Human Generated Data

Title

Industrial Problems, Coöperation: Switzerland: Coöperative Societies, Switzerland

Date

c. 1903

People

Artist: Unidentified Artist,

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Social Museum Collection, 3.2002.2124

Human Generated Data

Title

Industrial Problems, Coöperation: Switzerland: Coöperative Societies, Switzerland

People

Artist: Unidentified Artist,

Date

c. 1903

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Social Museum Collection, 3.2002.2124

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2019-06-06

Poster 99.6
Advertisement 99.6
Brochure 99.4
Paper 99.4
Flyer 99.4
Human 94
Text 90.5
Page 59.8

Clarifai
created on 2019-06-06

retro 96.5
collection 96.2
vintage 95.8
set 94.8
illustration 94.7
paper 93.9
vector 93.4
art 93.4
old 93.1
collage 93.1
picture frame 91.8
no person 91.3
template 90.7
layout 90.4
museum 87.1
page 86.8
architecture 86.8
antique 86
design 85.8
ancient 85.6

Imagga
created on 2019-06-06

newspaper 100
product 87.2
creation 68.7
money 53.7
currency 52.1
cash 46.7
dollar 44.6
paper 40.8
daily 38.9
finance 38.1
bank 37.7
bill 37.1
wealth 36.9
business 36.5
banking 35
dollars 32.9
hundred 30.1
financial 29.4
us 28
exchange 23.9
savings 22.4
close 20.6
bills 20.4
vintage 19.9
banknote 18.5
investment 18.4
rich 17.7
note 17.5
franklin 16.8
states 16.5
retro 16.4
economy 15.8
one 15.7
pay 15.4
old 15.3
stamp 14.5
market 14.2
closeup 14.2
letter 13.8
banknotes 13.7
united 13.3
comic book 12.6
finances 12.5
loan 12.5
mail 12.5
sign 12.1
postmark 11.8
paying 11.7
card 11.4
stock 11.2
wages 10.8
funds 10.8
notes 10.6
post 10.5
book 10.4
ancient 10.4
history 9.9
envelope 9.7
group 9.7
success 9.7
price 9.6
capital 9.5
heap 9.4
message 9.1
philately 8.9
president 8.9
monetary 8.8
tax 8.8
rate 8.8
symbol 8.8
text 8.7
debt 8.7
antique 8.7
save 8.5
web site 8.2
aged 8.2
collection 8.1
greenback 7.9
federal 7.9
twenty 7.9
postage 7.9
legal 7.8
dough 7.8
income 7.8
value 7.8
economic 7.8
treasure 7.7
tender 7.7
grunge 7.7
profit 7.7
document 7.4
design 7.3
global 7.3
new 7.3

Google
created on 2019-06-06

Text 89
Architecture 72.6
History 70.9
Collection 70.4
Photographic paper 68.1
Paper 66.6
Room 65.7
Newsprint 65.3
Art 58.1
Paper product 57.7
Book 51.5
Illustration 50.4

Microsoft
created on 2019-06-06

scene 97.3
room 94.2
gallery 91.8
museum 61.1
poster 55.6

Color Analysis

Face analysis

Amazon

AWS Rekognition

Age 4-7
Gender Female, 50.4%
Calm 49.7%
Happy 49.9%
Sad 49.6%
Angry 49.6%
Disgusted 49.7%
Confused 49.5%
Surprised 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 23-38
Gender Female, 50.4%
Sad 49.6%
Angry 50%
Happy 49.6%
Disgusted 49.7%
Calm 49.5%
Surprised 49.5%
Confused 49.5%

