Human Generated Data

Title

Industrial Problems, Welfare Work: United States. Colorado. Pueblo. Colorado Fuel and Iron Company: Industrial Betterment in the United States. Housing of Working People by Employers: Colorado Fuel and Iron Company, Pueblo, Colorado.

Date

c. 1903

People

Artist: Unidentified Artist,

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Social Museum Collection, 3.2002.2239

Human Generated Data

Title

Industrial Problems, Welfare Work: United States. Colorado. Pueblo. Colorado Fuel and Iron Company: Industrial Betterment in the United States. Housing of Working People by Employers: Colorado Fuel and Iron Company, Pueblo, Colorado.

People

Artist: Unidentified Artist,

Date

c. 1903

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Social Museum Collection, 3.2002.2239

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2023-10-25

Page 99.9
Text 99.9
Field 97.4
Grassland 97.4
Nature 97.4
Outdoors 97.4
Advertisement 96
Art 95.8
Painting 95.8
Poster 94.6
Plant 91.2
Tree 91.2
Publication 74.1
Architecture 57.6
Building 57.6
Housing 57.6
Grass 57.2
Arch 56.5
Vegetation 55.4
Mound 55.4

Clarifai
created on 2019-02-18

landscape 97.6
art 94
no person 92.9
museum 92.9
painting 92.8
travel 92
illustration 91.9
outdoors 91.6
sunset 90.9
water 90.8
print 90.7
retro 90.4
building 90.4
nature 90.4
vintage 90.2
paper 90.2
old 89.9
city 89.6
sky 89
album 88.3

Imagga
created on 2019-02-18

newspaper 100
product 100
creation 82.8
paper 30.6
daily 27.7
old 25.1
money 23
book 22
business 21.9
vintage 20.7
text 19.2
bible 17.6
letter 17.4
antique 17.3
retro 17.2
religion 17
currency 16.2
religious 15.9
page 15.8
cash 15.6
read 15.4
note 14.7
design 14.6
prayer 14.5
holy 14.5
finance 14.4
bill 14.3
dollar 13.9
bank 13.4
god 13.4
ancient 13
grunge 12.8
card 12.8
close 12.6
menu 12.5
pay 12.5
faith 12.4
spiritual 11.5
office 11.3
document 11.1
art 11.1
testament 10.9
envelope 10.7
writing 10.4
church 10.2
banking 10.1
gospel 9.9
history 9.8
postage 9.8
postal 9.8
financial 9.8
one 9.7
stamp 9.7
exchange 9.6
post 9.5
print 9.4
symbol 9.4
texture 9
open 9
new 8.9
scripture 8.9
postmark 8.9
fare 8.8
banknote 8.7
pray 8.7
us 8.7
payment 8.7
loan 8.6
mail 8.6
blank 8.6
reading 8.6
cross 8.5
communication 8.4
number 8.4
message 8.2
aged 8.1
wealth 8.1
graphic 8
information 8
education 7.8
color 7.8
dollars 7.7
spirituality 7.7
notes 7.7
sign 7.5
stock 7.5
savings 7.5
closeup 7.4
dirty 7.2

Google
created on 2019-02-18

Text 94
Holy places 90
Paper product 69
Tree 68.7
Room 65.7
Paper 57
History 54.1
Illustration 50.4
Art 50.2

Microsoft
created on 2019-02-18

text 86.8
museum 86.8
art 17.7
heritage 8.5
design 8.2

Color Analysis

Feature analysis

Amazon

Book

Clarifai

Tree
House
Window

AWS Rekognition

Book 66.6%

Clarifai

Tree 98.3%

Clarifai

Tree 98.1%

Clarifai

Tree 91.7%

Clarifai

Tree 91.3%

Clarifai

Tree 68.1%

Clarifai

Tree 57.3%

Clarifai

Tree 57.2%

Clarifai

Tree 46.6%

Clarifai

Tree 44.6%

Clarifai

Tree 42.3%

Clarifai

Tree 41.1%

Clarifai

Tree 37.1%

Clarifai

Tree 36.7%

Clarifai

Tree 36.7%

Clarifai

Tree 35.8%

Clarifai

Tree 33.6%

Clarifai

House 59.1%

Clarifai

Window 46.9%

Clarifai

Window 34.9%

Categories

Imagga
created on 2019-02-18

text visuals 77.6%
interior objects 8.1%
streetview architecture 6.6%
paintings art 5.9%

Captions

Microsoft
created by unknown on 2019-02-18

a close up of a sign 79.9%
close up of a sign 75.6%
a sign on a wall 62.9%

Clarifai

Created by general-english-image-caption-clip on 2025-07-12

a city in the early 1900s.

