Human Generated Data

Title

Industrial Problems, Coöperation: Europe. France. Paris: La Bellevilloise: Coöperative Societies, France: La Bellevillaise Socialist Coöperative Society in Paris 1907: Holiday Excursion of the Members and their Families

Date

c. 1907

People

Artist: Edouard Cordonnier, French active c. 1890s

Printer: E. Le Deley, French active c. 1900

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Social Museum Collection, 3.2002.2097.5

Human Generated Data

Title

Industrial Problems, Coöperation: Europe. France. Paris: La Bellevilloise: Coöperative Societies, France: La Bellevillaise Socialist Coöperative Society in Paris 1907: Holiday Excursion of the Members and their Families

People

Artist: Edouard Cordonnier, French active c. 1890s

Printer: E. Le Deley, French active c. 1900

Date

c. 1907

Classification

Photographs

Credit Line

Harvard Art Museums/Fogg Museum, Transfer from the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts, Social Museum Collection, 3.2002.2097.5

Machine Generated Data

Tags

Amazon
created on 2019-06-06

Person 98.6
Human 98.6
Poster 97.8
Advertisement 97.8
Person 96.3
Person 95.3
Text 94.5
Person 88.7
Person 85.9
Person 82.4
Person 81.8
Person 81.3
Person 76.7
Military Uniform 76.5
Military 76.5
Soil 76
Person 75.9
Nature 74.9
Outdoors 74.9
Person 74.2
Newspaper 73.1
Land 66.9
Person 61
Armored 58.1
Army 58.1
Soldier 57.7
Countryside 56.1
Person 44.9
Person 43.4
Person 42

Clarifai
created on 2019-06-06

vintage 99.5
print 99.2
old 98.8
art 98.7
retro 98.6
people 98.6
paper 98.6
antique 97.9
collection 97.7
illustration 96.6
group 96.2
card 95.4
postcard 95.3
picture frame 95
desktop 94.9
painting 94.5
portrait 94.4
adult 93.9
album 93.4
man 93.1

Imagga
created on 2019-06-06

gravestone 100
memorial 80.2
stone 58
structure 53
grunge 41.7
vintage 34.7
old 33.4
antique 32
texture 31.3
blackboard 28.4
aged 26.2
retro 26.2
frame 23.3
grungy 22.8
snow 22.4
border 20.8
ancient 20.8
wall 20.5
damaged 20
paper 18.8
rough 18.2
art 18.2
dirty 18.1
material 17.9
space 17.8
pattern 17.1
textured 16.7
landscape 16.4
design 15.8
blank 15.4
rusty 15.2
empty 14.6
color 14.5
parchment 13.4
brown 13.2
black 13.2
text 13.1
grain 12.9
decay 12.5
dark 12.5
stained 12.5
aging 12.5
old fashioned 12.4
weathered 12.4
graphic 11.7
wallpaper 11.5
outdoors 11.2
paint 10.9
stains 10.7
burnt 10.7
torn 10.6
messy 10.6
spot 10.5
obsolete 10.5
dirt 10.5
worn 10.5
cold 10.3
winter 10.2
decorative 10
backdrop 9.9
weather 9.8
crumpled 9.7
rural 9.7
season 9.4
historic 9.2
surface 8.8
faded 8.8
crack 8.7
forest 8.7
light 8.7
rust 8.7
canvas 8.5
sky 8.3
fence 8.3
park 8.2
urban 7.9
burned 7.8
film 7.8
grime 7.8
ragged 7.8
edge 7.7
stain 7.7
outdoor 7.6
field 7.5
negative 7.3
tree 7.2
trees 7.1
cool 7.1
country 7

Google
created on 2019-06-06

Microsoft
created on 2019-06-06

gallery 94.6
text 93.2
horse 92.8
room 92.6
scene 86.2
person 82.9
old 41.2
picture frame 8.4

Color Analysis

Face analysis

Amazon

AWS Rekognition

Age 26-43
Gender Male, 50.4%
Angry 49.7%
Surprised 49.6%
Disgusted 49.6%
Calm 49.9%
Sad 49.6%
Happy 49.6%
Confused 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 26-43
Gender Male, 50.4%
Angry 49.7%
Calm 49.8%
Surprised 49.5%
Sad 49.8%
Disgusted 49.5%
Happy 49.5%
Confused 49.7%

AWS Rekognition

Age 20-38
Gender Male, 50.2%
Angry 49.6%
Happy 49.5%
Calm 50.3%
Confused 49.5%
Sad 49.6%
Disgusted 49.5%
Surprised 49.5%