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person

Clarifai

Building
Tree
Poster
Person
Window

AWS Rekognition

Person 94%

AWS Rekognition

Person 85.3%

AWS Rekognition

Person 84%

AWS Rekognition

Person 82.8%

AWS Rekognition

Person 81.4%

AWS Rekognition

Person 77.7%

AWS Rekognition

Person 66.9%

Clarifai

Building 83.6%

Clarifai

Building 75.7%

Clarifai

Building 58.1%

Clarifai

Building 50.1%

Clarifai

Building 41.8%

Clarifai

Building 34.2%

Clarifai

Tree 80.5%

Clarifai

Tree 74.2%

Clarifai

Tree 62.8%

Clarifai

Tree 61.6%

Clarifai

Tree 51.1%

Clarifai

Tree 43.6%

Clarifai

Tree 40.7%

Clarifai

Tree 34.4%

Clarifai

Poster 79.3%

Clarifai

Person 71.8%

Clarifai

Person 71.5%

Clarifai

Person 61.5%

Clarifai

Person 46.1%

Clarifai

Person 42.7%

Clarifai

Person 39.5%

Clarifai

Person 35%

Clarifai

Window 58.4%

Clarifai

Window 56.3%

Clarifai

Window 54.7%

Clarifai

Window 53.7%

Clarifai

Window 50.9%

Clarifai

Window 50.3%

Clarifai

Window 49.4%

Clarifai

Window 47.9%

Clarifai

Window 47.6%

Clarifai

Window 46%

Clarifai

Window 45.4%

Clarifai

Window 44.9%

Clarifai

Window 43.1%

Clarifai

Window 41.8%

Clarifai

Window 41.4%

Clarifai

Window 41.2%

Clarifai

Window 39.1%

Clarifai

Window 38.9%

Clarifai

Window 37.6%

Clarifai

Window 37.2%

Clarifai

Window 37%

Clarifai

Window 36.8%

Clarifai

Window 36.6%

Clarifai

Window 35.8%

Clarifai

Window 35.4%

Clarifai

Window 34.9%

Clarifai

Window 34.6%

Clarifai

Window 33.8%

Clarifai

Window 33.7%

Clarifai

Window 33.4%

Clarifai

Window 33.3%

Clarifai

Window 33.2%

Categories

Imagga
created on 2019-06-06

paintings art 78.6%
text visuals 8.8%
streetview architecture 8.1%
interior objects 3.8%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2019-06-06

a close up of a sign 72.3%
a sign for a photo 51.1%
a room that has a sign on a wall 51%

Clarifai

No captions written

Salesforce

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-28

a photograph of a group of photographs of a group of people in front of a building

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip-2 on 2025-07-04

a collection of photographs of buildings in the city of berlin

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-11-20 on 2025-06-10

This is a collage featuring six photographs of cooperative societies in Switzerland, along with descriptive captions beneath each image. The images showcase various buildings and interiors associated with cooperative stores.

  1. Top Left Image: Depicts a small village store, described as having "unpretentiousness" and a "small membership."

  2. Top Middle Image: Shows a cooperative union building in Basel, emphasizing growth since its establishment in 1856 and highlighting a membership structure and retail business focus.

  3. Top Right Image: Displays the "Konsumverein," a cooperative in Olten, which appears as a large, ornate, multi-story building.

  4. Bottom Left Image: Features the "Konsumverein" in Bischofszell, which began as a joint-stock company in 1901 before becoming a cooperative store.

  5. Bottom Middle Image: Provides an interior view of a cooperative store in Zurich, showing employees and stocked shelves. The caption notes the store's substantial membership base and its operation under strict cooperative principles.

  6. Bottom Right Image: Depicts a building related to the "Plainstrative Society" in Geneva, described as the third-largest society in Switzerland, with members receiving dividends based on their purchases.

The layout is neat and informative, with a title "Coöperative Societies, Switzerland" at the top. Descriptions beneath each photograph offer an overview of the origin, function, and structure of the cooperative societies.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-08-06 on 2025-06-10

This image is a collage of six photographs on a gray sheet, with the title "Coöperative Societies, Switzerland" at the top center. Each photograph is accompanied by explanatory text.