Salesforce

Created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-02

a photograph of a photograph of a house with a bridge in the background

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-11-20 on 2025-06-12

This image is a historic photograph of two scenes from Redstone, Colorado, related to housing and infrastructure for working people provided by employers. It appears to come from a government or industrial report about worker housing in the United States.

  • Left photo: Shows a street in Redstone, Colorado, lined with trees and modest worker housing. The houses are simple structures with a wooden fence lining the road. The lighting suggests it was taken during daylight hours, likely emphasizing the efforts to create an organized residential area for workers.

  • Right photo: Features a schoolhouse in Redstone, Colorado. The building has a stone foundation and wooden walls, with architectural details including a steeply pitched roof and a bell tower. The schoolhouse is surrounded by trees, indicating it was built in a scenic location. Scaffolding appears to be present, suggesting ongoing work or updates to the structure at the time the photograph was taken.

Below the images, there is detailed text describing the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company, which constructed these homes and facilities for miners and other employees. The text highlights the company’s efforts to improve living conditions for their workers, including the construction of modern amenities like cottages and public buildings. Rent prices are also mentioned, along with details of the plastered and finished interiors of the homes—designed to be affordable yet comfortable.

The page belongs to a publication titled "Industrial Betterment in the United States: Housing of Working People by Employers," and references a statement from a government bulletin dated 1904. This shows how industrial companies at the time worked to combine economic and social efforts for their employees.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-08-06 on 2025-06-12

The image is a historical document featuring two photographs and descriptive text. At the top of the document, in bold heading style, is the title "Industrial Betterment in the United States: Housing of Working People by Employers."

The document contains two sepia-toned photographs side by side. The photograph on the left shows a street scene in Redstone, Colorado. It features trees, a dirt path, fences, and some buildings in the background. The landscape gives a rural or small-town feel. Below this photograph, the caption reads "Street in Redstone, Colorado."

The photograph on the right depicts a schoolhouse in Redstone, Colorado, with visible scaffolding indicating construction or renovation work. The building has an American flag on a flagpole, and there are trees and hills in the background. The architectural style appears traditional with a slight Gothic influence, as seen in the arched windows and entrance. This photograph is captioned "School-House, Redstone, Colorado."

Below the photographs is text providing information about the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company, Pueblo, Colorado. The text describes the company's involvement in housing for workers, noting that it operates several coal mines and industrial plants and is engaged in building homes for its employees. The description highlights the modern style of construction, including amenities such as water and sanitation services, schools, and social facilities, while also detailing the costs of these dwellings.

The document references a statement from Chas. M. Howe, "Housing of the Working People in the United States, Betterment of Employers," and cites a source from the U.S. Bulletin, Department of Labor, No. 54, 1904, at the end.

Anthropic Claude

Created by anthropic.claude-3-haiku-20240307-v1:0 on 2025-06-16

The image shows two photographs depicting industrial settlements or housing for working people in the United States. The first photograph shows a street in Redstone, Colorado, with wooden buildings and structures surrounded by trees. The second photograph shows a building in Sopris, Colorado, which appears to be a company-owned housing facility for workers. The text below the images provides some context, indicating that these were examples of "Industrial Betterment in the United States: Housing of Working People by Employers."

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-16

This appears to be a historical document about industrial housing in the United States, specifically showing housing provided by employers. The page contains two sepia-toned photographs of what appears to be company housing in Crestone, Colorado, associated with the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company of Pueblo, Colorado.

The images show residential buildings set against a backdrop of tall trees and mountains. The structures appear to be early 20th century construction, with wooden frames and what looks like a raised walkway or bridge connecting some of the buildings.

Below the photographs is descriptive text that appears to detail the housing conditions and specifications. The document seems to be part of a larger study or report about industrial betterment and worker housing in the United States.

The quality and style of the photographs, along with the document formatting, suggests this is from the early 1900s. It provides an interesting historical glimpse into company towns and worker housing during America's industrial period.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-05

The image presents a vintage document titled "Industrial Betterment in the United States: Housing of Working People by Employers," featuring two sepia-toned photographs and accompanying text.

Title
The title, centered at the top of the page, is printed in black ink on a beige background. It reads: "Industrial Betterment in the United States: Housing of Working People by Employers."

Photographs
Two photographs are displayed side by side below the title. The left photograph depicts a street scene with trees and buildings, while the right photograph shows a house with a porch and trees in the background.

Text
Below each photograph, a block of text provides additional information about the images. The text is written in black ink and appears to be a description of the photographs.

Background
The document is set against a gray background, which provides a neutral contrast to the beige paper and black ink used in the document.