AWS Rekognition

Age 23-38
Gender Female, 50.1%
Sad 49.9%
Angry 49.6%
Disgusted 49.5%
Surprised 49.5%
Happy 49.5%
Calm 49.9%
Confused 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 17-27
Gender Male, 50.4%
Sad 49.7%
Calm 49.6%
Surprised 49.5%
Confused 49.6%
Disgusted 49.5%
Happy 49.5%
Angry 50%

AWS Rekognition

Age 23-38
Gender Female, 50.1%
Angry 49.7%
Confused 49.6%
Calm 49.7%
Surprised 49.6%
Sad 49.6%
Happy 49.5%
Disgusted 49.9%

AWS Rekognition

Age 17-27
Gender Female, 50.4%
Calm 49.7%
Surprised 49.5%
Happy 49.5%
Disgusted 49.6%
Angry 49.6%
Sad 49.9%
Confused 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 26-43
Gender Male, 50.4%
Angry 49.6%
Happy 49.5%
Disgusted 49.5%
Confused 49.6%
Calm 50%
Surprised 49.5%
Sad 49.7%

AWS Rekognition

Age 6-13
Gender Male, 50.4%
Sad 49.6%
Surprised 49.6%
Confused 49.6%
Angry 49.8%
Happy 49.6%
Calm 49.7%
Disgusted 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 35-55
Gender Male, 50.1%
Happy 49.5%
Angry 49.5%
Calm 49.5%
Sad 50.2%
Surprised 49.5%
Confused 49.5%
Disgusted 49.7%

AWS Rekognition

Age 17-27
Gender Male, 50.5%
Surprised 49.5%
Happy 49.5%
Confused 49.6%
Calm 49.6%
Disgusted 49.6%
Angry 49.9%
Sad 49.8%

AWS Rekognition

Age 15-25
Gender Female, 50.4%
Calm 49.5%
Disgusted 49.9%
Surprised 49.5%
Angry 49.8%
Sad 49.6%
Confused 49.5%
Happy 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 17-27
Gender Male, 50.2%
Angry 49.7%
Confused 49.6%
Calm 50%
Surprised 49.5%
Sad 49.6%
Happy 49.5%
Disgusted 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 20-38
Gender Female, 50.4%
Sad 49.7%
Confused 49.6%
Surprised 49.6%
Happy 49.5%
Angry 49.7%
Disgusted 49.5%
Calm 49.8%

AWS Rekognition

Age 26-43
Gender Male, 50.4%
Confused 49.6%
Disgusted 49.7%
Sad 49.8%
Angry 49.6%
Surprised 49.6%
Happy 49.5%
Calm 49.7%

AWS Rekognition

Age 9-14
Gender Male, 50.4%
Confused 49.7%
Disgusted 49.6%
Sad 49.8%
Angry 49.6%
Surprised 49.5%
Happy 49.5%
Calm 49.8%

AWS Rekognition

Age 26-43
Gender Female, 50.2%
Surprised 49.5%
Happy 49.5%
Sad 49.8%
Angry 49.8%
Disgusted 49.6%
Confused 49.5%
Calm 49.7%

AWS Rekognition

Age 15-25
Gender Female, 50.2%
Happy 49.5%
Sad 49.8%
Angry 49.6%
Surprised 49.6%
Calm 49.8%
Confused 49.6%
Disgusted 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 11-18
Gender Male, 50%
Angry 49.6%
Calm 49.5%
Surprised 49.5%
Sad 50.1%
Disgusted 49.7%
Happy 49.5%
Confused 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 27-44
Gender Female, 50.4%
Happy 49.6%
Disgusted 49.6%
Angry 49.6%
Confused 49.5%
Calm 49.7%
Surprised 49.6%
Sad 49.8%

AWS Rekognition

Age 23-38
Gender Female, 50.2%
Surprised 49.5%
Disgusted 50.2%
Angry 49.5%
Sad 49.6%
Happy 49.6%
Confused 49.5%
Calm 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 20-38
Gender Male, 50.2%
Sad 49.9%
Confused 49.5%
Calm 49.6%
Disgusted 49.5%
Angry 49.9%
Surprised 49.5%
Happy 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 4-9
Gender Male, 50.3%
Calm 49.9%
Happy 49.5%
Sad 49.6%
Angry 49.6%
Confused 49.6%
Disgusted 49.7%
Surprised 49.6%

AWS Rekognition

Age 20-38
Gender Female, 50.4%
Happy 49.6%
Disgusted 49.6%
Surprised 49.6%
Sad 49.7%
Confused 49.6%
Angry 49.6%
Calm 49.8%