Starting from the top left, the first photograph is labeled "Swiss village store. Unpretentious store, small membership." It shows a simple building with a sloped roof and people standing outside.

To the right of that is a photograph of a larger building, labeled "Co-operative Union Beun, near the likes of Zurich and small societies this society has sales of 3 million francs and dividend of 5 1/2 percent of profits members interest averages 7 1/2 percent, trading in farm produce, bakery and clothing. Is closely connected with other local societies and exchanges the goods with them."

The top row's last photograph on the right is of an imposing building, labeled "Konsumverein, Olten."

On the bottom row, the first photograph on the left portrays another building labeled "Konsumverein, Bischofszell, began as a joint stock company, since 1901 a genuine co-operative store."

The middle photograph on the bottom row shows the inside of a store with people working inside, labeled "Frauenfeld society, Frauenfeld, second largest society in Zurich membership stocks consist of records only."

Finally, on the bottom right, there is a photograph of another building labeled "Spar-und Hülfs-Verein, Geneva, third largest society in Zurich city members can hold 1 share divisions sometimes control, the west wage interest for 3 from 7. Receives a dividend of 5 ¼ cents in ½ the shares such a society for co-op shares the large number, numbers receive 10% of annual profit."

These photographs collectively exhibit different cooperative societies and stores in Switzerland, during the time reflected in the style and architecture.

Anthropic Claude

Created by anthropic.claude-3-haiku-20240307-v1:0 on 2025-06-14

This image appears to be a collection of photographs depicting various cooperative societies and buildings in Switzerland. The images show different cooperative establishments, including a village store, a residential building, a store interior, and a larger cooperative building. The captions provide some information about the cooperative societies and their activities, such as their role in social welfare and community programs. However, the image does not contain any human faces, so I will not identify or name any individuals shown.

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-14

This is a page showing six historical photographs of cooperative societies in Switzerland. The images appear to be from the early 20th century and show different cooperative buildings and operations:

  1. Top left: A Swiss village store/cooperative in a traditional building with people standing outside
  2. Top center: A "Konsumverein Union" building in Basel
  3. Top right: A larger "Konsumverein" building in Olten
  4. Bottom left: A "Konsumverein" in Liechtensteig
  5. Bottom center: Interior of a store showing workers behind a counter with shelves of goods
  6. Bottom right: A "Distribution Society" building in Geneva

The photographs are mounted on what appears to be an album or display page with typed captions beneath each image. The overall theme appears to be documenting various cooperative society buildings and operations across different Swiss locations. These cooperatives were likely consumer organizations that provided goods and services to their members. The architecture ranges from traditional Swiss buildings to more modern (for the time) commercial structures.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-10

The image presents a collection of six vintage photographs, arranged in two rows of three, showcasing various buildings and scenes. The photographs are displayed on a gray background, with a title at the top that reads "Cooperative Societies, Switzerland" in black text.

Photograph 1:
The first photograph, located in the top-left corner, depicts a large building with a sloping roof and a dirt road leading up to it. A person is standing in front of the building, and trees are visible in the background.

Photograph 2:
The second photograph, situated in the top-center, shows a large white building with a tree in front of it. The building has a flat roof and several windows.

Photograph 3:
The third photograph, positioned in the top-right corner, features a large building with a flat roof and many windows. Power lines are visible in the background.

Photograph 4:
The fourth photograph, located in the bottom-left corner, displays a large building with a sign that reads "KONSUM VORNE & BUCHFELD." A person is standing in front of the building, and a horse-drawn carriage is visible in the background.

Photograph 5:
The fifth photograph, situated in the bottom-center, shows a man standing behind a counter, surrounded by shelves and other objects. The background is blurry, but it appears to be a store or market.

Photograph 6:
The sixth photograph, positioned in the bottom-right corner, features a large building with a flat roof and many windows. A person is standing in front of the building, and a horse-drawn carriage is visible in the background.