Overall
The image presents a historical document that showcases the housing conditions of working people in the United States during the early 20th century. The use of sepia-toned photographs and handwritten text adds a sense of nostalgia and authenticity to the document.

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-06-05

This image is a page from a book or document, featuring two photographs of houses in Redstone, Colorado. The title at the top reads "Industrial Betterment in the United States" and "Housing of Working People by Employers."

The left photograph shows a street in Redstone, with a white fence and trees lining the road. A person is walking along the sidewalk. The right photograph depicts a school house in Redstone, with a large building and a smaller structure in front of it.

Below the photographs are descriptions of the images, including information about the company that built the houses and the features of the homes. The text is written in black ink on a beige background, with some words and phrases underlined or italicized for emphasis. Overall, the image provides a glimpse into the living conditions of working-class people in Redstone, Colorado, during the early 20th century.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-06-03

The image is a page from a book or report, titled "Industrial Betterment in the United States: Housing of Working People by Employers." The page contains two black-and-white photographs and accompanying text. The left photograph shows a street in Redstone, Colorado, with a house and a bridge. The right photograph shows a house in Redstone, Colorado. The text provides information about the housing provided by employers for their workers in Redstone, Colorado. It mentions that the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company, which operates a number of coal mines in Colorado and New Mexico, has a large system of rolling mills at Redstone. The company has built a number of houses for its employees, which are finished within, provided with porches and projecting eaves, and painted in various and harmonious colors. The houses are arranged in regular order upon streets, with the group of dwellings at Jansen, Las Animas County, for the company's railway employees being particularly noteworthy. The text also mentions that the company's railway employees are charged for rent at a uniform rate of four cents a room per month.

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-06-03

The image is a vintage photograph featuring two separate scenes of residential buildings, with a text overlay at the top and bottom. The top text reads "Industrial Betterment in the United States Housing of Working People by Employers." The bottom text provides additional context and information about the images.

The left image shows a street scene in Redstone, Colorado, with a large, two-story house in the foreground. The house has a porch and is surrounded by tall trees. A person is standing in front of the house, and a fence is visible in the background. The text describes the house as part of the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company's efforts to provide housing for its employees.

The right image shows a group of houses in Pueblo, Colorado, also built by the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company. The houses are arranged in a row and are described as being comfortable and well-designed. The text notes that the company has built similar houses in other locations, such as Las Animas County, for its employees.

Overall, the image provides a glimpse into the efforts of industrial companies in the early 20th century to provide housing for their workers, highlighting the importance of industrial betterment and the role of employers in improving the living conditions of their employees.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-05-07

Here is a description of the image:

The image is a photographic print of two black and white photographs, taken around the early 20th century. The photos are part of a larger document titled "Industrial Betterment in the United States. Housing of Working People by Employers."

The left-hand photo is labeled "STREET IN REDSTONE COLORADO". It shows a street scene with what appears to be company housing. Trees are in the foreground, and a fence runs along the side of the street. A person can be seen walking in the distance, and there are houses further back.

The right-hand photo, labeled "SCHOOL HOUSE, REDSTONE. COLORADO", features a schoolhouse with distinctive architecture. There are trees surrounding the building, and a flag is visible on top of the schoolhouse.

Beneath each photograph is descriptive text. The text beneath the photos provides further context, mentioning the "COLORADO FUEL AND IRON COMPANY, PUEBLO, COLORADO" and describing the housing and buildings constructed by the company for its employees. It emphasizes the modern and comfortable nature of these dwellings and buildings, contrasting them with the squalid conditions often associated with mining communities. The statement also mentions the rental costs for these dwellings.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-05-07

Here's a description of the image:

Overall Impression:

The image is a historical document, likely from a report or publication. It's a sepia-toned print, suggesting it was created in the early 20th century. The focus is on "Industrial Betterment in the United States" through employer-provided housing for working people. It showcases model housing examples.

Layout and Structure:

  • The image is composed of two separate photographs, likely mounted on a page.
  • Text at the top provides the title and context.
  • Each photograph has a caption below, identifying the location and/or type of building.
  • Additional descriptive text is provided below the photographs, expanding on the context and details.

Individual Photographs:

  • Left Photograph:
    • Subject: "Street in Redstone, Colorado."
    • Description: It depicts a street scene, showing a roadway and possibly a picket fence on a raised platform. There's a tall tree.
  • Right Photograph:
    • Subject: "School House, Redstone, Colorado."
    • Description: This shows a school building, with a structure with a stone foundation, windows, and a turret-like element on top. There are also trees in the foreground.