AWS Rekognition

Age 26-43
Gender Female, 50.1%
Happy 49.6%
Disgusted 49.5%
Surprised 49.6%
Sad 49.6%
Confused 49.6%
Angry 49.8%
Calm 49.9%

AWS Rekognition

Age 17-27
Gender Female, 50.5%
Angry 49.5%
Disgusted 49.5%
Calm 50.2%
Surprised 49.5%
Happy 49.5%
Sad 49.7%
Confused 49.5%

AWS Rekognition

Age 35-52
Gender Male, 50.2%
Surprised 49.6%
Happy 49.6%
Confused 49.6%
Calm 49.7%
Disgusted 49.6%
Angry 49.7%
Sad 49.7%

AWS Rekognition

Age 26-44
Gender Female, 50.1%
Sad 49.6%
Angry 49.9%
Happy 49.6%
Disgusted 49.7%
Calm 49.6%
Surprised 49.6%
Confused 49.6%

Feature analysis

Amazon

Person
Poster
Person 98.6%
Person 96.3%
Person 95.3%
Person 88.7%
Person 85.9%
Person 82.4%
Person 81.8%
Person 81.3%
Person 76.7%
Person 75.9%
Person 74.2%
Person 61%
Person 44.9%
Person 43.4%
Person 42%
Poster 97.8%

Categories

Captions

Clarifai
created by general-english-image-caption-blip on 2025-05-19

a photograph of a group of people standing in front of a field -100%

OpenAI GPT

Created by gpt-4o-2024-11-20 on 2025-06-07

This image is a vintage photograph presented in two panels. The top panel shows a large group of people gathered outdoors in a forested area. They are dressed in early 20th-century attire, many holding hats, with the caption underneath stating, "Consommation communiste d'oxygène," which translates to "Communist consumption of oxygen." The scene suggests a shared experience in nature or fresh air, potentially symbolizing communal principles.

The bottom panel depicts a smaller group of people walking along a narrow dirt path through grassy fields. Trees are visible in the background. The caption beneath this panel reads, "Reprise du sol par la peuplade des Bellevillois de Ménilmontant," translating to "Reclaiming the land by the people of Belleville from Ménilmontant." Below it further details, "Patronage de 'La Bellevilloise' Excursion à Verrières - 7 Juillet 1907," referring to "La Bellevilloise," a community or organization in Paris, and their outing to Verrières on July 7, 1907.

The image as a whole emphasizes a sense of community, shared space, and collective activity, with historical context tied to early 20th-century labor or social movements.

Created by gpt-4o-2024-08-06 on 2025-06-07

The image is an old postcard from the early 20th century. It contains two black-and-white photographs, one on top of the other.

The top photograph depicts a large group of people gathered outdoors in a forested area. They are posed together, facing the camera, and some individuals are holding their hats in hand. The caption below this image reads "Consommation communiste d'oxygène," which translates to "Communist consumption of oxygen."

The bottom photograph shows a group of people walking along a narrow path through a field. They are in a line and wearing hats, typical of the period. The caption beneath this image reads "Reprise du sol par la peuplade des Bellevillois de Ménilmontant," meaning "Reclamation of the soil by the Bellevillois people of Ménilmontant."

Additionally, the text below the second image provides more context: "PATRONAGE DE 'LA BELLEVILLOISE' Excursion à Verrières - 7 Juillet 1907," which means "Support of 'La Bellevilloise' Excursion to Verrières - July 7, 1907."

The postcard includes the publisher's information: "Hélio E. Le Deley, Paris - E. Cordonnier phot., Paris." This suggests that the postcard was created by a photographer named E. Cordonnier and printed by E. Le Deley in Paris. The entire postcard is bordered with a simple white frame.

Anthropic Claude

Created by anthropic.claude-3-haiku-20240307-v1:0 on 2025-06-12

The image appears to be a historical photograph depicting two scenes. The top image shows a large group of people, likely members of a communist organization, gathered together outdoors. The caption below this image reads "Consommation communiste d'oxygène", which translates to "Communist consumption of oxygen".

The bottom image shows a group of people walking along a path through a grassy field. The caption below this image indicates that this is a "Reprise du sol par la peuplade des Bellevillois de Ménilmontant", which means "Reclaiming the land by the people of Belleville in Ménilmontant", and that this was an "Excursion à Verrières" or "Excursion to Verrières" on July 7, 1907.

Overall, the images appear to depict communist or socialist gatherings and activities in the early 20th century.