Additional Text:
Below each photograph, there is a block of text that provides additional information about the image. The text is written in a foreign language, possibly German or French, and includes details such as the name of the cooperative society, the location, and a brief description of the scene.

Overall:
The image appears to be a collection of photographs showcasing various cooperative societies in Switzerland. The photographs provide a glimpse into the daily life and activities of these societies, which were likely important institutions in the community. The inclusion of additional text below each photograph adds context and provides further information about the images.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-10

This image is a page from a scrapbook or photo album, titled "Coöperative Societies, Switzerland" in black text at the top center. The page features six sepia-toned photographs of buildings, each accompanied by a caption in black text below it. The captions are written in English and provide information about the buildings, including their names, locations, and purposes.

The photographs depict various types of buildings, such as houses, stores, and factories, which are likely related to cooperative societies in Switzerland. The captions provide context and details about each building, such as its history, function, and significance.

Overall, this image appears to be a collection of photographs and information about cooperative societies in Switzerland, likely compiled for educational or informational purposes.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-06-10

A page of a photo album with several black-and-white photos of different buildings. The top left photo is of a building with people standing outside, and the caption reads "Miss village store. Unpretentious store; small membership." The top middle photo is of a building with trees in front of it, and the caption reads "Cooperative Union", Basel. This Society acts as a wholesale society, two-third of the total number of Swiss retail societies being federated in it. It publishes and distributes free to members a weekly and a fortnightly journal, 2 in German, 1 in French,For educational and propagandistic purposes. It has its own laboratory for analyzing the goods it distributes." The top right photo is of a building with the caption "Konsumverein", Oiten. The middle left photo is of a building with the caption "Konsumverein", Bischofszell. Began as a joint stock company; since 1901 a genuine co-operative store." The middle photo is of a store with people inside, and the caption reads "Distributive Society", Zurich. Second largest society; 72 branch stores; 15000 total membership; stock consists of groceries only." The middle right photo is of a building with the caption "Distributive Society", Geneva. This third largest society, 30 branch stores. Members can hold 1 share each; joining must contribute to the reserve fund. Open to non-members also,who receive no share of the profits. No credit given, stores of the Society claims at 6.7% on inventory. Employees receive 10% of total profits."

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-06-10

The image is a collage of seven old photographs with text. The collage is titled "Cooperative Societies, Switzerland." The photographs depict different buildings and scenes related to cooperative societies in Switzerland. The text provides brief descriptions of each photograph, including the names of the cooperative societies and some details about their operations. The collage likely serves as an educational or informational resource about cooperative societies in Switzerland.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-05-27

Here is a description of the image:

The image is a composite of six black-and-white photographs arranged on a gray background. The title at the top center reads "Coöperative Societies, Switzerland." Each photograph depicts a different coöperative society location, accompanied by a brief description.

The photographs show various buildings and scenes:

  1. A Swiss village store: A modest building with a staircase leading to the entrance. The caption mentions it's an "Unpretentious store; small membership."
  2. "Co-operative Union," Basel: A larger, multi-story building surrounded by trees. The caption describes the society's role as a wholesale society and its educational and propagandist purposes, mentioning the publication of journals in multiple languages.
  3. "Konstarmersin," Olten: A grand building with intricate architectural details.
  4. "Konsterverein," Bischofszell: A corner building with the text "KONSUM VEREIN BISCHOFSZELL" on its facade. The caption notes its origin as a joint stock company that became a genuine co-operative store in 1901.
  5. "Distributive Society," Zurich: An interior view of a store with shelves stocked with goods and a shop assistant serving customers. The caption mentions it's the second-largest society with 72 branch stores and a membership of 15,000.
  6. "Distributive Society," Geneva: A large, imposing building with an arched entrance. The caption notes it's the third-largest society with 20 branch stores and describes the conditions for membership and profit sharing.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-05-27

Here's a description of the image:

The image is a page from a historical scrapbook, focusing on "Coöperative Societies" in Switzerland. It's organized into a grid of six black and white photographs, each with a caption underneath, likely from the early 20th century.