Textual Content:

The text gives insights into the goals, context, and methods of the "Industrial Betterment" movement. Key points include:

  • Emphasis on the employers improving the housing conditions of their workers, noting the contrasts with "squalid and insanitary miner's shack."
  • Descriptions of the type of housing provided, including comfortable, convenient, and sanitary cottages.
  • Specific locations, like Colorado, are mentioned.
  • Information on the size of the homes, rental rates, and architectural details.
  • There's a reference to a company, Colorado Fuel and Iron Company.
  • There's a note citing the source and date of the information: U.S. Department of Labor Bulletin from 1904.

Overall Tone and Purpose:

The image is promotional in nature. The photographs and descriptions aim to illustrate the positive impacts of employer-provided housing. It highlights the improvement in living conditions for the working class, and it's meant to inspire and encourage similar practices.

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-06-08

The image is a historical document titled "Industrial Betterment in the United States: Housing of Working People by Employers." It features two photographs and accompanying text, highlighting efforts by the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company in Pueblo, Colorado, to improve housing conditions for their workers.

  1. Left Photograph and Caption:

    • Image: The photograph shows a street in Redstone, Colorado, with a row of houses and a large smokestack in the background.
    • Caption: The text explains that the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company, which operates coal mines and coke ovens, has built pleasant dwellings for its employees. These homes are arranged in a practical and attractive manner, with modern conveniences like running water, electricity, and sewage systems. The company has also provided amenities such as a school, church, and hospital. The houses are described as comfortable and modern, replacing the old shacks that were previously common.
  2. Right Photograph and Caption:

    • Image: The photograph depicts a schoolhouse in Redstone, Colorado.
    • Caption: The text notes that the company has replaced old, unpleasant houses with new, modern dwellings that are well-ventilated and have modern conveniences. The houses are designed to be comfortable and attractive, with amenities like electricity and running water. The company has also built community facilities such as a school, church, and hospital. The text emphasizes the significant improvement in living conditions for the workers.

The document is a statement from G.W.W. Hanger, President of the Working People in the United States, dated March 24, 1904, highlighting the efforts of the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company to provide better housing for their employees.

Qwen

No captions written

Text analysis

Amazon

by
United
People
the
Industrial
Housing of Working People by Employers
Employers
of
Betterment
Industrial Betterment in the United States
Housing
STREET
SCHOOL
Working
AND
in
States
IN
have
been
order
finished
and
with
rolls
rolline
COLORADO
which
other
are
at
pleasered
or
recently
einen
ZAPER
STREET IN REDSTANT COLORADO
carry
and colors.
FUEL
whose
These
regiler order upon
Arranged
COLORADO FUEL AND JRON COMPANY, COLORADO
colors.
hounes have recently been completed. These are mll pleasered and really
upon
sion to rolline
completed.
HOUSE
thin.provided
Arranged 15
SCHOOL HOUSE REDSTONE CALORADO,
regiler
operated
finished wt thin.provided with pershee and progective eaven, jointed in
steel
sion
mills
pershee
15
*This Company which operated B ZAPER member of ectlifer other
6001-
to
*This
nation or
BYS
80,000
varies
einen measterned
CALORADO,
mills at Pitture steel plens at Poelilo,and tuo milk
REDSTONE
COMPANY,
wt
JRON
milk
throughout Coloredo.Usah are New 6001-
BYS tens,and
plens
really
TCI
REDSTANT
employees.
mll
marry 80,000
B
hounes
jointed
Company
progective
tens,and
Te"
member
New
throughout
Way
tuo
marry
84. RLO TCI
nation
Pitture
measterned
ectlifer
eaven,
Poelilo,and
RLO
Coloredo.Usah
84.

Google

Industrial Betterment in the United States Housing of Working People by Employers hich cpernten a larce mater of ccsl.iron and cther finished within,provided h and profeeti evea.cnd painted in in regmler erder upon streets, they appear to dectded ndraritace br the sice of the clčer are nere pecrly dis and conte-table drellines for the teuel squrlid nnd innerd tary aiper's These bud ldsngs ully contain froa 4 to 6 rcons ench, and mdla able. convenient. andtary and honeLke. The price charged pper in an casee wtth nanine wter and elecuvie lichts.ere
Industrial
Betterment
in
the
United
States
Housing
of
Working
People
by
Employers
hich
cpernten
a
larce
mater
ccsl.iron
and
cther
finished
within,provided
h
profeeti
evea.cnd
painted
regmler
erder
upon
streets,
they
appear
to
dectded
ndraritace
br
sice
clčer
are
nere
pecrly
dis
conte-table
drellines
for
teuel
squrlid
nnd
innerd
tary
aiper's
These
bud
ldsngs
ully
contain
froa
4
6
rcons
ench,
mdla
able.
convenient.
andtary
honeLke.
The
price
charged
pper
an
casee
wtth
nanine
wter
elecuvie
lichts.ere