Created by us.anthropic.claude-3-5-sonnet-20241022-v2:0 on 2025-06-12

This is a historical French photograph from July 7, 1907, showing an excursion to Verrières organized by "La Bellevilloise," which was a cooperative society. The image is composed of two parts:

  1. The top photo shows a large group of people gathered together outdoors, standing in a line. Many are wearing the fashion typical of the early 1900s, including hats and light-colored clothing.

  2. The bottom photo shows a smaller group walking along a path through what appears to be a meadow or field.

The French text includes "Consommation communiste d'oxygène" (Communist consumption of oxygen) and "Reprise du sol par la peuplade des Bellevillois de Ménilmontant" (Reclaiming of the soil by the people of Belleville-Ménilmontant).

This appears to be documentation of a social outing organized by La Bellevilloise, which was one of the first workers' cooperatives in Paris, founded in 1877. These types of excursions were common among working-class organizations of the time, combining leisure activities with social and political consciousness.

Meta Llama

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-90b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-05-24

The image is a vintage black-and-white photograph of a group of people in a field, with a caption in French. The top half of the image shows a large group of people standing in a field, with some holding instruments. The bottom half of the image shows a smaller group of people walking through a field, with a path leading to a wooded area in the background.

Key Features:

  • A large group of people standing in a field
  • Some people are holding instruments
  • A smaller group of people walking through a field
  • A path leading to a wooded area in the background
  • A caption in French at the bottom of the image

Caption:

  • "Consommation communiste d'oxygène" (Communist consumption of oxygen)
  • "Reprise du sol par la peuplade des Bellevillois de Ménilmontant" (Re-taking of the land by the people of Belleville from Ménilmontant)
  • "PATRONAGE DE 'LA BELLEVILLOISE'" (Patronage of "La Bellevilloise")
  • "Excursion à Yerrières - 7 Juillet 1907" (Excursion to Yerrières - July 7, 1907)

Overall:

The image appears to be a historical photograph of a group of people participating in a communist event or activity in a field. The caption suggests that the event was held on July 7, 1907, and was organized by the Patronage de "La Bellevilloise".

Created by us.meta.llama3-2-11b-instruct-v1:0 on 2025-05-24

The image is a vintage black-and-white photograph of two scenes, likely from the early 20th century, possibly in France. The top scene shows a group of people standing in a field, while the bottom scene depicts a group of people walking through a field.

  • Top Scene:
    • A large group of people, possibly a crowd or an audience, is gathered in a field.
    • They are dressed in casual clothing, with some wearing hats and others not.
    • The group appears to be facing the camera, but their expressions are not clear due to the low resolution of the image.
    • The background of the top scene is a dark forest or wooded area, which suggests that the event or gathering may have taken place in a rural setting.
  • Bottom Scene:
    • A smaller group of people is walking through a field, carrying various items such as bags and boxes.
    • The group appears to be moving towards the right side of the image, and their faces are not visible due to the low resolution.
    • The background of the bottom scene is also a field, but it appears to be more overgrown and wild than the top scene.
    • There are trees visible in the distance, which adds to the sense of a rural setting.

Overall, the image suggests that it may have been taken during a rural event or gathering, possibly a festival or celebration. The fact that the group is carrying items such as bags and boxes suggests that they may have been traveling to or from the event.

Amazon Nova

Created by amazon.nova-lite-v1:0 on 2025-05-24

The image is a black-and-white photograph depicting two scenes. The top scene shows a large group of people, mostly children, standing in a grassy field, with trees in the background. The bottom scene shows a group of people walking in a field, with a pole in the center. The photograph has a watermark that reads "Consommation communiste d'oxygène" and "Repris du sol par la peuple des Bellevilles de Ménilmontant." The photograph also has a caption that reads "Patronage de la Bellevilleoise" and "Excursion à Verrières - 7 Juillet 1907."

Created by amazon.nova-pro-v1:0 on 2025-05-24

A black-and-white photo collage shows two different scenes. The top photo shows a group of people standing in a field, some of them wearing hats and shoes, while others are barefoot. They are probably posing for a photo. The bottom photo shows a group of people walking on a grassy field. They are wearing hats and shoes. The field is surrounded by trees and bushes. There is a watermark in the bottom left corner.

Google Gemini

Created by gemini-2.0-flash-lite on 2025-04-29

Here's a description of the image:

This is a black and white postcard, divided into two sections. Both sections depict scenes of people outdoors.

Top Section:

  • A large group of people, mostly children, are standing in front of a dense line of trees. Many are dressed in white or light-colored clothing and have hats. There are some adults in the group as well.
  • The caption below the top image reads: "Consommation communiste d'oxygène" (Communist Oxygen Consumption).

