France" at the top. Beneath the photographs, centered, is the text "La Bellevilloise Socialist Cooperative Society in Paris 1907."

The photograph on the left is labeled "Entrance to the Offices, Bakery, and Classroom." It depicts a street scene with a cobblestone street and buildings visible behind a wrought iron fence. A tall chimney is visible in the background, and a woman in period clothing stands near the fence.

The photograph on the right is labeled "Director's Room." It depicts the interior of a room with a long wooden table and chairs. The walls are paneled with wood up to a certain height, and above that, the walls are wallpapered. There are framed pictures and documents on the wall. A chandelier hangs from the ceiling. The room appears to be furnished for meetings or discussions.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-05-30

Here's a description of the image:

This is a vintage black and white photograph, likely from the early 20th century, showcasing a co-operative society in Paris, France, specifically "La Bellevillaise Socialist Cooperative Society" in 1907. The image is divided into two distinct sections:

Left: Shows the "Entrance to the Offices, Bakery, and Classroom." It depicts a street scene with cobblestones. There are buildings with a wall and gate, a person standing by the gate, and a tall industrial structure, possibly a smokestack, is visible.

Right: Shows the "Director's Room." The room has long tables and chairs, suggesting a meeting space. The walls are decorated with a combination of wood paneling, wallpaper, and framed pictures. There's a chandelier hanging from the ceiling.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-04

The image depicts two scenes from the "La Bellevilloise" Socialist Cooperative Society in Paris, 1907. The title at the top of the image indicates it is related to cooperative societies in France.

  1. Left Image: Entrance to the Offices, Bakery, and Classroom

    • The left side of the image shows the exterior of a building, which is identified as the entrance to the offices, bakery, and classroom of the cooperative society. The building appears to be modest, with a cobblestone street in front. There are several people visible, including a man standing near the entrance and a few others walking or standing nearby. The building has a simple, utilitarian design, with multiple windows and a gate.
  2. Right Image: Director's Room

    • The right side of the image shows the interior of the Director's Room. The room is well-furnished with wooden furniture, including a large desk with a chair behind it and several chairs arranged in front of the desk. The walls are decorated with framed pictures and the room has a patterned wallpaper. There is a hanging light fixture in the center of the room, and the overall atmosphere suggests a formal, professional setting.

The image provides a glimpse into the operational and administrative spaces of a cooperative society in early 20th-century Paris.

Text analysis

Amazon

Cooperative
France
Cooperative Societies, France
ociety
Societies,
Coaperatove
the
Offices,
Bellevilloisc:
Direretori
Ertranee
Direretori Rloomm.
JJocialiist
"Lg Bellevilloisc: JJocialiist
Coaperatove ociety wy rris ngoz:
Ertranee ho the Offices, Botecy.ond Cosroorm
Rloomm.
rris
"Lg
ho
ngoz:
Cosroorm
Botecy.ond
wy

Google

Cooperative Societies, France Entrance the Offices, Batery.and Classroom Directors Room. "La Bellevillaise Jocialist Coiperatve Society in Raris 19o7
Cooperative
Societies,
France
Entrance
the
Offices,
Batery.and
Classroom
Directors
Room.
"La
Bellevillaise
Jocialist
Coiperatve
Society
in
Raris
19o7