The photographs show various establishments:

  • Swiss village store: An unpretentious store with a small membership.
  • "Co-operative Union", Basel: A large building, functioning as a wholesale society and publisher of journals.
  • "Konssumerverein", Olten: A large building, possibly a store or headquarters.
  • "Konsumverein", Bischofszell: A building that began as a joint stock company.
  • "Distributive Society", Zurich: A store with staff behind a counter
  • "Distributive Society", Geneva: A large building, likely a store.

The overall style is characteristic of vintage photography, with the captions typed in a standard font. The image offers a glimpse into the history of cooperative movements in Switzerland.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-05

The image is a collage of six photographs showcasing various cooperative societies in Switzerland. Each photograph is accompanied by a caption that provides details about the specific cooperative. Here is a summary of each photograph:

  1. Top Left (Bülach Village Store):

    • The photograph shows a small cooperative store in Bülach village. The building appears to be a modest structure, likely serving the local community.
  2. Top Center (Cooperative Union, Basel):

    • This photograph depicts the Cooperative Union in Basel. The building is described as the central office for a union of 75 local societies, with a total membership of 30,000. The union operates a wholesale business with a turnover of 4 million francs and 2 million francs in retail sales. It also runs a bakery, a boot factory, and a printing press, employing 200 workers. The building is noted for its modern and hygienic design.
  3. Top Right (Consumverein, Glarus):

    • The photograph shows the Consumverein in Glarus. The building appears to be a large, multi-story structure, likely serving as a cooperative store or headquarters.
  4. Bottom Left (Consumverein, Möhlinfeld):

    • This photograph features the Consumverein in Möhlinfeld, which was built in 1901. The building is described as a fine cooperative store, indicating its importance in the local community.
  5. Bottom Center (Cooperative Society, Zurich):

    • The photograph shows the Cooperative Society in Zurich. The society is noted for having the largest membership, with around 16,000 total members. The building is a multi-story structure with a modern facade, reflecting its role as a significant cooperative entity.
  6. Bottom Right (Distributive Society, Geneva):

    • The photograph depicts the Distributive Society in Geneva. The building is described as having a unique design, with a ground floor for retail and upper floors for offices and storage. The society has a positive balance sheet, indicating its financial stability and success.

Overall, the collage highlights the architectural diversity and significance of cooperative societies in Switzerland, showcasing their role in local communities and their economic impact.

Qwen

No captions written

Text analysis

Amazon

Switzerland
Cooiperative Societies, Switzerland
Cooiperative
Societies,
Second
Surian
"Kommterreretn".
store:
store: sall
sall
Thind

Google

Cooperative Societies, Switzerland CATON. w This oetety o lon etety, tac UmretentioE atore: nonll nenbership. "Konmureruin", 01ten. 2 in Geran in Pch n Tealtan tdon 41str abo KONSUN VERDN RISCADo second larent nooletr 78 braneh atares: 15000 total aeberahtp; stonk eonsiste of roceries only. Dtatritutivre Soetety", Genevs "Konnurrerein, Bischofsnell. no share of the oroite. Ho eredtt etwen. Stres of roceive 10 or setal uenes iday. Yaployoea
Cooperative
Societies,
Switzerland
CATON.
w
This
oetety
o
lon
etety,
tac
UmretentioE
atore:
nonll
nenbership.
"Konmureruin",
01ten.
2
in
Geran
Pch
n
Tealtan
tdon
41str
abo
KONSUN
VERDN
RISCADo
second
larent
nooletr
78
braneh
atares:
15000
total
aeberahtp;
stonk
eonsiste
of
roceries
only.
Dtatritutivre
Soetety",
Genevs
"Konnurrerein,
Bischofsnell.
no
share
the
oroite.
Ho
eredtt
etwen.
Stres
roceive
10
or
setal
uenes
iday.
Yaployoea