Bottom Section:

  • A group of people, including a couple walking together, are walking along a narrow path through a field of tall grass. They are followed by a wagon, possibly containing more people.
  • The caption below this image reads: "Reprise du sol par la peuplade des Bellevillois de Ménilmontant PATRONAGE DE "LA BELLEVILLOISE " Excursion à Verrières - 7 Juillet 1907" (Recapturing the soil by the people of Bellevillois de Ménilmontant PATRONAGE DE "LA BELLEVILLOISE " Excursion to Verrières - July 7, 1907).
  • The image credits the photographer and location: "Hélio, E. Le Deley, Pars - E. Cordonnier, phot., Paris" ( Helio, E. Le Deley, Paris - E. Cordonnier, phot.).

The card is a historical document, possibly advertising a group excursion for children. The title of the top image is a satirical critique of the idea of communism by linking it with an activity that everyone must do: breathing. The bottom image, is a more straightforward description of the children's activity.

Created by gemini-2.0-flash on 2025-04-29

Here is a description of the image:

This black and white photograph from 1907 is a postcard with two separate images. The upper image depicts a large group of people, many of whom appear to be children, posing in front of a densely wooded area. They are standing on a grassy hill, and many of the children are holding hats. The caption reads "Consommation communiste d'oxygène".

The lower image shows a group of people walking along a narrow dirt path through a field of tall grass. Trees can be seen in the background. The group includes both adults and children, some of whom are carrying items. The caption reads "Reprise du sol par la peuplade des Bellevillois de Ménilmontant", followed by "PATRONAGE DE "LA BELLEVILLOISE"" and "Excursion à Verrières - 7 Juillet 1907". The photographer is credited as "Hélio E. Le Deley, Pars - E. Cordonnier, phot, Paris".

Mistral Pixtral

Created by us.mistral.pixtral-large-2502-v1:0 on 2025-05-25

The image is a vintage postcard featuring two black-and-white photographs from an event organized by "La Bellevilloise," a cooperative society in Paris, France. The event is an excursion to Verrières that took place on July 7, 1907.

Top Photograph:

  • The top photograph shows a large group of people gathered outdoors. The group appears to be composed of men, women, and children, all dressed in early 20th-century attire. The people are standing in rows, with some seated on the ground in front. The setting is a grassy area with a dense forest in the background.
  • The caption beneath the photograph reads "Consommation communiste d'oxygène," which translates to "Communist consumption of oxygen," likely a humorous or ironic reference to the group enjoying fresh air in the countryside.

Bottom Photograph:

  • The bottom photograph depicts a smaller group of people walking along a narrow dirt path through a grassy field. The path is bordered by tall grass and leads towards a wooded area. The people are dressed similarly to those in the top photograph, suggesting they are part of the same excursion.
  • The caption beneath this photograph reads "Reprise du sol par la peuplade des Bellevillois de Ménilmontant," which translates to "The land reclaimed by the people of Belleville and Ménilmontant." This could be a playful or symbolic reference to the group's connection to their neighborhoods in Paris.

Additional Information:

  • The postcard is printed by "Hélio. E. Le Deley, Paris" and the photograph is credited to "E. Gondoinier, phot."
  • The text at the bottom of the postcard reads "PATRONAGE DE 'LA BELLEVILLOISE' Excursion à Verrières - 7 Juillet 1907," indicating that the event was organized by the patronage of La Bellevilloise and took place on July 7, 1907.

Overall, the postcard captures a moment from a community outing, showcasing the social and recreational activities of the time.

Text analysis

Amazon

Bellevillois
Menilmontant
peuplade
communiste
BELLEVILLOISE"
d'oxygene
Excursion
PATRONAGE
Juillet
DE
des
Consommation
de
PATRONAGE DE LA
du sol par la peuplade des Bellevillois de Menilmontant
sol
Deley,
la
Cordonnier.
LA
Paris
du
Paris Cordonnier. phot
par
Verrieres -
Excursion a Verrieres - Juillet 1907
phot
1907
Le
Helio.
Par s E. Deley, Le
Par s
a
E.

Google

Consommation communiste d'oxygène Reprise du sol par la peuplade des Bellevillois de Ménilmontant PATRONAGE DE c LA BELLEVILLOISE " Excursion à Verrières - 7 Juillet 1907 OleH E Le Deley, Par s E. Cordonnier, phot, Paris
Consommation
communiste
d'oxygène
Reprise
du
sol
par
la
peuplade
des
Bellevillois
de
Ménilmontant
PATRONAGE
DE
c
LA
BELLEVILLOISE
"
Excursion
à
Verrières
-
7
Juillet
1907
OleH
E
Le
Deley,
Par
s
E.
Cordonnier,
phot,
Paris